Why Don’t We Know More About Pricing Plants?

Plant Pricing
We’re learning that almost no one calculates plant prices the same way. And few are building a profit into their prices.

If you had to name one thing that determines the financial success of every business in our industry, it’s the obvious: how much we sell plants for.

So imagine my shock when I learned how little research has been done on this. Last fall, as I planned the topics I wanted to devote attention to in 2016 and 2017, plant pricing was at the top of my list.

But I was already committed to the consumer plant marketing research we’re doing with Michigan State University and Flowers Canada in 2016, for our most recent 10% Project (a program we began to help increase plant sales by 10%). So I thought it would be a good idea to have a series of articles reviewing all the research that has already been done, then launch a bigger 10% Project on plant pricing in 2017.

With that in mind, I called Charlie Hall at Texas A&M University.

“Plant pricing research? Let’s see. There’s the study we did with you in 2012 [our first 10% Project — I’ll explain more in a minute], Bridget’s [Behe, Michigan State] eye-tracking studies, and the article you wrote about 4-inch annuals. That’s about all I can think of.”

Wow. Really?

Obviously, much more needs to be done.

Naturally, the plan for 2016 changed quickly. In June, we launched a plant-pricing survey for the industry, including both growers and retailers. Dr. Hall, Dr. Behe, as well as several consultants, Steve Bailey, Sid Raisch, and Ian Baldwin, helped us shape the survey. Since this is the industry’s first pricing survey, we kept it fairly simple.

It covers three main areas: how prices are calculated, how growers and retailers handle sales, and if and when they apply perceived value pricing.

Preliminary Plant-Pricing Results Are In

While we are still analyzing data from the survey, I can share a couple of patterns.

1. There Is No Standard In Pricing. Even with a couple hundred or so answers coming in so far, almost no one calculates prices for plants the same way. For growers, some look at what the competition is doing and either match the price or mark their prices up or down. Others calculate their costs and markup the costs, or calculate a margin. Others pretty much take what the customer will give them. There are dozens of other ways, but some form of those three are fairly common.

2. Profit Isn’t Mentioned As Part Of Pricing. I personally know several grower-retailers who make a profit accidentally. They have a pricing formula, and hope it’s enough for them to come out in the black that year. From the answers I’m reading, these friends are not alone. I haven’t read every single answer yet, but I have read most. Not once is a goal profit mentioned. Or any sort of profit.

For growers who are calculating their prices in part based on their own costs, there’s a lot to learn. What all is included in that cost number? Inputs, labor, overhead? And is that expense added up for the year then divided out in the number of plants sold annually? What about shrink?

For those who are looking at competitors for their pricing, how are those competitors calculating prices? Is this a classic case of lemmings rushing over a cliff?

Why Do Plant Prices Matter?

Plant prices worry just about every industry sage I know. I’ve heard breeders, bankers, growers, and plant retailers talk about how our industry flirts with financial disaster.

The core concern? That no one charges what they need for their plants. When plants are undervalued, a few predictable things happen:

1. There’s no cushion for hard times. Think of all the businesses that failed during the recent recession. Building a cash reserve isn’t being greedy; it’s just making sure you have something to fall back on during those inevitable poor years.

2. Upper level staff and owners work extreme hours. This problem is especially true for the medium and small retailers and growers. Why stress your labor budget when you can work 12 hours a day, seven days a week during the season? Then you wonder why the next generation has zero interest in taking over the family business.

3. Improving your business is treated as a luxury instead of a necessity. Many plant retailers with unimproved structures don’t understand why they’re losing customers. But hoop houses with poor air circulation are an awful place to shop on a sunny day. And who wants to push a cart through gravel when shopping is so much easier elsewhere?

Stay Tuned

We’ll publish results throughout the third quarter of 2016, including in the September print addition of Greenhouse Grower RETAILING. Our game plan is to take the results of this survey and use them as a compass, pointing to the direction we need to go with a much larger study.

As I mentioned earlier, we have conducted one plant pricing study before. It was our very first 10% Project. When the results were in, we learned that plant prices are inelastic and lowering plant prices does not sell more plants — just the opposite, in fact. You can read the full article about the study at http://goo.gl/VRkulT.

Based on what we learn in this 2016 survey, we’ll conduct another large-scale study that may take place in either 2017 or 2018. That study should help us understand what methods of pricing plants actually make a profit.

We’ll share what we learn with you, and we’ll ask various experts to weigh in on the results, too. It’s my hope that, as an industry, we’ll figure out a way to price plants that is not only fair to customers and allows for healthy competition, but will also make the industry financially healthy.

Topics: , , ,

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Why Don’t We Know More About Pricing Plants?

  1. Great that you are embarking on this price study! It’s needed! Is anyone doing a similar study for the wholesaler nursery grower market? We need that too!

More From Retailing...
Cordyline Candy Cane (Excelsa Gardens, Inc.)

November 14, 2017

Garden-Retailers Pick Their Favorite Products From The Landscape Show

Grower-retailers have once again named their favorite new products, this time as part of the Cool Product Awards at The Landscape Show 2017 in Orlando, FL. Awards were presented to 12 companies, representing 14 products.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

September 26, 2017

Gardening Industry Not Recovering as Much From Recent Recession as in Past

In his latest blog posting, garden retail industry consultant Ian Baldwin says changing consumer demographics mean that, unlike past indicators, the garden business hasn’t surged after a recession — and it’s not going to under the current model.

