Dye-Infused Plants: The Point The Industry Is Missing

'Princess Alexia' anthurium

Fake. Repulsive. Garbage.

They’re among the many harsh words critics have used to describe ‘Blue Mystique,’ the dye-infused orchid Silver Vase unveiled at the 2011 Tropical Plant Industry Exhibition (TPIE). ‘Blue Mystique’ has undoubtedly been subjected to more criticism in the last year from within the industry than any other variety. The criticisms are mainly focused on how the blue orchid is produced and how it was, at one time, marketed.

The dye-infusion technique, critics argue, is an insult to the breeders who develop more natural varietal differences in orchids and other plants. The main criticism of Silver Vase’s marketing was that consumers initially weren’t aware the blue orchid they were purchasing reblooms white.

Silver Vase has since developed a message for tags, signage and its website that ‘Blue Mystique’ does indeed rebloom white. But, the technique Silver Vase uses to make orchids blue continues to rock a number of horticulturists at their core. Richard Drummond, the owner of Landscape Logistics, a 12-acre landscape supply company and retail nursery, is one horticulturist who’s sounded off on ‘Blue Mystique’ and the dye-infusion technique.

“Anyone can dye a plant blue but I absolutely do not understand how this trickery has come to be legitimized by any respectable nursery, retailer, wholesaler, broker or customer,” Drummond says. “This is an insult to all true botanists – past, present and future – especially those who were intelligent, determined and astute enough to develop true varietal differences in orchids or any other type of real plant.”

Drummond and others are entitled to their opinions. But if consumers truly want ‘Blue Mystique’ and other dye-infused plants – and based on the demand Silver Vase has had for it, consumers do – does it really matter what those in the supply chain think of the orchid?

The Unique Opportunity

The question is one the Silver Vase team considered long before it introduced ‘Blue Mystique’ at TPIE. But considering the industry desperately needs to cultivate new customers and few varieties generate “wows,” Silver Vase wasn’t afraid to take a chance in this instance.

“We knew since the beginning we were going to be facing [criticism], but we were ready to take on the heat,” says Marcella Lucio, Silver Vase’s marketing director. “We wouldn’t have any buzz if we were passé. You have to keep up with the times. There are new techniques coming and we tried this one out. We thought it would generate some opportunity, so we went and ahead and did it.”

 

‘Blue Mystique’ proved to be the opportunity of the year for Silver Vase. The orchid opened a new door with existing customers and gave non-customers a reason to give the South Florida grower a call. Plus, the new color resonated with consumers despite the retail price ranging between $29.99 and $39.99.

“A lot of the consumers who ventured out don’t have a lot of disposable income,” Lucio says. “But they told themselves they could make this expense because it’s so unique that they’ll enjoy it for the price they’re paying.”

‘Blue Mystique’ isn’t for everyone, of course. Fortunately, Lucio gets that. She has her own product preferences, but her job as a marketer is to keep an open mind to the consumer’s vast preferences and not her own. Marketers who target consumers narrowly are ones bound to serve a limited market, after all.

“There are different tastes out there and we have to open our minds to that,” Lucio says. “Sometimes, I get lost in my own personal opinion and taste, but I can’t do that because not everyone is Marcella and not everyone likes what I like. So we have to think about what the consumer, particularly women, like.”

Silver Vase Isn’t Alone

Silver Vase isn’t the only grower worldwide who’s adopted the dye-infusion technique. Eurocactus is producing echeverias in wild colors, and RijnPlant Breeding is offering its Princess Alexia anthuriums in blue and yellow. Both companies are based in the Netherlands, and RijnPlant saw the same market opportunity Silver Vase did.

“Dying the plants draws the interest of a wider public, and that’s good for the industry,” says Michel van Rijn, director of RijnPlant. “We shouldn’t forget that too many consumers nowadays don’t buy plants at all or judge plants as ‘not exciting enough.’”

