USDA Bee Scientist Alleges He Was Punished For Reporting On Neonicotinoids

USDA Whistleblower Case
Photo credit: Dan Gunderson, MPR News file

The debate over the long-term effects of neonicotinoids on the health of bees and butterflies is now making waves at USDA.

A recent report from Minnesota National Public Radio profiles a whistleblower complaint filed by entomologist Jonathan Lundgren, a scientist at USDA’s Agricultural Research facility in Brookings, S.D.

Lundgren’s complaint, which is being represented by the Washington, D.C.-based group Public Employees for Environmental Responsibility (PEER), claims that when Lundgren began to study how neonicotinoid insecticides affect bees and other beneficial insects, his research and work travel began falling under intense scrutiny, which later led to Lundgren being suspended for violating agency protocols.

Jeff Ruch, executive director of PEER, argues that pressure from the pesticide industry has led USDA to stifle scientists like Lundgren. He had no evidence, but said the complaint will let attorneys seek information and interview USDA officials about the Lundgren case. He believes that work will prove USDA targeted Lundgren because of his neonicotinoid research.

According to the Minnesota National Public Radio report, a USDA spokesperson said that while the agency can’t discuss individual cases, it takes scientific integrity seriously.

“We fully review allegations of wrong-doing and make the results of those reviews available to the public online.” USDA, he added, has “procedures for staff to report any perceived interference with their work, seek resolution, and receive protection from recourse for doing so.”

Earlier this year, Lundgren wrote a paper on research that showed neonicotinoid insecticides killed or stunted growth of monarch butterfly larvae.

Monarch populations have plummeted in recent years because of habitat loss. Lundgren’s research showed milkweed plants growing near farm fields treated with the insecticide could harm monarch larvae.

Check out the full report presented on Minnesota National Public Radio on October 28, which also includes an audio version of the story.


Leave a Reply to Pete Cancel reply

13 comments on “USDA Bee Scientist Alleges He Was Punished For Reporting On Neonicotinoids

  1. The USDA takes scientific integrity seriously is the joke of the year the USDA like the EPA is an extension of the pesticide industry and will punish anyone who interferes with their profits. I wish Jonathan Lundgren the best of luck going against these corrupt SOB’s

    1. No one is apply neonics to milkweed on purpose. Though the linked article does not specify it, corn seed is often treated with a powder form of neonics that can inadvertently spread via dust when planting corn seed. Any subsequent applications of neonics to the corn can inadvertently find its way to the milkweed. Milkweed is often found growing along borders of corn fields, the last remaining areas for its growth since the rest of the land is devoted to corn.

    2. The problem is that only about 5% of this nerve poison is taken up by the target plants, being water soluble the rest of it moves in the ground and is taken up by none target flowering plants which are attractive to bees and butterflies. Depending on the soil these nerve poisons can remain in the ground for years.

      1. There is no credible peer reviewed scientific research that supports or indicates a link to this theory as a causative factor in bee colony collapse. So far, that is speculative at best and persistent rumor mongering at worst.

      2. Is there any study showing neonicotinoids can persist for years in soil? That was a problem with chlorinated hydrocarbon type pesticides but does not seem possible for neonicotinoids.

  2. It should not be news to anyone that insecticides will kill insects. That is what they are designed to do. The object is to use them on target insects and not indiscriminately…..

      1. The Harvard study “treated the hives with” the neonics. What did they expect? The bees to grow healthier? There has been no decline in Australia, yet they use neonics extensively. What they don’t have are the V. mites. Further bee population/colonies are up 20% this year. These peer reviewed studies are not reliable and in the end, prove nothing.

  3. Lundgren was travelling at taxpayer expense without supervisory approval to discuss his research which hadn’t been peer reviewed, and using his official gov’t email for personal use? The MPR article provides this info, Had I done this when I worked for the government, it would have been an automatic 30 day suspension without pay and quite possibly a desk assignment.

  4. Any Scientist knows that their Research has to stand the test of time, and that the experiment can be replicated by others with similar results. It is irresponsible to conclude results from a single experiment, and to conclude or assume that the problem has been solved; such as “The reason the Monarchs have vanished is because Neonics were used nearby”.

More From Insect Control...
Dallas Johnson Greenhouses

April 14, 2018

Kemin Forms Distribution Partnership With Plant Products

Under the agreement, Plant Products will be a Kemin Crop Technologies’ distributor in the northeastern U.S.

Read More

April 13, 2018

Dümmen Orange Debuts New Rooting Technology

Basewell bare-root cuttings feature advanced root development and no growing media, which allows products to ship to growers from off-shore production locations, ready to transplant directly into the finish container.

