WholeTree Provides A Sustainable Substrate

The six partners in Young’s plant farm are all in the family. Clockwise from rear left: Greg Young, Burt Young, Rob Young, Drew Young, Bryan Young and Cale Young.

Growers hate surprises, especially when it comes to costs. So when the price of fuel or other supplies start to increase, most growers look for ways to hold down costs without sacrificing product quality. This is especially important at Young’s Plant Farm in Auburn, Ala., where the company motto is, “Grow the best plants, always.”

A Media Component Alternative

Researchers at Auburn University have been looking at alternative components in nursery growing media for several years. In 2004, USDA scientist Glenn Fain and then-Auburn Department of Horticulture chair Charles Gilliam discussed the concerns nursery growers voiced regarding pine bark supplies. It was during this meeting that Gilliam mentioned the idea of harvesting and grinding young, whole pine trees to make a substrate, a process referred to as WholeTree.

Fain began research on the WholeTree substrate along with other alternative media components in 2004. The research was done in collaboration with Gilliam and Auburn University Horticulture Professor Jeff Sibley. At the time, the USDA Thad Cochran Southern Horticultural Research Laboratory in Poplarville, Miss., and the university entered into a formal agreement to work on alternative substrates. Fain, who received his Ph.D. from Auburn and returned to the university in July 2007 as a horticulture professor, continues to work with WholeTree and other substrates.

Fain, Gilliam and Sibley have also directed numerous graduate students working on various aspects of alternative substrates. In the past six years they have published over 20 peer-reviewed scientific papers on their research and have presented results at numerous scientific and industry conferences.

Hurricane Changes Crop Focus

“Initially we were working on substrates and nursery crops,” Fain says. “We weren’t looking for a substrate for greenhouse crops. I grew up working in a wholesale and retail nursery, so my background and research area focused on nursery crops.”

All that changed when Hurricane Katrina hit the Gulf Coast in August 2005.

“The first time we cut down a whole tree and ground it up to make a substrate was in the spring prior to Hurricane Katrina,” Fain says. “We initially chose the Southern pine (Pinus taeda) because of its availability throughout the South. Our initial goal was to find a substrate for nursery crops that was not a byproduct of another industry. We were primarily trying to find an alternative to pine bark, which is a byproduct of the pulp and lumber industries. Pine was a logical choice since it is widely available and easy to grow.”

When Hurricane Katrina came through Mississippi, it wiped out all of Fain’s nursery crop trials. In an effort to get his research back up and running Fain chose to work with greenhouse crops.

“Where a nursery crop would take six months to a year to get any results, trials with greenhouse crops could be finished in 30 to 60 days,” he says. “I primarily studied bedding plants and a few perennials because they are also relatively quick crops.”

Researching Potential Substrates

After seeing positive results with the WholeTree substrate, Fain and his colleagues presented a poster on the research at the American Society for Horticultural Science conference in February 2006. Gene Young, who founded Young’s Plant Farm, heard about the research from long-time friend and former Auburn Department of Horticulture Head Ron Shumack. Young contacted Gilliam and Fain about the potential of using the substrate at his production facilities in Auburn.

“The Youngs saw what we were doing and wanted to get on board to help with the research,” Fain says. “The USDA formally entered into an agreement with the company to do the research, which was conducted at both its greenhouses and at the USDA lab. Auburn University also was involved with the studies. I returned to Auburn in July 2007 and continued working with the WholeTree substrate as well as other biomass products as potential substrate components.”

WholeTree Provides Flexibility

Young’s Plant Farm President and CEO Greg Young says the company has been trialing WholeTree substrate for more than six years and has been using it on regular basis for about three years. Young’s produces flowering annuals, garden mums, foliage plants and flowering pot plants, including poinsettias, cyclamen and kalanchoes. Most of the plants are sold to mass merchandisers.

The potting mix used at Young’s consists primarily of peat moss, perlite, vermiculite and WholeTree substrate. For some crops, pine bark is added. WholeTree is not used in the company’s plug mix.

“We have a variation of mixes that we use,” Young says. “The WholeTree substrate is normally used in 95 to 99 percent of our production.”

Young says on average WholeTree accounts for 20 to 25 percent by volume of the growing mixes. He said that percentage can vary depending on the crop and grower preference as to how much of the substrate is added to a mix.

The Sustainable Substrates Search

Auburn University horticulture professor Glenn Fain has looked at different plants for use as growing media substrates. He is a member of the Sustainable Substrates team, which includes researchers with the USDA Agricultural Research Service and at universities from across the country.

The goal of their research is to identify and develop regional and sustainable sources of substrates for the horticulture industry. The research is funded through the USDA ARS Floriculture and Nursery Research Initiative and by the Horticultural Research Institute.

