Growers Torn On Court’s Illegal Immigration Ruling

Greenhouse floriculture is torn over the Supreme Court’s ruling last month that upheld an Arizona law imposing sanctions against businesses that hire illegal immigrants.

In a GreenhouseGrower.com poll taken over the last week, 42 percent of those polled say they “absolutely agree” with the Supreme Court’s decision. Another 29.5 percent say they “absolutely do not” agree with the ruling, with 10.2 percent indicating they “somewhat agree,” 12.5 percent indicating they “don’t really agree” and 5.8 percent indicating they aren’t sure what to think.

As one anonymous reader wrote on GreenhouseGrower.com: “This law does not cover the main issue of illegal immigration. This law is just a patch to the whole system. The courts and legislatures do not know how to solve the problem and are using the E-verify to save face.”

Another reader shared a similar assessment: “I agree the illegal alien situation needs to be addressed. However, the answer is not to penalize the landscape, nurseries and garden centers, but to give these aliens some sort of legal-working status. The groups that push this issue obviously don’t realize there are very few American-born citizens that will do these jobs. Plus, the workers who are American citizens will be on unemployment when the businesses are forced to close.”

For more feedback from GreenhouseGrower.com readers, check out our original . Readers can also weigh in by taking last week’s poll and sharing their perspective on the ruling with Greenhouse Grower Editor Delilah Onofrey and Managing Editor Kevin Yanik.

Leave a Reply

10 comments on “Growers Torn On Court’s Illegal Immigration Ruling

  1. This is not that completed, workers go to the us consulate with a invitation to work from employer, they apply for work visa , with annual renewal base on performance. Committee a crime send them back, good employee and a citizen gets a renewal visa for another year. They pay taxes and homeland security knows exactly where they live and work.

  2. We have had some Wonderful Talented Devoted People work for us before all the Illegal Alien Situation came up. Everyone in this buisness knows how hard it is to get people to stay and work hard. Alot walk out the first day. Will not work for the kind of money that is payed in this Career Choice. We need to have a Legal Working Status . Keep the others Drug runners out. They won,t work anyway.

  3. I’m so tired of nearly every Republican politician (many Democrats too), blaming all the problems of this country on the backs of those laboring in our greenhouses and fields. I can’t remember having any college kid or for that matter high school dropout or graduate EVER apply for a job doing this type of work! We depend on these hardworking folks to keep produce cheap and plentiful. If they’ve broken no laws give them a path to citizenship……that’s all any of our ancestors came to this nation to achieve. It’s time to face reality and get off the scapegoat bandwagon!

  4. Bad,Bad,Bad, and worse. Hiring illegals only promotes a sick culture that does not value laws, morals etc. I have been in the industry for over 35 years and have seen how it erodes values. We need a workable system of immigration, but how can we have one with the dingbats in D.C.that are clueless. If they(the dingbats) had to run a business they would be bankrupt, OH THEY ARE. Solution enforcable laws. Start enforcing and there will be fewer offenders both employers and immigrants.

  5. Why do illegals come here? For jobs and a better way of life. If our worthless politicians can’t fix the problem because they’re afraid to then maybe the industries that hire them will have to. Don’t hire illegals then force the government to put a program in place that allows people who want to work to get legal status, a year at a time, pay taxes and give them a road to permenant status. The flow of illegals will stop or at least slow down if there are no easily obtainable jobs. I can remember back in my younger days, I’m 61, the brocero, spelled wrong, program. It worked. People from other countries would come in, get a work permit, green card, register with an employer and go to work. The government knew where they were, the employees wouldn’t run when the border patrol drove up and there were plenty of jobs and workers to fill them. The system worked. Politicians can’t fix problems because they’re careers mean to much to them and their careers are dependant on getting re-elected. They’re afraid of pissing someone off.

  6. Your so tired of republicans??? That’s a good partisan line. It’s not about scapegoating it’s about enforcing the current laws, that were already in place. That’s the opinion of most americans, not just republicans.

