The Peat Report: A Case Against Canadian Peat Moss

The Peat Report: A Case Against Canadian Peat Moss

The theme of last summer’s Seeley Conference, floriculture’s environmental footprint, included a discussion on how sustainable peat is as a soil amendment. The discussion stemmed from part of a presentation highlighting the new Sustainable Sites Initiative created by the American Society of Landscape Architects, the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center and the United States Botanical Garden.

The three organizations are teaming on the Sustainable Sites Initiative (SITES) to create voluntary national guidelines and performance benchmarks for sustainable land design, construction and maintenance practices. But two recommended requirements of the initiative–using peat-free planting media and avoiding sphagnum peat as a soil conditioner–sparked a debate at the Seeley Conference.

To further explain the requirements, as well as the reasons SITES drafted them, Greenhouse Grower tasked the SITES with sharing some perspective. We also asked Mark Elzinga, president of Elzinga & Hoeksema Greenhouses, to share his reaction to the requirements regarding peat and the role peat plays in his greenhouse operation. Both SITES, represented by Steve Windhager, and Elzinga participated in the 2010 Seeley Conference discussion.

To read Elzinga’s essay, “A Case For Canadian Peat Moss,. Below is SITES’ case against Canadian Peat Moss.

The use of sphagnum peat as a soil amendment was considered by the technical committees of the Sustainable Sites Initiative (SITES) in the development of the “Guidelines and Performance Benchmarks 2009,” available as a free download at www.sustainablesites.org/report. Reference to peat occurs specifically in Prerequisite 7.2 (restore soils disturbed during construction) and credits 5.9 (support sustainable practices in plant production) and 7.3 (restore soils disturbed by previous development).

Based on this technical committee work, the Sustainable Sites Initiative does not consider the use of sphagnum peat to be sustainable, as it is non-renewable within a 50-year time span.

Why Peat Is Not Sustainable

While the rates of annual accumulation of peat in Canada on an annual basis do exceed the volume extracted for horticultural purposes, this does not make this harvest sustainable. Peat accumulates at a rate of 0.5 to 1 millimeters annually, and thus an area cannot recover from harvesting within a sustainable time frame. Even the Canadian Sphagnum Peat Moss Association concedes that in regard to peatland restoration, “the full natural capital of the pristine bog [will not return] within any normative human timeline measurement.”

Peatlands are critical sinks for carbon and its extraction increases greenhouse gas emissions, covering only 3 percent of the world’s surface area but providing for 30 percent of all carbon stored in the soil. While extraction of peat for horticultural purposes currently only represents a small portion of total greenhouse gas emissions, harvesting peat does contribute to climate change.

One researcher has pointed out that because carbon dioxide (CO2) emissions from harvested, cutover peatlands are approximately three times greater than the emissions from natural sites, the loss of only 5 percent of Canadian peatlands–whether for horticultural extraction or some other cause–will result in Canadian peatlands being converted from a net carbon sink to a net source of CO2.

In addition, rising temperatures associated with global warming could significantly impact Canadian peatlands and trigger a feedback loop that would greatly increase peatland degradation and greenhouse gas emissions from them.

Abandoned, cutover peatlands rarely return to functional peatland ecosystems post-extraction because the physical and hydrological conditions required for sphagnum re-establishment have been eliminated in most cases. These degraded, cutover peatlands then become long-term, persistent sources of CO2 emissions. Thus, restoration of cutover peatlands is preferred to their abandonment, and it is possible to return a degraded peatland from a CO2 source to a carbon sink within three to five years–although a six- to 10-year time frame may also apply.

Continuing advances in extraction and restoration techniques may further reduce greenhouse gas emissions associated with horticultural extraction and facilitate more rapid and robust restoration.  However, intact, non-degraded peatlands sequester carbon at a greater rate than restored peatlands and disturbance associated with peat extraction irrevocably alters peatland ecology despite restoration.

In addition, negative consequences associated with peatland restoration, such as increases in phosphorus leaching from the rewetting of peat surfaces, are possible. And restoration will not regenerate peat stores at a rate that would permit sustainable extraction.

Therefore, while restoration of cutover peatlands is far preferable to their abandonment, there are significant environmental costs associated with cutover peatlands irrespective of restoration.

