Hand Watering, Booms, Sprinklers Or Drip?

Hanging basket setup

The amount of water that can be held by the substrate in a given container with a specific irrigation method is the effective water-holding capacity (EWHC). It may be desirable to maintain the moisture content of the medium below EWHC in order to regulate plant growth or reduce the risk of soil-borne diseases.

Overall, it is important to irrigate thoroughly. The amount of water applied must be sufficient to re-wet the entire volume of growing medium. If the medium is dry and not enough water is applied, only part of the mix will be re-wetted.

In irrigating thoroughly, the method of delivery plays an important role. With top-down irrigation, water will be pulled downward by the force of gravity. As it moves downward, some will be held by the growing medium.

Usually, some water will escape from the bottom of the pot before the medium is thoroughly wet. At the same time, water collects at the bottom of the pot and then moves back up. This can easily be seen if a saucer is placed under a pot with a very dry growing medium. When water is applied to the surface, it will quickly flow through to the saucer, but it then moves back up into the medium.

The relationship between the amount and rate of application of water and the amount retained can be rather complex, but generally, the slower the application, the higher the proportion that is retained. Applying small amounts of water repeatedly with pauses between applications (pulsed irrigation) allows for greater water retention and reduced leaching.

Irrigation System Breakdown

In the most basic terms, an irrigation system consists of three components: a source of water; a delivery system to get it to the growing medium; and valves to control water flow. The goal for any irrigation system is to deliver water to the growing medium as uniformly and efficiently as possible.

Irrigation systems can be divided into two basic categories depending on how water is delivered to the growing medium. Top-down systems deliver water to the surface of the growing mediu

Top-down systems can be divided into three sub-categories: hand watering, which may target individual containers or larger areas; overhead systems such as sprinklers or booms, which deliver water as a spray covering an area; and drip or trickle systems, which deliver water to individual pots.

Hand Watering

Hand watering is most efficient for plug trays and flats, small containers that are tightly spaced. Hand watering is least efficient for potted plants, when they are at final spacing and the canopy is closed, because it is harder to get the water to the growing medium, and it takes longer to deliver water to each container.

Even with careful application by experienced workers, as much as 50 percent of the water that exits a hose ends up on the floor. Efficiency and uniformity can be greatly improved by using water-saver saucers or trays that catch much of the water that would otherwise miss the pot. These trays retain water so it can be absorbed from the bottom up.

Booms

Boom systems are useful for plug trays and flats. Mist nozzles can deliver water consistently at a low rate, resulting in uniform wetting and good water retention. The spray is under low pressure so compaction and washout is minimized. However, drips and uneven spray can take a toll on small containers such as plug trays.

Booms can also be used for larger containers, especially when pots are still tightly spaced. Booms typically have selectable nozzles for different spray patterns, allowing them to be used for misting during propagation and for higher-volume delivery for irrigation. They can be programmed to make repeated passes over the same area or to shut on and off while passing over different areas in their path. Shutting off some nozzles on a boom allows for selective irrigation within a block, like when spot-watering pots on the perimeter of a block that dry out more rapidly than the interior.

Sprinklers

Sprinkler systems are often used for outdoor production areas. Uniformity is a problem outdoors, as sprinklers are designed for turf or field irrigation and don’t distribute water evenly, especially in windy conditions. Furthermore, considerable amounts of water can be wasted as runoff, depending on pot spacing.

Sprinkler systems can be used for irrigation inside the greenhouse, as well. As with booms, different nozzles can be used for propagation mist or potted plants. Like all overhead systems, they are most efficient with tight spacing and an open canopy.

Drip Systems

Drip systems deliver water from individual emitters. In drip tape, the emitters are incorporated at regular intervals in the tape. Drip tape is widely used for irrigation of cut flower crops in soil beds but can be used in a simple setup for containers. The tape is stretched in long runs at the height of the pots, which are placed under the emitters. Drip tape is also pressure compensated, which means water does not come out of emitters until the tube is uniformly pressurized. This ensures a uniform flow rate from all emitters. A pressure regulator is used to avoid excess pressure that could burst the tape.

The most familiar form of a drip system uses flexible “spaghetti tubing” to deliver water to individual containers. The delivery end of the tubing has a weight or stake to hold the tubing in the pot. Pot weights may be designed to shut off individual tubes when not in use, thus conserving water. In large containers, it can be difficult to spread water across the entire surface. Here, individual “spray stakes” are used for better water distribution.

