Nursery Service Program Review

Over the last six to eight years, third-party nursery service has developed extensively in the mass market arena, particularly at The Home Depot and Lowe’s. More recently, as in this year, Wal-Mart also has begun to test the concept in select markets and will be studying the results to see if the program bears expanding, maintaining or is deemed unnecessary.

The great debate begins as to why programs such as these would be necessary. After all, doesn’t it seem logical that mega-retailers are much more capable logistically of efficiently hiring and training staff to order, maintain and merchandise live goods? Apparently, the answer is they are more than capable of doing this, but it’s obviously more easily said than done.

Massive store growth amongst Wal-Mart, The Home Depot and Lowe’s has contributed to a talent shortage of live goods experts in their stores at this time. This is not to imply that many of their stores do not have high-performing, expert individuals that can drive business, but I know from my own experience in 15 years at The Home Depot that this was much less the case in 2005 than it was in 1995. Early in the ‘90s, almost every store Home Depot opened had experienced garden experts from the nursery industry to run these departments. This was easy when there were 50 to 100 stores, not 300 to 400 stores.

These high-performing individuals could make a huge, quantifiable difference in same-store sales versus similar volume stores in the same market without such individuals. When I say huge, I mean in the hundreds of thousands of dollars in live goods sales. This is not to mention all the related high-margin goods that will accompany these sales. These folks made the retail shopping experience exciting for the consumer. They created a sense of urgency in the shopper that would keep them guessing about what would be on display on their next trip into the stores.

Folks like these would be or are horrified with the current service formats. They feel they have lost control of the ability to be entrepreneurs in driving their store’s business and in most cases they have, particularly with pay-by-scan programs. The problem seems to be that there were less of these talented and specialized folks populating these retail outlets and mega-retailers were forced to be pro-active about maximizing the ability to merchandise this perishable live goods category properly. 

Service Program Selection

Service programs come in several formats. In the first format, the live goods suppliers provide their own service for their own products. This method is the current standard for most bedding plant suppliers who are selling to mass market retailers. It is by no means new and was initially developed in the Sunbelt markets right along with guaranteed sale programs on mainly color products. Service became necessary for the suppliers to protect their profits.

This method of service program really mushroomed with the onset of single-source suppliers of annuals into big box stores. Going back some years, most retailers would buy selective products from different growers in an effort to "cherry-pick" the best product mix and quality at any given time. If multiple vendors had service programs, this would create territorial battles at the retail stores with survival of the fittest (or craftiest) winning the retail square footage battle.

This is the preferred method of service program in today’s retail pay-by-scan environment. It seems to make a lot of sense that if you, as a supplier, own the inventory and are responsible for its maintenance, that you would have your own folks on staff to make sure product is merchandised and maintained properly.

Suppliers who provide this type of service basically have either built it into the cost of the plants to the retailer or they are able to bill out separately for services provided while maintaining more competitive costing on the live plants they are providing at retail.

Now that these types of programs are well entrenched across retail, many of the suppliers who provide the services (particularly pay-by-scan suppliers) are looking to expand or extend product mix to more effectively leverage the costs of these programs across their enterprise. Some bedding plant suppliers now are considering supplying and servicing woody ornamentals in some big boxes. 

Third-Party Service

The next main service format is third-party service providers. These would include such entities as Stinchcomb Associates, ICS, RPS and Quick Turn to name several. This type of program is either funded centrally by the retailer or jointly by live goods suppliers contributing to a revenue pool, or even some combination of both. Typically these service providers will service woody ornamentals including trees and shrubs. They may be involved with perennials and tropicals in some cases around the country or with certain retailers. They also will provide the service for the bedding plant categories.

This program, while not intending to displace what passes for nursery help in the stores today, by and large has become just that from my viewpoint based on in-store visits mainly in the Northeast part of the country this spring. One of the inherent problems with any service provider in mass retail today is the threat of store personnel assuming that these providers are the sole source of service provided for these categories. Instead of having a synergistic effect that could possibly take the retailer to new heights, service providers are sorely tested to perform at high levels with limited resources.

The problem here is one of simple mathematics. The revenue pool available currently without building too much into the cost of these plants may allow 20 to 40 hours per store per week only in the busiest of seasons such as April and May. Effectively merchandising these departments would take a minimum of 200 hours per week, in my opinion. This includes merchandising, signing, unloading and packing out and watering. There is a huge variance in what is provided and what is needed to be performing at high levels. Retailers who aren’t aware of this gap are suffering from poor customer perception. Store operations can either work as partners and greatly enhance these relationships or can be narrow-minded about the category and limit their current and future potential, and worst of all, lose market share for their retail site.

