Home Depot Sues Credit Card Companies For Weakening EMV Security

Home Depot logoHome Depot has decided enough is enough. The mass merchant is suing MasterCard and Visa for colluding on interchange rates, which it claims it enforces through a monopoly, and for watering down the effectiveness of EMV chips by not requiring PINs in the U.S.

In the lawsuit (read a PDF of the 140 page document), Home Depot’s lawyers state:

“For years, Visa and MasterCard have been more concerned with protecting their own inflated profits and their dominant market positions than with the security of the payment cards used by American consumers and the health of the United States economy. Visa and MasterCard have pushed consumers to use payment card technology that Visa and MasterCard know is defective and subject to fraud and have colluded with each other and with the banks that issue debit and credit cards to do so. They have also unlawfully fixed at high levels the so-called “interchange” fees that merchants must pay when presented with debit or credit cards. As a result of their conduct, United States consumers experience the highest rates of payment card fraud in the world, and United States businesses are subject to the highest payment card related fees in the world.”

The mass merchant goes on to say that MasterCard and Visa have made price fixing a longstanding practice, and are deliberately trying to undermine the fraud protections EMV can provide to ensure no other competition can enter the U.S. market. If Visa and MasterCard enforced the “chip and PIN” model, it argues, then that opens the playing field to other players. Instead, the credit card giants have allowed “chip and sign,” which opens cards to more fraud.

Here’s how the lawsuit phrases it:

“As noted, because debit transactions arose from the ATM (or PIN-based) networks, debit cards often can have more than one network enabled on a card. Yet Visa and MasterCard have perpetuated a regime in which there is a “signature” option on the front of a debit card (usually Visa or MasterCard), with the “PIN” options relegated to the back of the card. The Home Depot and other major merchants generally prefer to route debit transactions over PIN networks so they can foster competition and have the benefit of lower PIN debit prices and more security. Visa and MasterCard, however, have systematically worked together and with their member banks to prevent merchants from being able to take advantage of these options in a significant way. For years, Visa or MasterCard would simply bribe the banks that issue debit cards to install Visa or MasterCard itself as the sole PIN option on the back of the card, using the inflated interchange fees they generated from their price fixing scheme.”

Home Depot had a security breach in 2014, which put 56 million cards at risk. It has a vested interest in a more secure system. However, this lawsuit is going much further than that. If a PIN system is put into place, Home Depot and all other vendors will have options that may lower the interchange rates.

This will be a case to watch. If Home Depot succeeds, retailers everywhere will benefit.

 

Topics:

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Home Depot Sues Credit Card Companies For Weakening EMV Security

  1. Home Depot Hacked After Months of Security Warnings
    A breach at the home improvement retailer followed months of warnings

    http://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2014-09-18/home-depot-hacked-after-months-of-security-warnings

    http://www.wsj.com/articles/home-depot-hackers-used-password-stolen-from-vendor-1415309282

    http://www.cnet.com/news/home-depot-offers-19m-to-settle-customers-hacking-lawsuit/

    http://www.usnews.com/news/newsgram/articles/2014/11/07/53-million-customer-email-addresses-leaked-in-home-depot-hack

    That’s funny that they cite:

    “For years, Visa and MasterCard have been more concerned with protecting their own inflated profits and their dominant market positions than with the security of the payment cards used by American consumers and the health of the United States economy.”

More From Retailing...

May 18, 2018

Five Education Tracks Set for IGC Show

The event will feature topics such as online sales, store renovations, and more.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

May 17, 2018

Ian Baldwin: Why the Rise of the Under 35s Will Help Your Garden Retail Business

In his latest blog, garden retail consultant Ian Baldwin says this new generation of plant buyers is seriously engaged in gardening, and is using social media to help become successful plant owners.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

April 3, 2018

Ian Baldwin: Why the Roles of Garden Retail Staff May Be Changing

In his latest blog posting, garden retail industry consultant Ian Baldwin says the role of grower-retailers has changed from providing information to validating or correcting what consumers have already learned when browsing online.

Read More
Latest Stories

May 18, 2018

Five Education Tracks Set for IGC Show

The event will feature topics such as online sales, store renovations, and more.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

May 17, 2018

Ian Baldwin: Why the Rise of the Under 35s Will Help Yo…

In his latest blog, garden retail consultant Ian Baldwin says this new generation of plant buyers is seriously engaged in gardening, and is using social media to help become successful plant owners.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

April 3, 2018

Ian Baldwin: Why the Roles of Garden Retail Staff May B…

In his latest blog posting, garden retail industry consultant Ian Baldwin says the role of grower-retailers has changed from providing information to validating or correcting what consumers have already learned when browsing online.