“The process that is being used at Young’s Plant Farm has the potential to be used nationally,” Fain says. “We have looked at a lot of tree species as potential substrates. We are interested in plants that are rapid biomass producers — any plant, not just trees, that meets that criteria.”
One of the major issues in developing the substrates is freight costs.

“If a grower wants Canadian peat moss, it has to come from Canada, whether a grower is located in Florida or New York,” Fain says. “We are always looking for a crop that can be grown and processed locally. Something that could be produced within a 150-mile radius would be economical. The crop could be grown in certain areas, processed and then supplied to local growers helping to reduce their freight costs.”

“WholeTree works well as a supplement or alternative component in our growing mixes,” he says. “It helps with drainage. It helps reduce the amount of perlite we add in. It helps reduce the amount of peat that we have to buy. It is a replenishable resource that is locally grown rather than coming out of peat bogs in Canada and Europe. It definitely gives us some flexibility.”

Harvest, Haul, Chip And Mill

When Young’s initially began trialing the WholeTree substrate, trees were brought in from other locations in and outside the state, including Georgia and Mississippi. Young’s is now harvesting all of the pine trees it processes off its property.

“We probably don’t use more than 25 to 30 acres of land in a year. We are cutting 12- to 15-year old pine trees. We have plenty of timberland on which we can cut and replant the trees to meet our needs,” Young says.
Once the trees are cut, they are carried to the dock for processing.

“We are more careful with the hauling of the trees than most logging companies that harvest trees for pulp or lumber,” he says. “We want the trees to be as clean as possible. We don’t drag the trees along the forest floor to avoid picking up weed seeds or snagging other plants.”

Young’s has purchased all of the equipment for harvesting, hauling, chipping and milling the trees, as well as the equipment it uses to produce all of its growing mixes. The only part of the pine tree that is not used to make the WholeTree substrate is the roots. The needles, bark, trunk and pine cones are all processed and chipped. The chips, which are stored under a covered structure, are mixed a couple of times to help reduce their moisture content.

Then they are milled into 61-cubic-foot, UV-resistant, 6-ounce nylon tote bags. The bags, some of which are stored outside, have been used for three years and are re-used as many as 10 times. The substrate is cured for several days to a couple of weeks. During the curing process, the temperature in the bags rises to a range of 140˚F to 160˚F before stabilizing and dropping to the ambient temperature. WholeTree, which has been stored for up to two years, has been used to grow crops without any significant changes in its properties or performance, Young says.

Producing WholeTree Year-Round

“The substrate is lot easier to produce in the spring, summer and early fall,” Young says. “In the late fall and winter, the trees start to produce sap and that causes the milling process to use more energy. The speed of the process is reduced by 25 to 30 percent because the trees have so much more moisture compared to other times of the year.”

Young’s processed about 50 trailer loads of wood chips in 2011. The company usually chips about one trailer load per day, which produces 50 to 60 tote bags of substrate.

“We chip enough substrate to meet our needs for the entire year within a 45- to 50-day period,” Young says. “We don’t chip all the trees at one time. We do it at different times of the year.”

On the few occasions that the company has come up short on its supply of the substrate, it is usually an issue of logistics. Young says that during the periods when the equipment is running and the trees are being processed, there is enough substrate for the crops that need it.

“Periodically we may not put the substrate into the mix for a certain crop because we may have not tried growing that crop in it before,” he says.

Substrate Requires Subtle Changes

Fain says growers who use wood fiber substrates like WholeTree might have to make some subtle changes to their production practices depending on percentages used.

“These include primarily changes to nutrition and water management,” he says. “These substrates don’t have a lot of cation exchange capacity or much buffering capacity. That is one of the positive characteristics of peat, which has a high cation exchange capacity and more buffering capacity.”
According to Fain, wood fiber substrates can be affected more quickly by nutrient sources. For example, application of a fertilizer high in nitrate nitrogen would raise the medium pH, and one high in ammoniacal nitrogen would lower the pH. This change also occurs in peat-based media, but it is much more subtle. This has not been an issue in studies with a growing mix consisting of 40 percent or less WholeTree and peat.

“The negative with the wood fiber products is the growing medium pH can get out of line more quickly,” Fain says. “The positive is that it is easier to bring the pH back to where it should be. This is why we advise growers not to make the wood fiber product the major component of their mixes because of concern with trying to manage the pH.”

Money-Making Opportunities

All of the WholeTree substrate Young’s produces is used for its own production. The company hasn’t tried selling any of the substrate to other growers because of its weight limitations.