A pressure-compensating outlet ensures uniform flow rates from each emitter. Multiple outlets can be connected to the same pressure compensator. If the length and diameter of the tubing from each outlet is the same, then the flow rates will be uniform. If a multiple outlet system has tubes of varying lengths, then a flow restriction device at the end of each tube is needed to obtain uniform flow rates.

Pressure-compensated drip systems can be used for pulsed irrigation. For example, if the normal irrigation run time would be 30 minutes, the system can be run for six cycles of 5 minutes on, 10 minutes off. Irrigation systems controlled by soil moisture sensors can be programmed to pause long enough for soil moisture to equilibrate after each pulse.

Hanging baskets present a special problem for greenhouse irrigation. When baskets are hung on a transport system, drippers won’t work. A sophisticated system equips each basket with a funnel to ensure that the water ends up where it’s intended.

Takeaways

There are many overall advantages of top-down watering. For example, hand watering requires no installation of special equipment, so it is often used by seasonal operations. Hand watering is also the most flexible system. Very large potted plants, hanging baskets and plugs and flats may not be suitable for flood systems, so top-down watering must be used.

There are, however, limitations to top-down watering. For example, overhead systems result in wet foliage, which is conducive to foliar diseases. The water itself may be damaging to sensitive flowers and bracts. Plus, water and fertilizer residues may be left behind on leaves and flowers, which can be unattractive to consumers. Hand-watering requires labor each time plants need water. Drip systems require less labor on a day-to-day basis but require recurring labor to set up and maintain. Drip emitters can also clog, leading to non-uniform irrigation.

Topics:

Leave a Reply

More From Special Series...
Double Whammy Merchandise Display At CAST2015

May 28, 2015

Grow Inspiration To Grow The Horticulture Industry

We need to work together as the horticulture industry to inspire and instruct consumers with our plant knowledge and marketing expertise.

Read More
Plant-Select_for-web

May 28, 2015

PlantSelect.org And FindPlants.net Assist Consumers With Growing And Finding Plants

The recently launched PlantSelect.org and FindPlants.net websites offer growing and maintenance tips, where-to-buy information and design ideas to help consumers have success with growing and finding plants.

Read More
Cal-Poly fields

May 27, 2015

Cal-Poly Students And Faculty Ask Industry To Help Save Horticulture Facilities

California Polytechnic State University, San Luis Obispo, has released an update to its Master Plan that indicates that almost all of its orchards, horticulture facilities and field sites could be repurposed for buildings, including residential, and/or recreational space. According to a letter from Scott Steinmaus, the horticulture and crop science department head, the proposed changes directly affect the current orchard plantings and other long term plans for the department. The department is committed to making sure that its facilities remain invaluable teaching environments that enable its students to learn about crop, fruit and horticulture production, food safety and pest protection, in addition to providing sites for externally funded research projects that benefit the industry. Industry members are invited to submit comments to the university. According to Steinmaus, a recent eMail to the Cal-Poly community from the university president indicates that all of the input gathered through the end of May will be studied by the planning […]

Read More
Latest Stories

January 29, 2014

Growing Seedlings Under LEDs: Part Two

In the second part of a two-part series, Michigan State University researchers share their findings in germinating seedlings with LED lights.

Read More

December 4, 2013

Plant Breeder Yasuko Isobe: Consumer Lifestyles Will De…

People are more conscientious about living healthy lives and protecting the environment, says this Suntory Flowers breeder.

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Troy Thorup: If Consumers’ Needs Ar…

Troy Thorup breeds various seed and vegetative annual bedding plants for PanAmerican Seed. He has been a breeder for 13 years and holds a Ph.D. in plant genetics and breeding GG: What crops do you feel will be relevant and important over the next 30 years? Thorup: Anything that can balance the combination of beautiful and hard to kill. GG: Will the fervor for all new varieties continue in the industry? Will breeders begin to focus on filling consumers’ needs? Thorup: In my breeding, I don’t view these two things as separate issues. My goal in creating new varieties is largely driven to fulfill consumers’ needs. At the end of the day, if the consumers’ needs aren’t met, they will not buy the product. GG: How will breeders address needs to reduce chemicals by increasing crop resistance to pests and diseases? Thorup: This is a tough question to answer concisely […]

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Jason Jandrew: Multifunctional Plants Are…

This young breeder for Ball Horticultural Co. says breeders can take a cue from cell phones: keep adding features.