Read More

April 10, 2018

New Tool Helps Greenhouse Growers Analyze Irrigation Water Quality

The University of Connecticut and University of Florida have partnered to launch the WaterQual tool as part of the CleanWateR3 research program.

Read More
Latest Stories

April 2, 2018

Insect Management Tool From SePRO Registered in Califor…

Hachi-Hachi SC is active on all life stages of insects such as thrips, aphids, and mealybugs.

Read More

March 13, 2018

Greenhouse Biocontrol Goes Mainstream

Biological control has moved into the mainstream for greenhouse growers. And the timing couldn’t be better, as consumer demands for more sustainable production methods for the plants they buy are moving back upstream.

Read More
Adult Thrips feature

February 20, 2018

Thrips Causing Headaches? New Research Shows Bio-based …

Dr. Rose Buitenhuis will present practical knowledge for growers to implement immediately during Biocontrols West Conference in San Diego, March 7-9.

Read More

January 18, 2018

Mitigating Whiteflies in Ornamental Production

Gain better control over common greenhouse and nursery pests with these best practices.

Read More
Damage to Cannabis Buds from Hemp Russet Mite

October 22, 2017

Take Control of Mites in Cannabis Crops

Mite pests have become a problem for cannabis growers. To reduce crop losses, follow these best practices for better best management.

Read More
Whitefly adult

October 13, 2017

Researchers Continue to Keep Close Tabs on Whitefly

Dr. Lance Osborne of the University of Florida and Dr. Cindy McKenzie of USDA’s Agricultural Research Service are evaluating insecticide efficacy and the impact of product rotations on whitefly biotype populations.

Read More
Biocontrols in a Greenhouse

September 4, 2017

How to Successfully Integrate Biocontrols Into Greenhou…

The widespread adoption of biocontrol in Canadian floriculture greenhouses grew out of necessity. The lessons they learned can help you incorporate these tools in your production.

Read More
Aphids On Older Leaves

August 8, 2017

OHP Launches New Insecticidal Soap, Gains New Registrat…

OHP is making two new crop protection tools available to greenhouse growers: Kopa, an insecticidal soap, and California registration for Ancora, a microbial insecticide.

Read More
Cannabis Crop Protection

July 27, 2017

Keep Pests Out of Your Cannabis Facilities

Prevention of pest introduction is the most critical first step in an effective pest management program.

Read More

July 7, 2017

New Tools for Your Crop Protection Arsenal in the Green…

Over the past few months, crop protection companies have developed several new products designed to help you manage a wide range of insect and disease pests. Here’s a look at some of them.

Read More
Yellow Stick Card for thrips

July 5, 2017

Tips From a Top 100 Grower for Effective Thrips Control

A combination of conventional materials and biologicals can help provide season-long management of thrips in hanging baskets.

Read More
Scale on leaf nodes

July 2, 2017

Why Biological Control Fails: Encapsulation May be the …

If your biological control isn’t working for you, encapsulation could be to blame. Learn how this defensive response can cripple a biological control program.

Read More
Koppert Ulti-Mite Swirski sachet

June 21, 2017

New Tool from Koppert Provides More Effective Thrips Ma…

A newly patented sachet for the predatory mite Amblyseius swirskii is resistant to both low and high levels of humidity, helping growers combat thrips infestations.

Read More
Cannabis Seedling

May 20, 2017

Biocontrols: A Practical Option for Cannabis

With limited options for chemical pest control, cannabis growers are incorporating biocontrols into their integrated pest management programs. More education will cement this solution as a viable option in this emerging market.

Read More
Four Lined Plant Bug

May 8, 2017

Four-Lined Plant Bug Emerges as Troublesome Pest in Pen…

Four-lined plant bug damage is very characteristic: circular brown to black spots about one-sixteenth of an inch in diameter. The spots are easily mistaken for disease or frost damage.

Read More

May 4, 2017

Bayer Altus Update: Neonic Insect Control Alternative N…

Altus, a butenolide class insecticide with the active ingredient flupyradifurone, will be available beginning May 1, and is labeled for greenhouse and nursery use on ornamental plants, vegetable transplants, and indoor vegetable production.

Read More
Ambrosia Beetle

April 7, 2017

Tips On How to ID Ambrosia Beetle Damage, And How to Co…

Ambrosia beetles are often overlooked as being a primary cause of plant loss, but research and experience are proving otherwise.

Read More

February 28, 2017

OHP Launches New Ovicide/Miticide, Announces Partnershi…

Applause is a new miticide that targets eggs and immature stages of several mite species. Through the Vestaron partnership, OHP will market Spear-O, a toxin-derived bioinsecticide.

Read More