Comparing LED Lighting To High-Pressure Sodium Lamps

Figure 1. Spectral quality of 70 µmol•m–2•s–1 delivered from high-pressure sodium (HPS) lamps or light-emitting diodes (LEDs) with (percent) 100:0, 85:15, or 70:30 red:blue light.

Cuttings of vegetatively propagated bedding plants are frequently rooted in late winter and early spring to meet the spring and early summer market demand for flowering bedding plants. However, this is also the time when dirty and old glazing material, interior superstructures, and hanging baskets suspended above benches reduce already seasonally low ambient outdoor daily light integrals (DLIs) inside the greenhouse.

Increasing the DLI during propagation has been shown to improve growth and quality of rooted cuttings, as well as reduce time to flower after transplanting. While maintaining clean glazing material, minimizing superstructure and reducing the density of hanging baskets may increase greenhouse DLI, the only way to appreciably increase DLI is to provide supplemental or photosynthetic lighting.

Light-emitting diodes (LEDs) are solid-state, semi-conducting diodes that can emit light from ~250 nm to ≥1000 nm. There are several features of LEDs that make them attractive alternatives to high-pressure sodium (HPS) lamps. First, LEDs can produce narrow-spectrum light at wavebands useful for plant growth and development, including blue (450 nm) and red (660 nm). Additionally, LEDs currently have a luminous efficiency of 38 percent (red) to 50 percent (blue) in converting energy to light and an estimated life of 50,000 luminous hours or more.

The interest in the use of LEDs is increasing in commercial plant production, and this is seen in the ever-increasing number of LED arrays seen in the marketplace. However, the impact and science underlying the use of LEDs as a supplemental light source in ornamental plant propagation of cuttings (liners) and seedlings (plugs) are not clear. Our goal in this study was to determine how LEDs providing light comprised of different wavelengths would stack up against HPS lamps when supplemental light was used
in propagation.

Preparing Cuttings For The Study
Unrooted cuttings of New Guinea impatiens, zonal geranium and petunia were received at Purdue University. They were subsequently stuck into 105-cell propagation trays filled with a substrate composed of (by volume) 1 part perlite and 2 parts soilless substrate (Fafard Mix 2). The trays of cuttings were then sprayed with a surfactant to minimize water collecting on the leaves and placed under mist in the greenhouse.

Immediately after being placed into propagation, cuttings were fertilized with 50 ppm N from a balanced fertilizer (Jack’s Professional 13-2-13 Plug Special LX). For the first seven days (the callusing period), the DLI was maintained at ~5 mol•m−2•d−1 and the air and substrate temperatures were maintained at 73°F.

After seven days, when roots started to appear at the base of the stem, cuttings were placed under one of four supplemental lighting treatments, each providing 70 µmol•m-2•s−1. One group of cuttings was propagated under HPS lamps, while the other cuttings were propagated under LED light comprised of different ratios of red:blue light, including 100:0, 85:15 and 70:30. The spectral distribution of the supplemental light from the HPS lamp and LED lights are shown in Figure 1.

Comparing Growth Of Cuttings Under Different Light Sources
Our first objective was to determine if light from LEDs varying in wavelength would affect cutting growth and morphology when compared to cuttings rooted under HPS lamps.

For New Guinea impatiens and geraniums, we saw virtually no statistical differences between cuttings rooted under HPS lamps or any of the LED light treatments. The root and shoot dry weight, stem length and stem caliper were all similar.

However, petunias exhibited a slightly different response. There was a slight increase in the root and shoot dry weight for petunia cuttings rooted under the LED lights, while stem length was also slightly shorter. However, while these differences were statistically significant, we didn’t find the results to have much commercial significance since the differences were so small. For example, the petunia cuttings rooted under LEDs were about one-fifth of an inch shorter than cuttings rooted under HPS lamps.

We also measured the photosynthetic rates of the cuttings under the different light treatments. Again, there were no differences in gas exchange for New Guinea impatiens, geranium and petunia across the different lighting treatments. While some LED manufacturers have claimed that light from LEDs will result in an increase in photosynthesis, our study found nothing that would support this claim.

In addition to the growth and photosynthesis of cuttings, we wanted to see if LEDs had any effect on the cuttings after transplanting. We observed little effect of supplemental light source during propagation on growth and morphology of finished plants. This included time to flower, stem length, node number below the first flower or inflorescence, flower bud number and the shoot dry weight.

