View: Industry Power Shift Approaching

Growers proved they weren’t immune from change and accountability when retailers began putting downward pressure on them in the 1990s. Now, marketing consultant Jerry Montgomery says another power shift is coming, and it involves growers making suppliers just as accountable. Below is Jerry’s commentary:

Our industry was in the era of “Grower In Charge” up until the 1990s. The retailers followed the growers during that era, and the growers made almost all of the decisions relative to green goods marketing at retail.

Growers selected the sizes, the varieties, the packaging and in many cases dictated the seasonality. Of this was also the period where the supply was less than the demand and the hay days of industry growth, where it was not unusual for the wholesale value of bedding plants to increase 8-10 percent annually.

In the early ’90s, as the national retailers were becoming the leaders in retailing green goods, the dynamics drastically changed and the retailers took control of the supply chain. As they flexed their muscles and changed they way growers go to market, industry margins began to shrink because the retailer gained an understanding of production profitability and wanted to participate in the form of lowers prices.

Not only did retailers put downward pressure on prices, but they demanded UPC labeling, consumer information on the product labeling and got new and different packaging. They also started asking for specific varieties. Now, the retailers are adopting products from intermediaries and telling their vendors how many they have to buy, eliminating any bargaining for the grower with their supply chain.

During the ’90s, some growers expanded but many more started to see dramatically reduced profits. By the early 2000s, grower loss was at an historic level. To survive, growers have to listen to the customer and embrace their demands. This did not sit well with many companies that were accustomed to and embraced the concept of “grower in charge.” This was and continues to the beginning of the end for many industry companies that have a long history of success but can’t bring themselves to embrace the changing market dynamics.

Until the mid-1990s there was little accountability for grower performance. The responsibility for retailing green goods and the associated costs, including discards, was the exclusive domain of the retailers.

As the retailers gained more bargaining power and at the same time started developing very sophisticated supply chain measuring tools and techniques, they made their vendors more and more accountable. “Pay by Scan is another example of how the major retailers are managing their supply chain by pushing more accountability and cost to the vendor base. Unfortunately, most growers don’t buy on the basis of “pay by scan.” They just sell–not a bad deal for their vendors. But just wait.

Retailers now judge their vendors not on who has the smoothest-talking sellers but on numbers–comp sales year over year, gross margin, GMROI and same store sales. If those numbers don’t correlate with the retailer’s plan, the grower is at risk of losing the customer.

Consider how the number of bedding plant vendors has changed at Walmart over the past three years. According to some well-informed industry watchers, Walmart has gone form more than 250 bedding plant vendors to a current level of 35 to 40. If you evaluated Lowe’s and Home Depot, the numbers would be similar to those of Walmart.

In the face of the changing market, there are high rates of failure but there are also a number of success stories. Check out the table (below) for the elements that, in my opinion, are the drivers that determine why some fail while others succeed.

Elements Successful Companies Struggling Companies
Customer focus Listen and respond, lead Hate the customers
Understand accountability Embrace being measured Always have excuses
Response to change Drive and embrace change Fight it
Measure the vendors Make them accountable Think it’s ridiculous
Measure themselves Standard practice Waste of time

Power Shift

In the future, large retailers will be more demanding and expect higher levels of performance from all of their vendors. This will ultimately put the supply chain in the hands of fewer growers, and those growers will have more bargaining power. When that happens they will buy on a “pay-by-scan” basis.

Looking at other parts of the supply chain, the game changes dramatically for the breeder/producer and the brokers. These sectors are not immune from the elements of change and accountability. No longer can either group sell based on mundane features; they must go to market with superior products that are competitively priced, and they must have a stellar track record of order fulfillment and on-time delivery.

Growers are and will continue to hold their vendors accountable for a lot more than just a pretty new color. Vendors are now accountable for making their customers money–not supplying goods. If you look at the most successful companies in any segment of this industry, it’s those that have passion for making their customer’s successful and doing it while making a profit.