  7. I think it is morally important to obey the laws that are in place even when I don’t agree with them. So who is opposed to having a reasonable process for foreigners to gain legal status to obtain a job in the US? To pass and uphold laws that make it illegal to hire an “illegal alien” at the same time as having laws that make is unreasonably difficult to gain legal status to work appears to be a covert method of preventing competition for jobs. I suppose it would not be very popular to come right out and say that is the reason for these laws. I wonder how many of the legislators and judges in place today would have been born in other parts of the world if we had these same policies 100 years ago. Most of the current citizens of this country are here because we or our ancestors had reasonable opportunity to gain legal citizenship. Why do we feel it is right to deny the same opportunities to others?

  8. Native born Americans will not do these jobs. In over thirty years, not one has ever applied for a job in my farm. I provide health insurance, a great working environment, pay overtime, follow all labor laws. Even with the current unemployment rates, there is no native born American citizens asking for a job here. Who is going to harvest our food, work in our factories, build our homes etc., if we don’t have immigrant workers who are more than willing to do these jobs that Americans won’t do?

  9. Shoot let’s all just quit our jobs and look forward to our Nanny Socialist State’s next handout. If American born citizens are entitled to handouts then why not? As our society becomes more reliant on Uncle Sam to take care of it’s citizens needs ( and go further into debt ) we can all sit back and ask ourselves why our Chinese Overlords (own the most U.S. debt of any county in the world ) are taking over the world one dollar store item at a time. This country use to be great because of the lack of government intervention, and hard work Americans put in. More government does not make a country great. It simply binds the whole ability of the nation to move forward. Now our nation’s citizens feel entitled to not have to work hard because there are others to do this work. Well take away those willing to work and what do we have? NOTHING that’s what we have. Let’s all sit back and enjoy the slow demise of what use to be a great nation. this country – why…..because we can!

  10. Let me just say that all businesses should be using E verify to check the legal status of their employees. That being the case it is also clear that the current system for acquiring work visas is inadequate. I guess a better way to put it is that it just takes too much work. The truth is we have hispanic people stopping by nearly everyday asking for work. There is no need to fill out forms to acquire the temporary help (employees with visas) we need. Why would an employer jump through hoops to get an employee when plenty just show up? By requiring E Verify and placing sanctions on those who hire illegals it will drive our industry to slog through the mess required to get the help we need. Furthermore, native born Americans will do the work required… they just won’t do it for minimum wage, and want to get unemployment during the time they aren’t needed. I personally grew up in an agricultural area where there wasn’t an abundant (over abundant) hispanic population. I worked as a landscaper, in a nursery, as a roofer, as well as detassled corn and I recall only having one hispanic coworker in all the crews I was a part of. The work was seasonal but I was young and it payed well compared to being a fry cook. If you don’t agree just look at the Dutch! Rather than overwhelm the system with underpaid, unskilled, temporary workers they improve efficiency by mechanizing processes where feasible and hiring young unskilled labor when absolutely necessary.

More From Labor...
Aquaponics At Brogue Hydroponics

March 30, 2015

10 Things You Need To Know About Aquaponics

Are you curious about expanding into aquaponics? From pest control to equipment, Bob and Jesse Kilgore of Brogue Hydroponics offer 10 factors you need to consider.

Read More
Aquaponics At Brogue Hydroponics

March 30, 2015

Aquaponics Is Making A Splash At Brogue Hydroponics

The owners of Brogue Hydroponics explain why they expanded into aquaponics, and how the shift has helped them uncover a new market opportunity.

Read More
Hendriks-Half-Open-Roof_GGS

March 26, 2015

10 Greenhouse Products For First-Rate Growing Environments

From coverings to fork-lifts, greenhouse suppliers offer a variety of products to make growing easier. Check out the slideshow to learn more about these, plus several other products that can offer you value, versatility and durability.