RijnPlant, like Silver Vase, spent considerable time trialing the dye-infused Princess Alexias. In RijnPlant’s case, van Rijn says two years were spent trialing the anthuriums before they were taken to market. He also indicates the paint used for dye in Princess Alexias derives from the food industry. So in some ways the process is natural, van Rijn says.

Consumer safety is yet another reason for extensive Mystique trials at Silver Vase.

“We are doing ours in a safe way, ensuring that plants last for the end consumer and that there’s nothing harmful about it for anybody,” Lucio says.

Takeaways

After a year of passionate debate about the dye-infusion technique, Lucio has few, if any, regrets about pushing the Mystiques to market. After all, the opportunities the orchid line created for Silver Vase have been tremendous.

“The biggest opportunity for us was to be heard and put on everyone’s radar,” Lucio says. “Yes, the sales came, but the opportunity to have people contact us is the number one thing we’ve gained with the Mystique line.”

Still, one lesson Silver Vase learned in having such a popular premium line is that sales of other products can suffer. To many of Silver Vase’s newest customers, the operation is the one that grows the blue orchid. But Silver Vase also offers a large assortment of Phalaenopsis orchids and bromeliads, and it doesn’t want customers to lose sight of those lines.

“In the very beginning, some focus did shift away from our assortment because everybody was asking us about blues,” Lucio says. “We got very involved with everything related to the Mystiques that we probably put the assortment in the backseat.

“But the regular [Phalaenopsis] are our bread and butter. We don’t know where these Mystiques are going to go – are they long lasting or a huge trend that in five years no one takes advantage of? So we’ve got to go back to offering what we are all about.”

Topics:

Leave a Reply

23 comments on “Dye-Infused Plants: The Point The Industry Is Missing

  1. On 1/16/2012, I purchased a blue orchid. The cost was 39.99 plus tax. Had I known that this plant would rebloom white I would never had made that purchase. There is nothing on the tag that indicates this orchid will rebloom white, I still have that tag and can prove it. I feel like I have been scammed and being a widow on a fixed income, I am extremely sorry I have been duped into believing this orchid would stay blue.

  2. In reference to your blue orchid which I just purchased, since I live just south of Ocala and am not too far from Homestead, can I bring my plant back to you, after the blooms drop, for a reinfusion?

  3. Just a little not to say……….I did not read the tag because I just assumed that the color of the flowers were what they are! Who wouldn!!! Well I paid 25.00 ea. for the blue and the Lila… Was very disapointed to find out that they come back white.. If I had wanted white I would have bought white.. I'd like them to stay the color I bought… Alot of trouble to take them back.. 50.00 plus tax is a lot of money……….. Still disapointed!!!!

  4. Seems to me like others r disapointed too about the flowers not staying the color they r when u buy them… U send me the info or what to infuse them with!! The color I want is the color flower I bought!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  5. Yes, disappointment here, too. The tag is misleading and does not specifically say blue does not last. Want my money back or the recipe to make it blue again!

  6. Lighten up people. The flowers are beautilul and the tag does say next blooming will be white.. I got a blue for my wife on mothers day and she loved it. Hard to choose which color is prettiest though. Can the die be purchased or will food coloring work? Would apprecieage knowing. Thank You

  7. My wonderful son purchased one of your blue phalaenopis orchids for me for Mother's day. It is lovely and we have thoroughly enjoyed it. Now it is sending out a new spike of blooms which are of course white. I am not disappointed, I knew when he gave it to me that it had been colored and would not repeat. I still love it and am thrilled that it is happy and reblooming. I love phalaenopis orchids no matter the color. Thank you for the pleasant experience of a blue orchid which matched my living room decor perfectly.