Read More
Hydrangea mac. Fire Island (Monrovia Nursery)

September 19, 2017

Grower-Retailers Pick Their Favorites From Farwest 2017

Members of The Garden Center Group once again named their top selections in both live and hard goods for the Retailers’ Choice Awards at Farwest 2017.

Read More
Latest Stories
Cordyline Candy Cane (Excelsa Gardens, Inc.)

November 14, 2017

Garden-Retailers Pick Their Favorite Products From The …

Grower-retailers have once again named their favorite new products, this time as part of the Cool Product Awards at The Landscape Show 2017 in Orlando, FL. Awards were presented to 12 companies, representing 14 products.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

September 26, 2017

Gardening Industry Not Recovering as Much From Recent R…

In his latest blog posting, garden retail industry consultant Ian Baldwin says changing consumer demographics mean that, unlike past indicators, the garden business hasn’t surged after a recession — and it’s not going to under the current model.

Read More
Hydrangea mac. Fire Island (Monrovia Nursery)

September 19, 2017

Grower-Retailers Pick Their Favorites From Farwest 2017

Members of The Garden Center Group once again named their top selections in both live and hard goods for the Retailers’ Choice Awards at Farwest 2017.

Read More
Trends Slide - No Logo

September 12, 2017

Garden Media Group’s 2018 Trends Report Highlights Natu…

This year’s Garden Trends report offers seven trends that you can use to inspire mental wellness. Take a look to see how many trends you’re already using to connect with your customers.

Read More
GCA Bathroom Winner Wingards Market 1

September 8, 2017

Garden Centers of America Announces Best Bathroom Award…

If you’re a grower-retailer, your restroom may end up being the most important part of your customers’ experience. Find out the big winners of this year’s Garden Centers of America’s Best Bathroom Awards.

Read More

August 29, 2017

7 Popular Retail Trends from the 2017 IGC Show

Almost every type of retail garden product imaginable filled the booths on the tradeshow floor at the 2017 IGC Show held in August in Chicago, from pots and containers to garden tools, patio furniture, and decorative items. Here are seven gardening and product trends that stood out at the show.

Read More

August 21, 2017

50 Cool Products on Display at the 2017 IGC Show

Check out these cool products vendors showed off at the 2017 IGC Show on the Navy Pier in Chicago, August 15-17.

Read More
griffin-expo

August 15, 2017

Griffin Becomes Newest Distributor for Master Nursery G…

The agreement allows Griffin to join Master Nursery’s network of more than 150 supplier partners, while giving Master Nursery access to new product and service options for member businesses in the Midwest, Rocky Mountain, and Pacific Northwest regions.

Read More
Decorative Premium Hanging Baskets (Ainong USA)

July 25, 2017

16 Products That Garden Retailers Loved at Cultivate’17

In what has become an annual tradition at Cultivate, a team of garden retailers presented awards for their picks as the best new products (both live goods and hard goods) from Cultivate’17.

Read More

July 11, 2017

Grower-Retailers Invited to Help Pick Their Favorite Pr…

The Garden Center Group is inviting grower-retailers to join them on their quest to highlight the best new retail products on display at Cultivate’17.

Read More
Hort Couture Farm to Table Display

July 7, 2017

New Marketing and Retail Display Ideas to Boost Your P…

Innovative marketing displays and retail concepts at California Spring Trials 2017, inspired by popular consumer trends and the need to encourage consumer success, overflowed with exciting new ways to promote plants.

Read More

June 19, 2017

IGC Show Features Talks on How to Cash in on the Buy Lo…

This year’s event, which takes place Aug. 15-17 in Chicago, also includes a free workshop on what you might do when starting your business over from scratch.

Read More
Robert O'Neill

May 11, 2017

Former SEAL Team Six Leader to Address Attendees at IGC…

Robert O’Neill is a highly decorated combat veterans and the author of the just-published memoir, “The Operator: Firing the Shots That Killed Osama bin Laden and My Years as a SEAL Team Warrior.”

Read More

April 24, 2017

Ian Baldwin Offers Examples From Grower-Retailers on Pr…

In March, Baldwin wrote a blog advising grower-retailers to consider raising their prices this spring. The post inspired a number of creative suggestions.

Read More
Ian Baldwin

March 31, 2017

Ian Baldwin: Aim High With Your Pricing This Spring

In his latest blog posting, the garden retail consultant says consumers are spending more today, which means it’s a good time to consider raising your prices.

Read More
GCA Summer Tour 2017 Andersons Newport Beach

March 23, 2017

Garden Centers of America Unveils Stops on Its Summer T…

Registration for the event, which includes visits to several garden centers each with their own unique highlights, is now open.

Read More
MSU Guide To Attracting Pollinators

March 9, 2017

New Guide on Bee-Friendly Plants Available From Horticu…

The guide is designed to help grower-retailers educate and motivate their customers to purchase and plant pollinator-friendly materials.

Read More
Grapevine Balls, Glass House, and Galvanized Dish Gardens (Flori-Design, Inc.)

March 6, 2017

Cool Product Awards from Garden Retailers Announced at …

This year’s Tropical Plant Industry Exhibition (TPIE) once again served as a great spot for the Cool Product Awards, an annual collaboration between TPIE, Florida Nursery Growers and Landscape Association, and The Garden Center Group.

Read More