“The substrate would have to go through a drying process and there would be a fuel cost involved with removing the moisture,” Young says. “Looking at a shipping range of 100 to 200 miles, we would have to do the calculations to see if it was worth drying and compressing the substrate for shipping. There are a lot of options for drying and packaging.”

In addition to providing the company some flexibility with the components it can use in its potting mixes, WholeTree has helped the company reduce its peat costs.

“This becomes even more important when fuel starts to approach $4 a gallon,” Young says. “With peat coming out of Canada, half of the cost is peat and the other half is freight.”

Leave a Reply

More From Media...

March 4, 2015

Nexus Corporation’s Cheryl Longtin Encourages Women To Seek Volunteer Leadership Opportunities

When Cheryl Longtin came to the horticulture business in 1994, she applied her experience in the automotive industry to promote the adoption of more technology in greenhouse production. Longtin says horticulture, with its rich family tradition, has long promoted women in the industry compared to other industries, but women in horticulture must continue to seek out opportunities to provide volunteer leadership in organizations that shape the future of the business.

Read More

March 4, 2015

Second Annual GreenhouseConnect Will Bring Growers and Suppliers Together in San Diego This October

Following a successful inaugural event in Tampa last fall, Greenhouse Grower has announced the dates of its second annual GreenhouseConnect: October 26-29, 2015. Representatives of an expected two dozen leading greenhouse operations from across the U.S. will join senior-level suppliers at Rancho Bernardo Inn in San Diego for several days of one-on-one strategic meetings, a growers-only roundtable, informational sessions and a variety of networking events.

Read More
cultivate'15 logo

March 4, 2015

Cultivate’15: AmericanHort Announces What’s New

In an industry that has seen major changes occurring at a fast pace, many industry professionals leave Cultivate with their heads spinning and no clear idea of how to regroup and strategize. Cultivate’15 is “Changing the Game.” As this year’s focus, Changing the Game will call your attention to the ways in which our industry has changed and your opportunities to compete successfully.

Read More
Latest Stories

December 2, 2014

Grow-Tech Announces BioStrate, Its Newest Hydroponic Gr…

Grow-Tech LLC recently announced the release of BioStrate Felt, a biobased textile specifically engineered for the growing of hydroponic microgreens and baby salad greens.

Read More

November 18, 2014

7 New Media And Light Products For Greenhouse Productio…

New media and light products cover a broad sweep of growing conditions.

Read More

October 27, 2014

Peat Moss May Be In Short Supply This Year

Adverse weather conditions in Canada have played havoc with the peat moss harvest.

Read More

September 24, 2014

Canadian Harvest Of Peat Moss Is Below Average For 2014

The harvest season has been challenging, according to the Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss Association (CSPMA), with lower-than-expected harvest of peat moss across most production regions in Canada, due primarily to adverse weather conditions across the country.

Read More

July 23, 2014

Liming Requirements And pH Modification For Pine Wood C…

In the last of a four-article series highlighting the production and use of pine wood chips as aggregates in greenhouse substrates, the researchers found growers do not need to adjust their production practices when 20 percent pine wood chips are used as a perlite replacement.

Read More

May 14, 2014

How Pine Wood Chips In Substrates Affect Plant Growth R…

This is the second article of the four article series highlighting the production and use of pine wood chips as aggregates in greenhouse substrates.

Read More

April 3, 2014

The Processing And Properties Of Pine Wood Chips

In the first of a four article series highlighting the use of pine wood chips as alternative aggregates to perlite in greenhouse substrates, researchers from North Carolina State University discuss the processing and physical properties of pine wood chips.

Read More

April 3, 2014

Water And Media Are The Foundations Of Your Business: T…

Electrical conductivity (EC) and pH, as well as water alkalinity, have the biggest effects on nutrient availability. Learn how to keep track of them through three common methods for better monitoring in the greenhouse.

Read More
PlugEase from Acme Group

March 3, 2014

Acme Group Introduces PlugEase, A Line Of Recyclable Ag…

The Acme Group recently announced its new line of recyclable Agrifabrics and plant plug substrate, PlugEase. The products make recycling affordable for greenhouse growers, farmers and horticulturalists.

Read More
Emerald Coast Growers

February 26, 2014

Emerald Coast Growers Constructs New Soil Facility

Emerald Coast Growers has constructed a new, consolidated soil mixing facility to increase efficiency and allow for easier custom blending by crop.

Read More
Combination pH and EC meter. Photo courtesy of Hanna Instruments

February 5, 2014

Test Media pH And EC With The 2:1 Technique, Pour-Throu…

Avoid a buildup of soluble salts and create an environment most conducive to nutrient uptake with these three common media testing methods.

Read More
Fertiss Growing Medium from Oasis Grower Solutions

November 18, 2013

Three New Options For Growing Media

From special blends to mycorrhizae, here are some new options for growth media.