  8. I BOUGT MY ORCHID AT KROGERS,FOR 29.99.THE FLORIST THERE TOLD ME THAT THE FLOWER HAD BEEN DYED,BUT BY ADDING FOOD COLOR TO THE PLANT,THE NEW GROTH WOULD BE BLUE AGAIN. OVER WATERING,UNDER WATERING AND FAILING TO FEED THE FLOWER IS THE DEATH WARRANT. I'LL BUY AGAIN. BY THE WAY MS.MADDOX,WHATS AN ELDERLY LADY ON A FIXED INCOME DOING SPENDING 39.99 ON A FLOWER?

    1. Too bad about your ‘CAPS LOCK’ key being stuck.

      Mrs. Maddox never mentioned her age. My sister was a widow at age forty four. It happens.

      People on fixed incomes shouldn’t be able to buy something beautiful? Shame on you. I think that what she objected to was spending her precious money on a sham. If the orchid had been truly blue each time it bloomed, I don’t think she would have complained. She was tricked, conned and, unlike more financially fortunate people, it might have been a more painful experience for her.

  9. i also was fooled i purchased ! orchid and loved it assuming it was indeed a color variety my husband purchased another for me for my birthday a year later when it rebloomed white i was disgusted that i was taken for the money i spent on it we should all be given the dye free of charge to keep the blue color we were not warned like purchasers now are. it is a shame for someone to make money under false pretenses!!!!

  10. It's Christmas morning and I just gave my hubbie his Mystic Blue Orchid. He was soooo excited. He has looked at this plant at least a dozen times and committed how he would love to have one. After he read the label he brought it to me and said "how disappointing ". So we went straight to your web site to investigate this dye infused orchid. By the way…we had no idea it was even possible to do this to orchids. It was soooo worth every bit of the $29.99 for a"BLUE ORCHID " but not for a white one. We will enjoy this bloom but VERY DISAPPOINTED that once it's finished blooming the BLUE orchid will be gone.

  11. Yes, if anyone finds out how to make my purple orchid purple again, let me know, I know most people say its food coloring? I would be willing to give it a Shot LOL?

  12. I just purchased a Mintie Mystique orchid as I was struck by the soft green color with a darker center tinged with blue. It is a truly stunning flower. Now that I have the flower home, I fully read the tag and see that it's a white orchid. My fault for not reading but I never knew you could dye orchids. I am extremely disappointed and never would have spent the money for a plain white orchid. Would Silver Vase consider selling infusion kits? If not, I will steer clear of their products and read labels completely before buying. My pleasure over this special treat for myself has been totally deflated.

  13. Incredibly disappointed that this company sells plants that will re-bloom in a different color. Pointing out that the tag specifies this is ridiculous. WHY would I read the tag before buying it? Perhaps a big red warning tag would be more appropriate. I feel taken, which significantly puts a damper on the pleasure I would have gotten from the flowers. I will make sure to buy from companies OTHER than Silver Vase in the future.

  14. Lee Fennell was my grandfather. If you do not know who he is then you really haven't been part of the Orchid growers in the US. He must be flipping in his grave about an orchid that was dyed to become another colored flower. He spent many long nights and days with his orchids. All the original orchids he collected were kept at the Orchid Jungle. Only the hybrids were sold all over the US. I have 20 flowering now out of the 25 and only 5 that have not sent up a shoot. Guess what color they were when I bought them?

  15. I guess I was not the only one duped about the color, although true blue is an unusual color for many flowers. I carefully took the tag off when I got home, it was in a spot I wouldn't have been able to read the back in the store and in print too small for me to read without glasses anyway. What a surprise that it says it will come back "gorgeous white", there is no real indication that this was a dyed flower in plain sight, I didn't even realize that orchards were being dyed to miss-represent the color. The only real reason to look at the tag on most flowers is to find the care instructions not to be informed you that you have been "taken" and your beautiful expensive blue orchard will become a common place white inexpensive one on the next blooming. I guess we live in a day and age that even buying a flower you can have one put over on you unless you carefully read all the fine print.

