Most bedding plants are produced in heated greenhouses from January through May, when high energy inputs can be required to maintain a desirable temperature. With shrinking profit margins and volatile energy prices, scheduling crops in an energy-efficient manner is increasingly desirable. At Michigan State University (MSU), we have performed experiments with many seed-propagated annuals to quantify how temperature and daily light integral (DLI) influence flowering time and plant quality.
In the seventh article of this series, we present crop timing data on seed geranium and zinnia and then use the information to estimate greenhouse heating costs at different locations, growing temperatures and finish dates. We also highlight the effect of DLI on flowering of these two crops.
Materials & Methods
Geranium and zinnia seeds were sown in 288-cell plug trays by C. Raker & Sons, then grown in controlled environmental growth chambers at MSU at 68°F (20°C). Inside the chambers, the photoperiod was 16 hours and the DLI was 9 to 11 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹.
When plugs were ready for transplant (29 days after seed sow for geraniums and 16 days after seed sow for zinnias), they were thinned to one seedling per plug and transplanted into 4-inch (10-centimeter) pots and grown in greenhouses with constant temperature set points of 63, 68, 73 and 79°F (17, 20, 23 and 26°C).
At each temperature, plants were grown under a 16-hour photoperiod with two different DLIs provided by sunlight, a combination of shade curtains and different supplemental lighting intensities from high-pressure sodium lamps.
Seed geranium is a day-neutral crop and thus, day length has no effect on flowering time. Many zinnias are facultative short-day plants. Although they flower under long days, flowering can be accelerated under short days.
Our experiments were performed twice to obtain average DLIs that ranged from 3 to 19.5 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹. To give perspective, a DLI of 3 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ is representative of light conditions received by a Northern greenhouse on a cloudy day in the winter. A DLI of 19.5 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ is typical for inside a greenhouse on a mid- to late spring day. The flowering date was recorded for each plant when geraniums had an inflorescence with five open flowers and zinnias had one whorl of petals fully reflexed. When each plant flowered, plant height, number of leaves and number of flowers and flower buds were recorded.
Crop timing data were used to develop mathematical models to predict flowering time and plant quality under different temperature and DLI conditions. The scheduling models were validated by growing a crop of geranium ‘Pinto Red’ at 71°F to compare predicted flowering times with actual times. Crop models for zinnias were validated by growing plants at three different constant temperatures. The Virtual Grower software (available free at VirtualGrower.net) was used to estimate the cost to heat a 21,504-square-foot greenhouse (about half an acre) to produce each crop for different finish dates and at different locations in the United States.
Estimated heating costs to produce flowering seed geranium ‘Florever Violet’ and zinnia
‘Dreamland Coral’ (from a 288-cell plug; see Table 1) at different temperatures and locations for
first flowering on April 1 or May 15. Cities were chosen from each of the seven leading garden
plant-producing states. Calculations performed with Virtual Grower 2.01 software with constant
temperatures. Greenhouse characteristics include: 8 spans each 112 × 24 feet, arched 12-foot roof,
9-foot gutter, polyethylene double layer roof, polycarbonate bi-wall ends and sides, forced air unit
heaters burning natural gas at $1.00 per therm ($10.24 MCF), 50% heater efficiency,
no energy curtain, and an hourly air infiltration rate of 1.0.
Time to flower for seed geraniums and zinnias decreased as average daily temperature increased. For example, in geraniums grown under a DLI of 10 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹, time to flower from a 288-cell plug decreased from 73 days at 63°F to 42 days at 79°F (Figure 1). Zinnias grown under the same DLI flowered 3.5 weeks earlier at 79°F versus 63°F (Figure 2). Our crop timing data for zinnias is for plants grown under long days, and flowering could have been accelerated if short days had been provided. Regardless of daylength, we anticipate similar temperature trends on crop development rates.
Time to flower also decreased as the DLI increased until some saturating value. For example, as the DLI increased from 4 to 12 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹, time to flower for geraniums grown at 68°F decreased by four weeks and zinnias decreased by 12 days. The estimated saturation DLI for the shortest time to flower was 18 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ for geraniums and 12.5 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ for zinnias (Figure 3).
In other words, increasing the DLI above these values did not shorten crop time. Figure 3 also illustrates that the value of supplemental lighting is greatest when the natural DLI is lowest. Plants grown under a high DLI developed fewer leaves on the primary stem before flowering and thus flowered earlier compared to a lower DLI.
The geranium and zinnia crop models predicted time to flower within five days for at least 94 percent of the validation data. To illustrate the effect of temperature on crop times, we identified dates that 288-cell plugs grown under long days would need to be transplanted for two market dates when grown long days and 10 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ of light (Table 1).
In geranium, inflorescence number increased slightly as temperature decreased and as DLI increased. Geraniums grown at 63°F and under 16 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ had two more inflorescences than plants grown at 79°F and under 4 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹.
In zinnias, the number of flower buds at first flowering was primarily influenced by DLI. For example, plants grown at 73°F and under a DLI of 15 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ had almost twice as many inflorescences than plants grown at the same temperature, but under 4 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹.
Plant height at flower increased as DLI decreased. For example, geranium and zinnias grown at 73°F and under 4 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹ were 4 to 7 inches (10 to 18 centimeters) taller than plants grown at the same temperature, but under 18 molâˆ™m¯²âˆ™d¯¹. The number of branches in zinnias increased as temperature decreased and as DLI increased.
We used our crop timing data to determine if it is more energy-efficient to transplant a spring crop earlier and grow cool versus transplanting later and growing warm. We estimated that to produce a geranium crop for April 1 in Grand Rapids, Mich., New York, N.Y., Charlotte, N.C. or Cleveland, Ohio, heating costs per square foot would be 16 to 20 percent lower at 79°F versus 63°F.
In contrast, to produce the same crop in San Francisco, Calif., Tallahasee, Fla. or Fort Worth, Texas, heating costs would be 7 to 26 percent higher at 79°F versus 63°F. To produce zinnia for April 1, transplanting the crop early and growing at 63°F