Read More
TREEosk-from-Bower-and-Branch

March 25, 2018

Tree-osk From Bower and Branch Offers Unique Way to Buy…

The Tree-osk, which has become a fixture in several garden centers, provides an interactive consumer experience when buying trees, shrubs, and perennials.

Read More
GCA-Summer-Tour-McAuliffes

March 9, 2018

GCA Announces Complete Seattle Garden Center Summer Tou…

The Garden Centers of America Summer Tour in Seattle will feature visits to some of the most unique plant retailers in the Pacific Northwest.

Read More
Hand-Crafted Stone Mushrooms (Stone-Age Creations)

February 9, 2018

Garden Retailers at TPIE Highlight Their Favorite Produ…

A team of garden retailers once again participated in the 2018 Tropical Plants Industry Expo Cool Product Awards.

Read More

February 6, 2018

Registration for 2018 IGC Show Now Open

The event takes place Aug. 14-16 in Chicago and features keynote presentations from horticultural economist Charlie Hall and Daymond John from the TV series “Shark Tank.”

Read More
Cordyline Candy Cane (Excelsa Gardens, Inc.)

November 14, 2017

Garden-Retailers Pick Their Favorite Products From The …

Grower-retailers have once again named their favorite new products, this time as part of the Cool Product Awards at The Landscape Show 2017 in Orlando, FL. Awards were presented to 12 companies, representing 14 products.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

September 26, 2017

Gardening Industry Not Recovering as Much From Recent R…

In his latest blog posting, garden retail industry consultant Ian Baldwin says changing consumer demographics mean that, unlike past indicators, the garden business hasn’t surged after a recession — and it’s not going to under the current model.

Read More
Hydrangea mac. Fire Island (Monrovia Nursery)

September 19, 2017

Grower-Retailers Pick Their Favorites From Farwest 2017

Members of The Garden Center Group once again named their top selections in both live and hard goods for the Retailers’ Choice Awards at Farwest 2017.

Read More
Trends Slide - No Logo

September 12, 2017

Garden Media Group’s 2018 Trends Report Highlights Natu…

This year’s Garden Trends report offers seven trends that you can use to inspire mental wellness. Take a look to see how many trends you’re already using to connect with your customers.

Read More
GCA Bathroom Winner Wingards Market 1

September 8, 2017

Garden Centers of America Announces Best Bathroom Award…

If you’re a grower-retailer, your restroom may end up being the most important part of your customers’ experience. Find out the big winners of this year’s Garden Centers of America’s Best Bathroom Awards.

Read More

August 29, 2017

7 Popular Retail Trends from the 2017 IGC Show

Almost every type of retail garden product imaginable filled the booths on the tradeshow floor at the 2017 IGC Show held in August in Chicago, from pots and containers to garden tools, patio furniture, and decorative items. Here are seven gardening and product trends that stood out at the show.

Read More

August 21, 2017

50 Cool Products on Display at the 2017 IGC Show

Check out these cool products vendors showed off at the 2017 IGC Show on the Navy Pier in Chicago, August 15-17.

Read More
griffin-expo

August 15, 2017

Griffin Becomes Newest Distributor for Master Nursery G…

The agreement allows Griffin to join Master Nursery’s network of more than 150 supplier partners, while giving Master Nursery access to new product and service options for member businesses in the Midwest, Rocky Mountain, and Pacific Northwest regions.

Read More
Decorative Premium Hanging Baskets (Ainong USA)

July 25, 2017

16 Products That Garden Retailers Loved at Cultivate’17

In what has become an annual tradition at Cultivate, a team of garden retailers presented awards for their picks as the best new products (both live goods and hard goods) from Cultivate’17.

Read More

July 11, 2017

Grower-Retailers Invited to Help Pick Their Favorite Pr…

The Garden Center Group is inviting grower-retailers to join them on their quest to highlight the best new retail products on display at Cultivate’17.

Read More
Hort Couture Farm to Table Display

July 7, 2017

New Marketing and Retail Display Ideas to Boost Your P…

Innovative marketing displays and retail concepts at California Spring Trials 2017, inspired by popular consumer trends and the need to encourage consumer success, overflowed with exciting new ways to promote plants.

Read More