Climate Change Implications

Finally, climate change associated with greenhouse gas emissions is expected to bring hotter, drier conditions. By lowering existing groundwater levels, climate change can upset the delicate balance in peatland ecology between carbon sequestration and greenhouse gas emission, transforming many peatlands from net carbon sinks into net sources of CO2.

Canadian peatlands in the subarctic and boreal wetland regions, such as the Hudson Bay Lowlands, the Mackenzie River Valley region and the northern parts of Alberta and Manitoba, are most likely to be affected.

Researchers have calculated that climate change will impact 60 percent of the total area of Canadian peatlands and 51 percent of the organic carbon sequestered. In addition, greenhouse gas emissions from peatlands triggered by climate change could create a feedback loop that could raise temperatures still further and accelerate peatland degradation.

While additional research needs to be done to evaluate climate change’s impact on peatlands and carbon fluxes globally, the carbon sink-source relationship for Canadian peatlands is more likely to become a more significant contribution to climate change with continued harvesting.

Peat Moss Alternatives

Compliance with SITES credits that preclude the use of sphagnum peat moss is practical and achievable because alternatives do exist to the use of peat moss for soil restoration and as a medium for horticultural plant production. Compost, which the Soils Technical Subcommittee has judged to be a superior source of organic matter for soil restoration than peat moss, is widely, though not universally available, and typically at a much closer distance to a development site than a Canadian peatland. 

Alternatives to peat moss as a plant-growing medium, such as coir fiber and dust, wood fiber and bark, biosolids, bracken and compost, are available if not as extensively used.

It should also be noted that the efficacy of particular peat moss alternatives is relative to the use (i.e. plant propagation versus horticultural production) and to specific plants, and that the use of peat moss alternatives is in a learning phase as horticulturists become more familiar with them and understand the techniques and requirements needed to obtain best results. However, encouraging change and innovation that reasonably raises the bar for existing practices is consistent with SITES principles.

It is also important to note SITES is a voluntary set of guidelines for landscape sustainability aimed at market transformation and that certification is possible without achieving credits 5.9 or 7.3. SITES is striving to ensure that the built landscape is part of the solution for our global environmental problems, and we believe avoiding the use of peat is an important part of achieving this goal.

About the author: Multiple people associated with the Sustainable Sites Initiative (SITES), including Steve Windhager, director of the Lady Bird Johnson Wildflower Center and SITES, produced this essay. SITES can be contacted at [email protected].

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “The Peat Report: A Case Against Canadian Peat Moss

  1. The myth that man’s impact upon CO2 is impacting global temperatures is rapidly falling apart. Why commit an economic disaster? This myth is short lived. EX. The Chicago Carbon Exchange closed down while the getting was good.

  2. The myth that man’s impact upon CO2 is impacting global temperatures is rapidly falling apart. Why commit an economic disaster? This myth is short lived. EX. The Chicago Carbon Exchange closed down while the getting was good.

More From Media...
Soil-pH feature

January 7, 2018

How Direct-Stick Meters Can Help Take the Guesswork Out of Soil pH

Monitoring your soil pH is critical to maintaining the health of your greenhouse crops. Try these tips for managing pH, as well as accurately testing your soil with direct-stick soil pH meters.

Read More
Peat vacuum harvester

December 8, 2017

The Sustainability of the Peat Industry Looks Better Than You Think

Despite talk about alternative products and differences of opinion over its sustainability as a resource, peat is here to stay.

Read More
mycoapply-from-mycorrhizal-applications-feature

December 6, 2017

How Mycorrhizae Provide Value at Your Greenhouse or Nursery

Mycorrhizae create a connection between the roots of a plant and the surrounding growing media. This ultimately leads to better crop health through enhanced nutrient and water uptake.

Read More
Latest Stories
Soil-pH feature

January 7, 2018

How Direct-Stick Meters Can Help Take the Guesswork Out…

Monitoring your soil pH is critical to maintaining the health of your greenhouse crops. Try these tips for managing pH, as well as accurately testing your soil with direct-stick soil pH meters.

Read More
Peat vacuum harvester

December 8, 2017

The Sustainability of the Peat Industry Looks Better T…

Despite talk about alternative products and differences of opinion over its sustainability as a resource, peat is here to stay.

