Gardening Industry Not Recovering as Much From Recent Recession as in Past

Ian Baldwin
Ian Baldwin

Note: The following is the latest blog posting by garden retail industry consultant Ian Baldwin. It was originally posted on Sept. 21, 2017.

It’s been a busy summer of travel, conferences, and clients, which makes now the perfect time to ask: “How was the garden retail business for you in 2017?”

I was guilty as charged in being distinctly bullish about prospects for a banner year this year. The economy is firing better for most (though not all) people than it has done for years. We see a soaring stock market, rising household income, and talk of a $1,000 cell phone. Landscapers and housing contractors are sold out for months (years in Utah, so I am told), while there is just enough inflation around to encourage some much-needed price raises.

It should have been a banner year, just like 2016 should have been, too. But neither year reached the expectations of retailers that I know. I see reports that one of the home centers is up 6% in sales across the board, but much of that was contractor-driven. Meanwhile, plant and hard goods suppliers I know say it was just so-so.

Two Steps Up, Two or More Back

Most independent garden grower-retailers saw a modest 2% to 5% rise in sales, but a smaller or flat traffic count with a compensating rise in average sale, just like the last 15 years. But rises in sales were largely due to the price rises that I (and others) urged retailers to adopt. Given the ever-rising costs of business, some might even say they went backwards despite an increase in the top line sales. Yes, it was a poor weather year for many, but there has always been weather — this is something else.

So I am officially declaring that for the first time in my lifetime, the do-it-yourself (DIY) garden business hasn’t surged after a recession — and it’s not going to under the current model. There has been such a fundamental change in the consumer’s lifestyle and demographics since 1983, 1990, or 1999 that history is not a good guide here. What worked for the last 45 years isn’t working.

Let’s Analyze Before We Strategize

Before we deconstruct, let’s hear what happened from the trenches — your trenches. I have good data that shows the DIY sales leaders this year were such categories as indoor plants, (green and/or blooming), succulents, edibles, pottery, personal (think purses, jewelry, apparel, etc.), and self-indulgences (everything from big blousy hydrangeas to Yeti coolers). Meanwhile, normal-sized color was flat and woodies were down significantly in DIY business (unless you have lots of new homes locally).

In other words, consumers decorated a lot — but didn’t dig much.

So, how was it for you? What were your category winners and losers? Did you see decorating as a major revenue stream and invest in it, or were your buyers still buying like it’s 1997?

I look forward to hearing from you as we re-construct the garden retail business together.

Go to Ian’s blog page to weigh in with your thoughts.

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

More From Management...
Marijuana-Company-of-America-Cannabis-Greenhouse-Photo

May 24, 2018

New Cannabis Greenhouse in Washington Nears Completion

Once the Marijuana Company of America’s new 30,000 square-foot facility is fully built, it will have the ability to house approximately 4,000 plants.

Read More
Collegiate-Plant-Initiative

May 23, 2018

Collegiate Plant Initiative Helps Foster a Love of Plants Among Students

CPI offers a unique perspective of the plant world, with the goal of connecting college students with exciting plants and teaching them more about opportunities in the plant industry.

Read More
Biocontrols in a Greenhouse

May 22, 2018

Register Now for Award-Winning Online Greenhouse Growing Courses

Learn about production cost and profit, as well as the basic behind plant science, via two online classes being offered by the University of Florida.

Read More
Latest Stories
Marijuana-Company-of-America-Cannabis-Greenhouse-Photo

May 24, 2018

New Cannabis Greenhouse in Washington Nears Completion

Once the Marijuana Company of America’s new 30,000 square-foot facility is fully built, it will have the ability to house approximately 4,000 plants.

Read More
Collegiate-Plant-Initiative

May 23, 2018

Collegiate Plant Initiative Helps Foster a Love of Plan…

CPI offers a unique perspective of the plant world, with the goal of connecting college students with exciting plants and teaching them more about opportunities in the plant industry.

Read More
Biocontrols in a Greenhouse

May 22, 2018

Register Now for Award-Winning Online Greenhouse Growin…

Learn about production cost and profit, as well as the basic behind plant science, via two online classes being offered by the University of Florida.