From my history, a retail buyer or manager will never be completely satisfied with the performance of third-party service providers, no matter how hard they may try. Suppliers who may be funding either fully or partially are also typically very hard to please and seem to always have some type of contentious relationship with these providers. It has to do with feeling like "you’re getting your moneys worth." Quite often they do and there are many times when they don’t.

Store service programs look like they are here to stay. Retail presentation has radically improved, in most cases as a result of these programs. Big box retailers can have their cake and eat it, too, if they convince their operators at store level to partner with these providers and not defer everything about the program to them. My vision as a Home Depot merchant was to have the service provider execute many (not all) of the tasks at hand in unpacking plants off of racks and on to tables, signing the product and perhaps watering the plants. At the same time, my belief was that all of the displaced hours injected into the system would lead to the most unbelievable customer service ever provided with apron-wearing associates literally swarming over the customers. Unfortunately, this was not the case in the majority of situations. If this tide can be changed, then and only then will the independent garden centers have anything to worry about.

Leave a Reply

More From Marketing...

April 26, 2016

“Bee-Friendly” Labels Matter To Plant Consumers, According To Study

Research at Michigan State University shows ornamental plant buyers understand and respond to bee-friendly production practices.

Read More
Krause Berry Farms Farm To Table Dinner

April 20, 2016

What The Floriculture Industry Can Learn From Farm Marketers (And Vice Versa)

Although we have a lot in common with the produce industry, there is much we can learn from one another.

Read More
Costa Farms Container Ideas E-Book

April 12, 2016

Costa Farms Targets Consumers With New Container Gardening E-Book

The electronic book offers tips on container selection, design, and plant care for millennials looking to grow in small spaces.

Read More
Latest Stories

April 26, 2016

“Bee-Friendly” Labels Matter To Plant Consumers, Accord…

Research at Michigan State University shows ornamental plant buyers understand and respond to bee-friendly production practices.

Read More
Krause Berry Farms Farm To Table Dinner

April 20, 2016

What The Floriculture Industry Can Learn From Farm Mark…

Although we have a lot in common with the produce industry, there is much we can learn from one another.

Read More
Costa Farms Container Ideas E-Book

April 12, 2016

Costa Farms Targets Consumers With New Container Garden…

The electronic book offers tips on container selection, design, and plant care for millennials looking to grow in small spaces.

Read More
Tropical Fruit Tree Selection (Hopkins Tropical Fruit Nursery)

April 7, 2016

University Of Florida Research Shows Consumers Value Lo…

Compared to conventional plants, consumers reported a higher purchasing likelihood for certified organic or organically produced fruit plants.

Read More
Random Acts Of Flowers

March 31, 2016

The Floriculture Industry Needs A Unified Message To Pr…

Seeing the sneak preview of the new varieties that will be presented at California Spring Trials (CAST) spurs a visceral reaction in me. I’m giddy and excited about these gorgeous plants, having taken in some of their beauty and excellent performance already at Costa Farms’ Season Premier. I’m excited to travel to Spring Trials and that spring is coming, and I’m ready to dig in and get gardening. I’m guessing many of you feel the same way. And it’s likely that consumers do, too. Nearly a year ago, upon returning from California Spring Trials, I lamented the absence of ideas translated from CAST to retail. The beautiful displays, the breathtaking combinations, the clever marketing — somehow, all of that effort and enthusiasm focused on business-to-business promotion is not being funneled effectively to the consumer. As an industry, we are not good at working together to market our products in a clear, […]

Read More
Sakata Seed America President David Armstrong

March 30, 2016

Sakata Signs Agreement With Indonesian Government To Co…

This week, Sakata Seed Corp. announced internationally that it has signed an agreement with the Republic of Indonesia to cooperate in the further development and production of its line of SunPatiens interspecific hybrid impatiens, based on the principles of the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). Under an agreement based on the CBD, Sakata Seed has worked with the Indonesian government since the early 2000s to identify the origin of the native germplasm collected in Indonesia to develop SunPatiens, and the two parties have agreed on how the indigenous genetic resources will be used for the further development of SunPatiens. There are currently only a few cases in the world of such an agreement, based on the CBD in the category of horticultural plants, made between a resource-rich country and a commercial seed company. Greenhouse Grower contacted Sakata Seed CEO David Armstrong to provide context about this agreement, what it means […]