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Hans Hansen: The Future’s Plants Wi…

Hans Hansen is the director of new plant development, heading up the hybridizing department for Walters Gardens Inc. in Zeeland, Mich. A graduate of the University of Minnesota, Hansen has been hybridizing plants since he was in high school. At Walter’s Gardens, he manages perennial crops including hemerocallis, hostas, monardas, digitalis, baptisias, leucanthemums and ferns, among others. What direction do you feel breeding is headed? We are living in an absolutely incredible time to be a plant breeder. Recent advancements in science and technology are opening an entirely new direction and present fascinating new opportunities for hybridizers. These include new species recently being discovered, mutagenic plant breeding, new classifications of plants based on scientific studies and new tools not available previously. The internet has turned the world into a very small place. What crops do you feel will be relevant and important over the next 30 years? With the general […]

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Brent Horvath: Grasses Are A Breeding Foc…

Brent Horvath is the owner of Intrinsic Perennial Gardens, Inc., headquartered in Hebron, Ill. Horvath grew up in the industry, working at his parents’ garden center and florist shop. He holds a degree in ornamental horticulture from Oregon State University and today, he grows a wide range of perennials and ornamental grasses. GG: How long have you been a breeder or studying to be a breeder? Horvath: I started in the mid ’90s. After I read Alan Bloom’s Hardy Perennials book, where he talked about how many of his introductions came about, I really started becoming more interested in selecting and breeding. GG: What direction is your breeding career taking? Horvath: As a perennial grower with ornamental grasses being a big part of our production and sales, I focus on those plants that sell well for me. Half of my business is to landscapers and around 20 percent to retailers. […]

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Amanda Hershberger: Pest And Disease Resi…

Amanda Hershberger is a plant breeder for Syngenta. She holds a B.S. in horticulture from Purdue University and an M.S. and Ph.D. in horticulture from the University of Georgia. GG: How will breeders address needs to reduce chemicals by increasing crop resistance to pests and diseases? How far away is this technology? Hershberger: Resistance breeding is vital to the success of many crops and reduces the need for chemical control, as well as reducing the pest’s development of resistance to a chemical control. My personal work experience involves resistance of vinca to Phytophthora. Breeding for pest and disease resistance in ornamental plants has primarily utilized traditional breeding methods. Resistance breeding has also included molecular methods for problems such as black spot in rose and Fusarium in carnation. Agronomic crops have really paved the way for resistance development using molecular markers. I foresee a greater use of molecular techniques to achieve resistance […]

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Joseph Tychonievich: Rock Gardening Will …

Take a look at the other trends Tychonievich says he sees shaping the next 30 years of the greenhouse industry.

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Kelly Norris: Breeders Must Be Champions …

Kelly Norris is currently the horticulture director at the Greater Des Moines Botanical Garden and he holds two degrees (B.S., M.S.) in horticulture from Iowa State University. Norris has been part of the industry since age 15, when he talked his parents into buying a nursery and moving it from Texas to their family farm in Iowa. As the owner of Rainbow Iris Farm, he started breeding irises 12 years ago and continues to focus on breeding independently, as well as in the new breeding program at the botanical garden. GG: As a young breeder, what direction do you feel breeding is headed? Norris: I feel there are two kinds of plant breeders entering the market today. There are those coming of out graduate school looking for jobs in the industry (which aren’t plentiful) and end up toiling away with petunias and commodity crops. I feel for them. Then there […]

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Ockert Greyvenstein: Minimal Inputs Are A…

Greyvenstein also says edible landscapes and hardy grasses will become more relevant floriculture crops.

Read More

December 2, 2013

Plant Breeder Ping Ren: Breeding Must Meet Consumer And…

Jianping (Ping) Ren breeds various seed and vegetatively propagated annuals and perennials for PanAmerican Seed, where she has worked for 13 years. Ren received a Ph.D. in plant breeding in 1998 at Cornell University. Before coming to the floriculture industry, Ren was a vegetable breeder in China with a focus on Brassica vegetables. GG: Will the fervor for all new varieties continue in the industry?  Ren: There are so many new varieties each year. It can be confusing and sometimes difficult for growers and consumers to keep up. But we are all looking for “new” things all the time. There has to be something “new” each year. Of course, some new varieties are new for certain improved traits, which are necessary and can benefit breeding companies (high yield, reduced cost), growers (high germ, more uniform) and consumers (better color and garden performance). The more exciting new for the industry is “true” new […]

Read More

December 2, 2013

Today’s Breeders On Tomorrow’s Plants

One of the future challenges is the continuing need for new and improved crops for the consumer. Make no mistake about it, new crops — and new breeders — are the lifeblood of this industry.