Read More

November 14, 2013

Growing Media: To Mix Or Not To Mix

Thinking about making your own growing mixes to lower costs? There are many things to consider before taking the plunge.

Read More
Berger Logo

November 1, 2013

Berger Acquires Beaver & Lafaille Peat Moss

Berger, a producer of growing mixes, has acquired Beaver Peat Moss & Lafaille Peat Moss, consolidating a long-standing relationship between the companies. The transaction is effective on November 1, 2013. Under the agreement, Serge Lafaille, Beaver & Lafaille Peat Moss’ president, will join Berger’s sales team in order to ensure an easy transition for his current customers. “I am proud to join Berger’s team; we have the same business and growing philosophy, as well as a relentless commitment to being close to our customers in order to offer them what they truly need,” Lafaille says. Berger and Beaver & Lafaille Peat Moss have been partners since 1986. “For Berger, this transaction is a natural evolution of the strong relationship we’ve created with Beaver & Lafaille Peat Moss throughout the past 27 years,” says Berger CEO Claudin Berger. Located in St-Modeste, Quebec, Berger provides growing media and peat moss to professional […]

Read More

August 19, 2013

Students Evaluate Bio Char In Soil

Horticulture students from Olds College in Alberta, Canada, are investigating the viability of using bio char as a soil additive for greenhouse-grown crops. The group includes Emily Stanley, Michael Templeton and Heather Hood. Olds has a very good horticulture program, and I graduated from the greenhouse program there in 1996. Because of my involvement in the program, the group approached me to be a mentor for the study. In this role, I had conference calls with the group every two weeks to discuss the status of the project and offer any insight from a professional grower’s perspective. Bio char is a product derived from a special burning process of organic matter with limited amounts of oxygen. This holds the carbon in the organic matter. When the process is finished, you have a bio char product that can be used as a soil amendment. The students conducted trials on tomatoes and […]

Read More

June 6, 2013

Pro-Mix Is Now On Social Media

Premier Tech Horticulture, which is among the North American leaders of peat moss-based growing media production and distribution, has recently announced the launch of its social media strategy, including the unveiling of its Pro-Mix Facebook, Twitter and YouTube pages for professional and amateur gardeners. Known as a customer-focused and market-driven company, Premier Tech Horticulture strongly believes that today, people are expecting constant interactive communication with brands. As a result, interacting and communicating with external audiences through both new and traditional media remain important elements. Now, with Pro-Mix, this dialogue will also take place online, via new social media platforms that are easy to access for everybody. “These Pro-Mix social media platforms (Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, Pinterest, blogs, wikis, YouTube, etc.) present us with unique opportunities to listen to our customers and stakeholders, but also to share with people our 20 years of experience, knowledge and expertise,” says Chantal Duchesneau, marketing and […]

Read More

June 5, 2013

Webinar: Coir Chunk Media – A Good Choice For Lon…

Coir Chunk Media–A Good Choice For Long-Term CropsTuesday, June 11 at 2 p.m. Eastern, 11 a.m. Pacific Click here to register for this webinar. Growing media manufacturers are looking for new components that can be added to their growing media to improve physical properties and address common problems that the grower and/or end user face. One such problem the homeowner experiences with peat-based growing medium in hanging baskets and long term-planters is that they are hard to re-wet with water after they have dried out. Join Horticulture Specialist Troy Buechel on Tuesday, June 11 at 2 p.m. Eastern, 11 a.m. Pacific for this informative webinar to learn how Premier Tech Horticulture is addressing this issue with a new growing medium called PRO-MIX HP-CC. This product contains a unique coir chunk that does not require a wetting agent to wet and helps to hold water while maintaining good air porosity. Find out […]

Read More

April 23, 2013

Premier’s PRO-MIX Marketing Equates Healthy Soil with H…

Professional growers and experienced gardeners have known it for ages: the secret to healthy plants and ultimately, great gardens, begins with excellent soil. Now, that knowledge is being adopted more widely by the average home gardener. To further that knowledge, Premier Tech Horticulture is promoting the idea of creating a $10 hole for a $1 plant using the eight growing mixes in the PRO-MIX line, formulated for a variety of gardening needs. “We’ve developed a variety of soil solutions from organic growing mixes and potting mixes to specialized planting mixes,” says Chantal Duchesneau, marketing and communications director for Premier Tech Horticulture. “Most of the mixes include an all-natural ingredient, MycoActive, a form of mycorrhizae that stimulates a plant’s root system to take up more nutrients and water to improve health and growth.” Two of the PRO-MIX products are: PRO-MIX Ultimate Garden Mix, which is suitable for outdoor plants and vegetables, […]

Read More