Read More
Latest Stories

March 18, 2015

H-2B Situation Goes From Bad To Even Worse

On March 5, the Department of Labor (DOL) announced that it will no longer accept or process H-2B labor certifications or requests for H-2B prevailing wage determinations in light of a March 4 decision. Shortly after the DOL announcement, the Department of Homeland Security's (DHS) Citizenship and Immigration Services followed suit, announcing it will at least temporarily cease approving visa petitions. These announcements essentially shut down the H-2B program for any company that has not completed the DHS H-2B visa petitioning process.

Read More
american-hort-logo

March 4, 2015

H-2B Cap Hit, Adding to Visa Program Woes

The H-2B visa cap for the first half of fiscal 2015 was hit late in January. As a result, some growers may not have access to the H-2B workers they need during the months ahead. The visa cap and resulting labor shortages will have impacts throughout the horticulture industry.

Read More

December 9, 2014

Immigration — Obama Acts Without Congress

On November 20, President Obama announced a series of executive actions on immigration policy, which are already proving to be politically divisive, and many Republican legislators say this unilaterally "poisons the well" for reform. In AmericanHort's view, that dire prediction need not be the case.

Read More
USDA Logo

November 17, 2014

USDA Names First Liaison For Veterans Interested In Agr…

The new Military Veterans Agricultural Liaison position will coordinate ongoing USDA support for active duty military and veterans.

Read More

September 26, 2014

GROW Perspective: Government Compliance Issues On The H…

Lack of focus on human resources can sink your ship

Read More

September 26, 2014

Great Things In Store For North Creek Nurseries

With a brand new greenhouse in the works and lean flow manufacturing boosting its bottom line, North Creek Nurseries ventures into a new era of growing for its customers.

Read More

September 11, 2014

Is Lean Flow The Competitive Edge You Need?

If you’re feeling worked to the bone, cramped for space or starved for profits, now is the time to look into lean flow.

Read More

July 22, 2014

Proposed Worker Protection Standard Changes You Need To…

The comment period for the proposed Worker Protection Standards ends on August 18, 2014. Find out how the proposed changes will affect your greenhouse operation.

Read More
Laura Drotleff

July 8, 2014

Consider Hiring Non-Traditional Growers To Secure Our I…

Your operation can benefit from hiring returning veterans, professionals changing careers and non-traditional students, in addition to horticulture graduates. Where have you had luck recruiting?

Read More
SAF Congressional Action Days 2014

February 20, 2014

Healthcare Law, Immigration Reform Are Top Priorities F…

The event, being held March 10-11 in Washington D.C., will bring together horticulture industry members to lobby members of Congress to revisit legislation that is important to the industry.

Read More
E-Verify

October 14, 2013

E-Verify Website Down During Government Shutdown

Recent visitors to the E-Verify website came face-to-face with the same message they see on other government sites: Closed.

Read More
Robin Siktberg

April 19, 2013

Speaking With One Voice On Immigration Reform (Opinion)

I am from a family that holds widely divergent political views that are hotly debated at gatherings. My mother was once chairwoman of our county’s Republican committee, and my father cast his first presidential vote for for Franklin Roosevelt. My husband and I have agreed not to put political signs in our yard — ever — because they would just cancel each other out. You get the picture. So, it was with a great deal of interest that I attended the Society of American Florists (SAF) Congresssional Action Days in March to see government in action. I’d been to Washington before, but only as a bystander, never as a participant. Despite the cliffs and sequesters, I still believe the process works — maybe not as well as we’d like right now, but more than ever, we, as citizens, need to make our voices heard. The briefings before the event and […]