Read More
Westerlay-Orchids-School-Donation

May 19, 2018

Westerlay Orchids Shows Its Support for Local Schools

Proceeds from all sales the company made during the Carpinteria Greenhouse and Nursery Tour will be donated to fund STEAM (Science, Technology, Engineering, Art, and Math) programs.

Read More

May 18, 2018

Five Education Tracks Set for IGC Show

The event will feature topics such as online sales, store renovations, and more.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

May 17, 2018

Ian Baldwin: Why the Rise of the Under 35s Will Help Yo…

In his latest blog, garden retail consultant Ian Baldwin says this new generation of plant buyers is seriously engaged in gardening, and is using social media to help become successful plant owners.

Read More
Perennial-Plant-Symposium

May 16, 2018

2018 Perennial Plant Symposium Offering Power to the Pe…

Perennial and gardening enthusiasts of all experience levels are invited to attend plant discussions on Monday, July 30 for a chance to hear from the best in the field on a range of topics.

Read More
Growing Innovations conference and tradeshow logo

May 14, 2018

Growing Innovations Geared to Connect Specialty Ag With…

Innovation abounds in agriculture, yet it can feel sometimes as if the gap between exciting new developments and what growers actually need in their operations can be awfully wide. We at Meister Media Worldwide intend to help narrow this gap. Which is why we’re pleased to introduce Growing Innovations – an altogether new type of event that will debut Nov. 7-8 at the Las Vegas Convention Center in Las Vegas, NV. Unlike most agricultural events and trade shows, Growing Innovations is not about technology per se, nor is it about everyday issues that growers face. Instead, this new conference and tradeshow is very acutely solutions oriented. It takes as its starting point specialty crop growers’ most pressing real-world challenges – production efficiency, labor and water shortages, logistics, and data management to name just a few – and showcases advances, both current and up-and-coming, that have the greatest potential to bring […]

Read More
Laura Drotleff

May 8, 2018

Greenhouse Production Costs Keep Going Up, So Why Are P…

There is a general sentiment within the industry that pricing needs to be reevaluated to better account for the trend toward rising input costs.

Read More
2018-Top-100-logo-with-image-feature

May 7, 2018

2018 Greenhouse Grower Top 100 Growers: The Complete Li…

Strong growth among the nation's largest growers shows no signs of slowing down, as nearly a third of the Top 100 growers have significantly expanded production, and many have ongoing projects underway.

Read More
Lean-Event-at-Smith-Gardens-feature

May 3, 2018

How Companies Can Work Together to Solve Problems and B…

Pacific Northwest Lean consortiums show what growers can achieve when they work together to solve problems and improve labor efficiencies.

Read More
Luxflora Networking

May 1, 2018

Luxflora Launches Flourish Funding to Support Women-Led…

The nonprofit, floriculture organization plans to announce its first Initiative winner at Cultivate in July and encourages interested applicants to submit their applications by May 31 to be considered.

Read More
Greenhouse-Space-Tracking

April 27, 2018

Five Keys to Accurate Greenhouse Production Costing

There are several steps you can take to make sure you understand the true costs of running your business.

Read More

April 26, 2018

ForwardGro Advances Medical Cannabis in Maryland With F…

Building on roots in agriculture, this new medical cannabis facility continues to implement process improvement to provide quality medical-grade product for the patients who need it.

Read More
Mucci-Farms

April 24, 2018

Mucci Farms Completes First Phase of its New Ohio Tomat…

The new facility, the company’s first expansion outside of Canada, encompasses 24 acres, with harvest set to begin in May.

Read More
Seed-Your-Future-Initiative-Release-3.3.16-1

April 24, 2018

Bloom Campaign by Seed Your Future Will Address “Plant …

BLOOM! connects young people to the power of plants to build a pipeline of future talent for the industry behind them: horticulture.

Read More
Griffin-Massachusetts-Cannabis-Workshop

April 23, 2018

Griffin Hosting Cannabis Growers Workshop in May

The half-day program in Colorado will focus on several aspects of crop fertility and nutrition delivery strategies.

Read More
AFE-Flower-Marketing-Videos

April 20, 2018

Your Weekly Chance to Market the Positive Vibes That Fl…

Each week between now and the end of the year, American Floral Endowment will post a new video promoting flowers.

Read More