The only significant effects observed were a slightly greater stem length and dry mass for petunias grown from cuttings propagated under 85:15 red:blue light when compared to plants finished from cuttings propagated under HPS lamps. Again, while statistically significant, they have little impact or commercial  significance.

Finally, in addition to quantifying the effects of LEDs on the growth and flowering of cuttings, we wanted to assess the energy use of the different supplemental lights. The daily energy consumption of the HPS, and 100:0, 85:15, or 70:30 red:blue LEDs was 3.01, 3.29, 3.43, and 4.06 kWh•d-1, respectively. Blue light (450 nm) is a higher-energy light compared to red (635 nm), causing an increase in energy consumption with an increasing percentage of blue light.

Additionally, while LEDs do not produce radiant heat with the light that is emitted, there is heat generated by the diode itself. In order to maximize the long lifespan of LEDs, the heat must be removed from the diode and this can be achieved passively, with a material that would act as a heat sink, or actively with the use of air cooling.

Although the LEDs consumed more energy, the fans used to air-cool the arrays consumed 1.49 kWh per day and accounted for 37 to 45 percent of the total energy consumption for each LED array. Using a passive heat sink would reduce the energy use and, therefore, operating costs of the LED lights. However, a passive heat sink would also likely increase the size of the fixtures and initial investment cost.

When you are looking at LEDs for use as a supplemental light source, make sure to see how the LED lights are cooled and weigh the pros and cons of the energy consumption of actively cooled, minimal-shading lights versus passively cooled LEDs that could potentially increase shade in the greenhouse.

LED Lights Are Comparable With HPS Lamps
We found few differences among cuttings of New Guinea impatiens, geraniums or petunias propagated under HPS or LED lights. Furthermore, we observed no significant differences among cuttings grown under the different combinations of red and blue light from LEDs. As a result, we feel that LEDs are a suitable alternative supplemental light source for use during cutting propagation. However, our study highlighted the impact of LED design on the electrical efficiency of LED lights.

Next time you are considering using LED lights in your greenhouse, be sure to consider all the factors involved in LED design, including energy consumption and shading of LED arrays. For more information on LEDs, visit our team website at:

Topics: ,

Leave a Reply

More From Greenhouses...

March 4, 2015

Nexus Corporation’s Cheryl Longtin Encourages Women To Seek Volunteer Leadership Opportunities

When Cheryl Longtin came to the horticulture business in 1994, she applied her experience in the automotive industry to promote the adoption of more technology in greenhouse production. Longtin says horticulture, with its rich family tradition, has long promoted women in the industry compared to other industries, but women in horticulture must continue to seek out opportunities to provide volunteer leadership in organizations that shape the future of the business.

Read More

March 4, 2015

Second Annual GreenhouseConnect Will Bring Growers and Suppliers Together in San Diego This October

Following a successful inaugural event in Tampa last fall, Greenhouse Grower has announced the dates of its second annual GreenhouseConnect: October 26-29, 2015. Representatives of an expected two dozen leading greenhouse operations from across the U.S. will join senior-level suppliers at Rancho Bernardo Inn in San Diego for several days of one-on-one strategic meetings, a growers-only roundtable, informational sessions and a variety of networking events.

Read More
cultivate'15 logo

March 4, 2015

Cultivate’15: AmericanHort Announces What’s New

In an industry that has seen major changes occurring at a fast pace, many industry professionals leave Cultivate with their heads spinning and no clear idea of how to regroup and strategize. Cultivate’15 is “Changing the Game.” As this year’s focus, Changing the Game will call your attention to the ways in which our industry has changed and your opportunities to compete successfully.

Read More
Latest Stories
Rough Brothers aeroponic greenhouse project

February 24, 2015

Rough Brothers Takes A Hands-On Approach To Several Pro…

Two projects Rough Brothers worked on for Altman plants in Giddings, Texas, and Scissortail Farms in Tulsa County, Okla., show that pre-planning on the grower's part opens the way for a smooth-running expansion project.

Read More
Stuppy Greenhouse Manufacturing's Rainbow Super Structure

February 23, 2015

Stuppy Greenhouse Manufacturing Says Every Customer’s G…

Well-suited greenhouses that function efficiently for customers arise from involving them in the design process from start to finish. Stuppy Greenhouse Manufacturing put this philosophy on a greenhouse design for a wholesale grower looking to expand his annuals operation. The grower's needs were simple, yet daunting: design a greenhouse that delivers the perfect growing environment, but keep maintenance and operating costs low.