Read More

April 16, 2013

Agriculture Agrees on Immigration Package

The struggle to achieve immigration reform took a giant step forward late Friday, when an agreement was finally reached on the framework for agriculture’s portion of the comprehensive immigration bill. The Senate “Gang of Eight” is drafting the bill, which may be introduced as early as Tuesday. “Society of American Florist (SAF) members who attended Congressional Action Days (CAD) and helped lobby for immigration reform can feel proud of their work,” says SAF’s Lin Schmale. “Keeping Congressional attention focused on floriculture’s needs will continue to be of critical importance. We are delighted that the negotiators have reached agreement, and commend them on achieving what is truly a great success!” After weeks of often very intense negotiations, agreement was reached Friday between the Agriculture Workforce Coalition (AWC), of which SAF is a member, the United Farm Workers (UFW) and the key senators involved in the process, on the details of agriculture’s […]

Read More

March 7, 2013

Anyone Can Automate [opinion]

Automation of production lines and greenhouses is typically thought of as something that is only an option for bigger growers, but that's not necessarily the case. Greenhouse Grower presents some realistic automation options for every size of operation.

Read More

February 22, 2013

Common Objections To Mechanization In The Greenhouse

The first thing I would say about automation is start somewhere. Even if you go with any type of sprinkler or overhead irrigation system that is stationary and not a boom system, start somewhere. Get your feet wet. Get comfortable with the fact that you are starting to rely more on machines and not people. One of the biggest hurdles we have is with small and medium size growers. They will say, “It’s going to make my growers lazy.” My response to that is, “At the end of the day, that’s a management problem. That’s not an equipment problem.” What you need to worry about when you get new machinery is making sure everyone understands why you are buying machinery. If the boom systems or any automated overhead irrigation systems are making your growers lazy, that’s not because of the grower. That’s because the grower is worried about his job. […]

Read More
SAF Members Bring Flower Power To Capitol Hill

February 22, 2013

Immigration Reform To Help Greenhouse Labor Issues

Right now The Society of American Florists is getting ready for Congressional Action Days. We ask our members to fly into Washington, D.C., and travel around the Hill, meeting with their specific members of Congress about the issues we think are most important to the industry right now. It gives our members an opportunity to carry their messages to their members of Congress. This is really important because you can say anything in Washington as a lobbyist, but it has to be backed up by the people out there running businesses. We are grateful for the people who come in and carry that message around the Hill. It is also a great opportunity for business owners to connect with their members of Congress. Lobbying For Immigration Issues One of the issues we will be taking to the Hill this year, as we have for the past ten or more years, […]

Read More

February 8, 2013

A Day In The Life Of Lobbying For Floriculture

ANLA’s Craig Regelbrugge is fighting for floriculture. As ANLA’s vice president for government relations and co-chair for the Agriculture Coalition For Immigration Reform, Regelbrugge is on the front line working toward policies that benefit our industry, such as immigration reform. So what’s his day like? Here’s a report from Washington D.C. on a day in the life of Craig Regelbrugge.  You can do your part by attending and supporting events like SAF’s Congressional Action Days, March 11-12, 2013, in Washington D.C. Here’s Regelbrugge’s report: After four years of trying to get a large boulder rolling uphill, there is motion and momentum. Now, it’s about directing that motion. And sustaining the momentum. Let me give you a quick ‘day-in-the-life’ description of the daily grind, and a few thoughts about the road ahead. • I awoke yesterday to a ‘Marketplace’ interview on NPR of Colorado Senator Michael Bennet. He’s one of the […]

Read More

February 8, 2013

The State Of Labor In The Greenhouse Industry

Ask any grower for thoughts on the state of labor today and you are bound to get an earful. While some people blame government crackdowns on immigration, others point the finger at lazy, over privileged Americans who would prefer not to get their hands dirty. But, there is one thing everyone agrees on: It isn’t getting any better. Although organizations like the American Nursery & Landscape Association (ANLA) and Society of American Florists (SAF) lobby year after year in favor of reforms to make it easier to hire foreign-born workers, the process is a slow one, and growers can’t afford to be shorthanded during peak production times. Some companies have implemented mechanization or automation to fill their employee gaps and lower payroll costs. Technology presents a viable option for those able to achieve a timely return on investment; however, it is easy to overinvest and rack up unnecessary debt. Operations […]

Read More