The companies we see as the market leaders are not those who jump when the customer demands something but those who provide leadership by keeping their customers informed and up to date with the changing marketplace. They are the leaders because they understand how to successfully operate within the ranks of large retailers. They are the go-to companies.

Customer and vendor success are not mutually exclusive; they are synonymous with the companies in today’s world that embrace and drive change and love being accountable to their customer’s while making their vendors accountable to them. It’s the ideal formula for staying healthy and developing a competitive advantage.

Change and accountability have made a huge impact on the grower market, creating fewer but stronger companies and causing others to enter other sectors like contract growing.

The next sector to be affected by these elements will be the breeder/producer segment, as more of their customers will measure their performance–not just judge them by new genetics. We all know there are more genetics available than the market can possibly absorb. We are entering a period when this sector will undergo enormous changes. Some will emerge stronger than ever, but some of the old-line traditional companies will no longer exist.

All successful companies in the future will be run by smart business people who know how to manage all the business disciplines and embrace change and accountability.

About the author: Jerry Montgomery is a 40-year veteran of the floriculture industry and has worked for distributor companies, breeders and large growers specializing with a focus on sales and marketing. As an industry consultant, he works for large growers, distributors and breeder/producers. His focus is to understand the market dynamics from breeder to consumer through intense retail travel, visiting more than 2,000 stores since January 2008.

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “View: Industry Power Shift Approaching

  1. If the growers are all moving towards ‘pay by scan’ who then is going to hold the individual retail stores responisble for lack of watering, following marketing planograms and setups, as well as ordering too heavy or too light product ?

  2. If the growers are all moving towards ‘pay by scan’ who then is going to hold the individual retail stores responisble for lack of watering, following marketing planograms and setups, as well as ordering too heavy or too light product ?

More From State of the Industry...
Plants-and-Money

January 5, 2018

State of the Greenhouse Industry: Dealing With Your Banks in 2018 Will Take Patience

Financial institutions are still reluctant to part with capital for agricultural and horticultural growth, despite economic indicators. Here’s why banks have raised the bar on lending.

Read More
Capitol-Building

December 28, 2017

State of the Greenhouse Industry: Regulatory Uncertainty Means It’s Time to Get Involved

With election dynamics, a new farm bill, and pending immigration reform in the mix, 2018 looks to be a wait-and-see year for the horticulture industry.

Read More

December 9, 2017

Southern California Wildfires Narrowly Miss Most Grower Operations

Here’s an update on horticulture businesses in the areas affected by the California wildfires.

Read More
Latest Stories
Plants-and-Money

January 5, 2018

State of the Greenhouse Industry: Dealing With Your Ban…

Financial institutions are still reluctant to part with capital for agricultural and horticultural growth, despite economic indicators. Here’s why banks have raised the bar on lending.

Read More
Capitol-Building

December 28, 2017

State of the Greenhouse Industry: Regulatory Uncertaint…

With election dynamics, a new farm bill, and pending immigration reform in the mix, 2018 looks to be a wait-and-see year for the horticulture industry.

Read More

December 9, 2017

Southern California Wildfires Narrowly Miss Most Grower…

Here’s an update on horticulture businesses in the areas affected by the California wildfires.

Read More
Biocontrols in a Greenhouse

November 3, 2017

Take Greenhouse Grower’s 2018 State of the Indust…

Growers and others associated with the greenhouse business often ask the Greenhouse Grower editorial staff where we get ideas for stories. The Answer: You! That's why we're asking you to please take some time to answer our annual State of the Industry survey.

Read More

November 1, 2017

Technology Is Changing the Game for Growers

Technology is sexy. There’s a fervor associated with buying the latest go-go-gadget — and a fear of missing out if we don’t. We all want that latest, most advanced smartphone, home assistant, or wearable tech, no matter the cost. And jobs associated with technology? Google, Microsoft, Apple, Amazon, Facebook, Twitter — offer some of the most competitive and coveted positions on the planet. Just look at the stir Amazon made when it announced it would build a $50 billion second headquarters, with cities from all over North America clamoring to be the one chosen, considering the significant economic potential. Technology and tech jobs are it — and it’s no wonder growers don’t feel jobs in horticulture can compete. But what if they can? If tech jobs are the future and the future of horticulture depends on technology, then we have a real opportunity to seize. Millennials who have grown up […]