Read More
National Greenhouse Manufacturers Association

January 27, 2015

Stricter Energy Codes May Impact Your Ability To Expand

Are you aware stricter energy codes may be on the horizon that will certainly impact your business in a big way? Here's a Q & A from the National Greenhouse Manufacturers Association that helps explain the dangers of the coming energy codes and what we as an industry can do to prevent them.

Read More

January 27, 2015

10 Questions To Ask Before Purchasing A Greenhouse Cove…

Whether you’re replacing an existing greenhouse covering or building a new greenhouse, it’s a significant investment, so you need to make sure you have the right type of covering to suit your needs and budget. What’s more, with production costs on the rise, you can’t afford to have anything less than a durable, high-quality covering that is energy efficient. To make a smart purchase, do your homework before you buy. A good place to start is by answering the following questions, which will help you separate the good products from the mediocre ones.

Read More

January 26, 2015

Greenhouse Growers Look To Build And Retrofit In 2015

You’re likely to see more construction work going on in the greenhouse industry in 2015, according to Greenhouse Grower’s 2015 State of the Industry survey. Responses show growers have high hopes for the future, which may be one reason why more of them are looking to spruce up their facilities.

Read More
Griffin Logo

November 10, 2014

Griffin Announces Dates For 2015 Grower And Retailer Ex…

Griffin Grower and Retailer Expo 2015 dates set for Massachusetts and Pennsylvania.

Read More

September 30, 2014

Emerald Coast Growers Adds Greenhouse Space To Increase…

Emerald Coast Growers has expanded with the addition of 25,344 square feet at their Milton, Fla., facility. The construction is in response to increased demand for their products, and will primarily be used for ornamental grass production.

Read More

June 6, 2014

High Tunnels: Reduce Heating Costs While Improving Bedd…

This is the first article in a two-part series featuring research from Purdue University that focuses on energy-efficient production of cold-tolerant bedding plants.

Read More

May 27, 2014

4 Ways To Finance Your Greenhouse Upgrade

If you’re ready to invest in greenhouse energy-efficient upgrades but aren’t sure how to finance them, there are a number of resources that can help.

Read More

May 22, 2014

Structures Issue: Growers Evolve With New Growth And Ma…

Is our industry really improving or does it just look that way? With growth in the past two years among Greenhouse Grower’s Top 100 Growers and the housing market on the upswing, the economy certainly is showing signs of life.

Read More

May 21, 2014

Lucas Greenhouses Gets A Jump On Spring Crops With Its …

A retractable roof greenhouse enables Lucas Greenhouses to start and finish part of its spring crop earlier and provides a superior production environment into the fall.

Read More

May 2, 2014

High Tunnels Help To Expand Markets, Crops

Growers are taking advantage of the USDA-Natural Resources Conservation Service’s Seasonal High Tunnel Initiative to extend the production season for a variety of crops.

Read More

April 24, 2014

9 High Tunnel And Shade Products For Your Operation

Extend the growing season and enhance plant quality with these nine high tunnel and shade products.

Read More
National Greenhouse Manufacturers Association

March 21, 2014

Greenhouse Heating Basics From The National Greenhouse …

Here's a Q&A from the National Greenhouse Manufacturers Association that might help you improve your greenhouse.

Read More
Greenhouse interior At Corsos

March 18, 2014

Will Greenhouses Add Production Space In 2014?

For those who are making changes this year, many responded that new production space will be used to extend their growing seasons, for early-season sales as well as edibles during the winter months.

Read More

February 25, 2014

Behind The New Greenhouse Projects At Van de Wetering A…

Read about the projects VB Greenhouses worked on at Van de Wetering Greenhouses and Kurtz Farms.

Read More

February 25, 2014

7 Spring Cleaning Tips For Commercial Greenhouses

During every busy shipping season you invariably run into issues that would have been eliminated had a little spring cleaning taken place. Here are a few points you may want to consider before spring shipping rolls around:

Read More

January 21, 2014

Exclusive: Danziger Is Building A State-Of-The-Art Stoc…

The breeder is constructing almost nine acres of state-of-the-art greenhouses near Barbarena, Guatemala, to bring its stock farm closer to the U.S. market. The first phase of construction was complete in February 2014.

Read More