Read More
NGI-SunPatiens-Compact-Hot-Coral-Sakata

March 23, 2016

P. Allen Smith Says SunPatiens Are Hero Plants For Cons…

Plants that ensure consumer success with disease resistance bred into their genetics, and ease of use in a variety of conditions, are heroes for gardeners, especially beginners, and they should be celebrated and supported to promote gardening success and interest. These are the messages the award-winning designer, gardening, and lifestyle expert P. Allen Smith wants the horticulture industry to know, with the recent announcement of his expanded partnership with Sakata Seed. In an exclusive interview with Greenhouse Grower, P. Allen Smith describes his expanded partnership with Sakata Seed to promote SunPatiens and why the now 10-year-old series helps both novice and expert gardeners to be successful. Smith also collaborates with Sakata to promote the HomeGrown Collection of vegetables. SunPatiens Set Consumers Up For Success, Smith Says As a plantsman first, Smith has extensively trialed SunPatiens in his gardens at Moss Mountain Farm in Little Rock, AR, and says he is […]

Read More
Suzanne McKee

March 18, 2016

4 Pitfalls To Avoid With Responsive Web Design

When implementing responsive design on your website, sidestep these common problems with some advance planning.

Read More
1 800 Flowers Instagram Women's Day

March 15, 2016

Society Of American Florists Uses Social Media To Take …

SAF strategically promoted five key Facebook posts to expand its reach beyond its followers and prominently featured Women’s Day on its other consumer channels.

Read More
Mason Day Great Plant Debate Campaign For GrowIt!

March 3, 2016

GrowIt! App Founders Look To Make Waves At The Chicago …

Mason Day and Seth Reed will hold a “Great Plant Debate” at the event, while updating the GrowIt! app with information on every plant featured at the show.

Read More

February 26, 2016

How To Recruit Loyal Customers With Facebook

Facebook is a powerful engagement tool that when used effectively can help you attract and retain faithful customers.

Read More
Greenhouse Vegetable Marketing

February 18, 2016

9 Tips To Maximize Your Greenhouse Vegetable Market Pot…

Set yourself apart by sizing up your competition, evaluating your demographics, and putting customers first.

Read More
GrowIt! Logo

February 9, 2016

GrowIt! And MasterTag Partner To Enhance Plant Care Inf…

The partnership allows MasterTag to provide plant care instructions to the wide catalog of plants available on GrowIt!, which helps consumers find plants in their area.

Read More

January 27, 2016

Costa Farms’ Season Premier Provides Sneak Peek A…

Costa Farms presented the 2016 Season Premier at its 2-acre Trial Gardens in Miami, FL, in the third week of January. The event showcases varieties from breeders of all sizes to growers and major retail buyers, providing a look at what genetics are coming to the market and how they’ll perform in retail settings and in the landscape, when consumers bring them home. The mild winter climate in South Florida allows Costa Farms’ Research and Development Department to simulate the spring growing conditions of various regions in the country. Because each group of visitors to Costa Farms’ Trial Gardens wants to see what the new plants look like in the environments that matter to them, Season Premier offers several areas within the Trial Gardens that highlight different ways to look at the wealth of new varieties. The New Product Showcase offers a way for retailers to see how plants will […]

Read More

January 26, 2016

Beekenkamp And Danziger Partner To Distribute Poinsetti…

Danziger is continuing to expand its portfolio of products to the U.S. market with the addition of poinsettia cuttings of Beekenkamp’s varieties.

Read More
Houseplant Featured Image

January 21, 2016

How To Improve Consumer Interest In Indoor Foliage Plan…

Researchers discover why there is decreasing consumer demand for indoor foliage plants and suggest ways to overcome hurdles to purchasing.

Read More
Bee On Flower

December 29, 2015

Scotts Miracle-Gro To Fund 50 Pollinator Gardens In 201…

In an effort to help combat the loss of pollinator habitats in recent years, the Scotts Miracle-Gro Co. announced plans in mid-December for a year-long effort to improve consumer education about pollinators and promote the creation of backyard and urban habitats where they can thrive. The “Pollinator Promise” will fund the establishment of at least 50 pollinator gardens throughout the U.S. in 2016, as part of the company’s GRO1000 community gardening initiative. The GRO1000 initiative, now in its sixth year, partners with the U.S. Conference of Mayors, the Pollinator Stewardship Council, The Franklin Park Conservatory, and others, to promote the availability of additional grants for gardens and green spaces throughout the country. “The importance of pollinators is unquestionable and it is easier than most people think to create a habitat where they can thrive,” says Jim King, Senior Vice President of Corporate Affairs at Scotts Miracle-Gro. “The Pollinator Promise is […]

Read More
Viraj Puri (left) and Eric Hadley (right) of Gotham Greens with Martha Stewart (middle)

December 17, 2015

Congratulations To The 2015 Martha Stewart American Mad…

Each year, Martha Stewart and the editors of Martha Stewart Living honor American entrepreneurs and small business owners for their dedication to producing innovative, high-quality products. This year, three companies from the green industry made the list.

Read More
[gravityform id="35" title="false" description="false"]