Read More

November 14, 2013

The Basics & Beyond: Understanding The Differences …

As I talk to growers around the country, I often find that there is confusion between (1) photoperiodic lighting used to create a long day for flower induction of long-day plants and (2) supplemental lighting used to increase the total quantity of photosynthetic light received over the course of the day, which is referred to as daily light integral (DLI) in the greenhouse. For more information on DLI, please visit http://bit.ly/11x79eK To add to the confusion, supplemental lighting is sometimes referred to as photosynthetic or assimilation lighting. In this article, I will attempt to clarify the differences to assist you in selecting the appropriate lighting strategy for your greenhouse crops. Understanding Photoperiodic Lighting The number of hours of light in a 24-hour period (photoperiod) controls flowering of both short-day and long-day crops. It is actually the uninterrupted period of darkness that controls flowering responses. Long-day plants are those that only flower […]

Read More

November 14, 2013

Comparing LED Lighting To HPS Lamps For Plug Production

Research at Purdue University is determining how LEDs, providing light of different wavelengths, compare to traditional high-pressure sodium lamps.

Read More

August 6, 2012

Capillary Mats Are Back

Thirty years ago, capillary mats were used for production of floricultural pot crops like Easter lilies. The advantage was that plants could be grown practically pot-to-pot, thus maximizing plants per square foot. Also, since Easter lilies grow best when fertigated with tempered water delivered on a uniform schedule, the capillary mat was ideal. During the 1990s, capillary mats for growing plants fell out of favor as a fertigation method when compared to drip irrigation and other sub-irrigation methods. However, recent advances in electronic controls, mat composition and the use of a drip tape to deliver water directly to the mat at even locations, make cap-mat watering worthy of another look. Combine this with concerns about groundwater contamination, quantity, quality and costs associated with water usage, cap mats and their low-water requirements will certainly come back into the greenhouse growing picture. There are a number of capillary mat types available, each […]

Read More

July 9, 2012

Save Water With Automation And Sensors

Automating irrigation is a great way to save water. One of the latest innovations in irrigation automation is the use of substrate moisture sensors to trigger irrigation. These sensors are relatively inexpensive and, when used, can conserve water and, consequently, reduce pollution and the amount of money spent on electricity for pumps in wells. A wide variety of annual and perennial plants may be irrigated with as little as 0.3 to 1.3 gallons of water for the entire cropping cycle using substrate moisture sensors. Sensors Ensure Proper Substrate Moisture For High-Quality Plants Most substrate moisture sensors literally measure the amount of water in soils. This is usually expressed by volume, as the ratio of the volume of water to the volume of substrate in a pot (substrate moisture content percent = (volume of water xvolume of substrate) / 100). In peat-based substrates, the substrate moisture content of 45 to 50 […]

Read More

April 26, 2012

Subirrigation: Watering From The Ground Up

The goal for any irrigation system is to deliver water to the growing medium as effectively and efficiently as possible. Effectively means getting the right amount of water into the growing medium. Efficiently means minimizing the amount of water that is lost from the system.  In order to irrigate effectively, an irrigation system must deliver water uniformly to every pot in an irrigation zone. An efficient irrigation system will either deliver water with minimal leaching and runoff or capture and reuse all the water that is not retained in the growing medium. Sub-irrigation systems are generally both more effective and efficient than top-down systems. These systems include capillary mats, troughs, flood and drain trays and flood floors. Capillary Mats The simplest form of sub-irrigation, in these systems water is delivered to a porous mat that is in contact with the bottom of the container. This allows water to move from […]

Read More

April 24, 2012

Hand Watering, Booms, Sprinklers Or Drip?

The amount of water that can be held by the substrate in a given container with a specific irrigation method is the effective water-holding capacity (EWHC). It may be desirable to maintain the moisture content of the medium below EWHC in order to regulate plant growth or reduce the risk of soil-borne diseases. Overall, it is important to irrigate thoroughly. The amount of water applied must be sufficient to re-wet the entire volume of growing medium. If the medium is dry and not enough water is applied, only part of the mix will be re-wetted. In irrigating thoroughly, the method of delivery plays an important role. With top-down irrigation, water will be pulled downward by the force of gravity. As it moves downward, some will be held by the growing medium. Usually, some water will escape from the bottom of the pot before the medium is thoroughly wet. At the […]

Read More