Read More

May 23, 2017

USDA-APHIS Bulletin on Unauthorized Distribution of Gen…

On May 2, 2017, USDA-APHIS was informed that an orange petunia variety was potentially genetically engineered and had been imported and moved interstate without required authorization by APHIS. This led to testing of numerous petunia varieties, which confirmed this particular variety and several others are genetically engineered, and meet the regulatory definition of a regulated article under APHIS regulations. APHIS continues to work with the industry to ensure unauthorized GE petunias are not distributed in the United States.

Read More

March 2, 2017

Greenhouse Grower State of the Industry Whitepaper Avai…

This year’s survey featured a record 975 respondents and tackled topics such as sales trends, technology, major industry challenges and opportunities, and much more.

Read More
Greenhouse Grower State of the Industry Webinar

February 27, 2017

State of the Industry Webinar Available for On-Demand V…

The half-hour presentation includes an analysis of Greenhouse Grower’s 2017 State of the Industry survey, along with insights from horticulture industry leaders.

Read More

February 11, 2017

Poinsettia Survey Reveals Growers Increased Poinsettia …

On average, growers responding to Greenhouse Grower’s 2016 Poinsettia Survey said the poinsettia season was “good,”Here’s a glance at the outlook for poinsettias in the marketplace.

Read More

January 25, 2017

59 New Members of Congress Need to Hear from You, SAF S…

Retailers, wholesalers, suppliers, and growers coming to the Society of American Florists' (SAF) 37th Annual Congressional Action Days, March 13-14 in Washington, DC, have a lot of explaining to do. There are 59 new congressmen and senators on Capitol Hill, and this freshmen class needs a lesson about floriculture.

Read More
bouldin-lawson-pro-sticking-line-at-north-creek-nurseries

January 25, 2017

State of the Industry 2017: Growers are Ready to Invest…

Greenhouse Grower's 2017 State of the Industry Survey revealed that grower investment in technology is imminent due to the cost and availability of labor, to improve efficiency, expand their growing operations, and allow employees to concentrate on higher value jobs that are less labor-intensive.

Read More

January 24, 2017

Growers are an Aging Demographic, 2017 State of the Ind…

Owners and upper management of growing operations in the horticulture industry, not unlike others in agriculture, are aging, according to Greenhouse Grower’s 2017 State of the Industry Survey.

Read More
Biocontrols and beneficials absolutely can be used in outdoor production, with the use of banker plant systems

January 24, 2017

Growers Becoming More Sustainable but Most Think Climat…

Greenhouse Grower's 2017 State of the Industry Survey revealed that growers are adopting biocontrols and organic production, yet 58% of growers said they don't believe humans can control climate change.

Read More

January 24, 2017

State of the Industry Survey Says 2017 Will be a Year o…

Growers, suppliers, and researchers who took Greenhouse Grower’s 2017 State Of The Industry Survey say they are ready to drive change and profitability in horticultural businesses.

Read More
Moana plant yard

January 4, 2017

Green Industry Poised for Continued Economic Growth in …

Positive economic indicators point to 2017 being a year of modest growth for the green industry, according to economist Charlie Hall.

Read More

January 3, 2017

Growing Optimism for the Horticulture Industry in 2017

With a new administration and a new Congress, AmericanHort's Craig Regelbrugge says the horticulture industry has reason to be cautiously optimistic that regulatory relief could be on the horizon.

Read More
Bees on flowers

October 11, 2016

Bees Endangered? Here’s The Rest Of The Story

Recently, mainstream media reported that certain bee species have been placed on the endangered species list, but the situation isn’t as dire as one might think.

Read More
cuttings-facility

September 27, 2016

How Global Suppliers Of Unrooted Cuttings Are Working T…

The world’s top vegetative producers discuss how they continue to evolve to overcome challenges and embrace opportunities to help growers and the varieties supply chain.

Read More