Read More
mycoapply-from-mycorrhizal-applications-feature

December 6, 2017

How Mycorrhizae Provide Value at Your Greenhouse or Nur…

Mycorrhizae create a connection between the roots of a plant and the surrounding growing media. This ultimately leads to better crop health through enhanced nutrient and water uptake.

Read More
lucas-greenhouses-plant-roots-growing-mix

November 13, 2017

Michigan State Offering Online Root Zone Management Cou…

Participants in the three-month, self-paced online course can learn about water quality, plant nutrition, and irrigation management.

Read More
Growing-Media-Symposium-Tour

November 13, 2017

International Growing Media Symposium Comes to the U.S.

This International Symposium, with representatives from 21 countries, covered new market opportunities, generated innovative ideas, and offered first-hand information to more than 150 attendees.

Read More
Oasis PlantPaper

September 25, 2017

Oasis Introduces New Biodegradable Paper Wrap for Plant…

PlantPaper is an all-natural, bio-based, wrap media that contains no glue and provides more effective rooting.

Read More
LM-Bark 1 (Lambert Peat Moss)

September 25, 2017

European Growing Media Manufacturers Face Challenging M…

Rising costs and a poor harvest have created challenging conditions for the growing media industry in 2017, according to the UK-based Growing Media Association.

Read More
Growing Media Mixing Model

August 28, 2017

New Mixing Model Predicts Rooting Media Properties

Researchers at Wageningen University & Research have developed a mixing model that predicts the properties of a mix of constituents in any growing media ratio.

Read More
Vijay Rapaka

July 30, 2017

Oasis Grower Solutions Hosting Plant Production Webinar

The webinar, which takes place on Aug. 10, will provide information on growing media for cutting propagation and seed germination.

Read More
New Growing Media Blends

July 26, 2017

British Researchers Evaluating New Media Blends to Redu…

Research in the United Kingdom has shown that coir-free growing media has the potential to work as well as coir for strawberry crops, and these research results likely apply to greenhouse production, as well.

Read More
Iron and Manganese toxicity in geranium

June 13, 2017

Are Your Geraniums Showing Signs of Iron or Manganese T…

Zonal geraniums with low pH can exhibit iron and manganese toxicity symptoms, including marginal chlorosis, leaf speckling, and upward-cupping of the leaves, according to Michigan State University experts.

Read More
GrowTech CatEyePlug Feature

June 6, 2017

Grow-Tech Introduces New Media Plug, Joins Dümmen Orang…

Grow-Tech LLC, a designer and manufacturer of stabilized growing media products, is making waves this week with the launch of a new plug and an announcement that it is joining forces with Dümmen Orange.

Read More
rhp-substrates-root-problems-web

May 9, 2017

How to Test and Correct for Low Substrate pH in Your Gr…

If you mix your own or purchase a pre-mixed substrate, it is recommended you determine the initial pH. In too many cases, growers end up discovering low substrate pH.

Read More
pbh-peat-mix-feature

January 2, 2017

Why You Need To Know What’s In Your Growing Media…

Before you buy growing media mixes or raw materials to mix your own custom blends, here are some important factors to consider.

Read More
zenplug-with-orchid-from-grow-tech

December 25, 2016

Grow-Tech Patents Plug Designed for Tissue Culture

The ZenPlug from Grow-Tech is used for tissue culture in orchids and difficult-to-root cuttings, and is one of several products recently developed by Grow-Tech.

Read More
Various Wood Substrates

December 18, 2016

The Evolution And Revolution Of Wood Substrates

Growing media formulations are evolving as researchers fine tune blending techniques for wood component substrate alternatives to achieve reliable, consistent results.

Read More
oasis-grower-solutions

December 17, 2016

New Growing Media Technology Designed To Promote Health…

Oasis Grower Solutions recently launched several new innovations that support plant growth and health all the way to maturity.

Read More
mycoapply-from-mycorrhizal-applications-feature

December 5, 2016

New Growing Media Advancements Giving Growers More Opti…

With innovative, sustainable growing media components, growers will be able to improve plant health, achieve consistency among crops, save money, and reduce inputs, while saving space on storage.

Read More