  16. I paid 29.99 for my Blue Mystique. The tag says nothing about me blooms being white. I had no idea and now looking at this boring white bloom, still in it’s fancy Silver Vase vase, I am furious. I feel ripped-off and I am going to complain to Silver Vase and Home Depot.

  17. I have never had an orchid bloom so long as the Silver Vase orchid still blooming its head off on my counter right now, on January 4 having been bought on October 9, 2013. When my boyfriend gave it to me in October I loved it but said to myself, “he doesn’t know that without buds on it, this orchid surely won’t bloom long. I would have chosen one with lots of buds.” Well, just today I see one of the first blooms on a spike is just beginning to fade and curl. There are 14 other beautiful blooms on two spikes. I am enjoying this beauty tremendously!

    These other comments seem to be all about the blue dyed orchid so maybe I’m leaving my comment in the wrong place. Just for the record, though I wouldn’t buy a deep blue orchid because I know it is not a natural color, I am happy some grower has made them available for people who are seeking that color for whatever reason they might have: a Hanuka color, room decor, July 4 celebration?

    I sought out your website specifically to tell you how very happy I am with my Silver Vase purple Phalaenopsis orchid. I want to be sure you know that from now on I will be seeking out the Silver Vase name on a tag before purchasing on orchid or bromeliad.

  18. It is disingenuous of the “grower” to say that it’s doing all it can to educate consumers that the plants they are buying will not re-bloom blue or violet or whatever color they were “infused” with prior to sale. It’s trickery nonetheless…why would any reasonable person think that the flowering plant they are purchasing won’t flower the same color next time? Why not just sell them a can of floral spray dye with every plant…at least then they can have a bloom the color that they originally purchased when new buds and blooms appear on the plant. It’s a slippery slope, and the integrity of the industry is the victim along with the consumer.

  19. My son bought my orchid for me on Valentines day last year, I knew by looking at it that is was dyed. It was so pretty I didn’t care that it was going to bloom white the next time. I still have it and blue it is not, but beautiful it is still.

Latest Stories
shade-trials-OKSU

January 22, 2018

2017 Oklahoma State University Field Trials Results

Check out the 2017 field trial results for Oklahoma State University in Oklahoma City, OK.

Read More
Company-Culture-at-AgBiome

January 22, 2018

Four Ways to Attract Employees With a New Approach to C…

AgBiome is a participative, self-managed organization where no one has a boss. Instead, employees self-assemble as teams around organizational issues that need to be tackled, and internal experts help drive important decisions.

Read More
NatureFresh-Farms-Bug-Brigade-feature

January 22, 2018

Don’t Miss Opportunities to Market Your Biocontro…

Our industry can do a better job of spreading the word to customers and the public about how we’re using biopesticides and other biocontrols.

Read More
Pennisetum-Feathertop_Feature-Image_NDSU

January 21, 2018

2017 North Dakota State University Field Trials

Check out the 2017 field trial results for North Dakota State University Department of Plant Sciences in Fargo, ND.

Read More
National-Floriculture-Forum-photo

January 21, 2018

2018 National Floriculture Forum Heads to Florida

The event takes place March 2-4, and will feature tours of local floriculture operations, as well as discussions from industry leaders.

Read More
Colorado-Greenhouse-Lighting-Research

January 20, 2018

New Tech Could Lead to More Efficient Use of Light in t…

Working with a $2.45 million USDA grant, a team of University of Colorado Boulder researchers are developing a scalable, cost-effective new greenhouse material.

Read More
Dynamax-SM150-Kit-feature

January 20, 2018

Soil Moisture Sensor Designed for Durability and Accura…

The new SM150T soil moisture sensor from Dynamax was developed to measure soil moisture and temperature with research-grade accuracy.

Read More
Mixture-of-Begonia-Megawatt-and-Whopper-series_OSU

January 19, 2018

2017 The Ohio State University Field Trial Results

Check out the 2017 field trial results for The Ohio State University/Chadwick Arboretum in Columbus, OH.

Read More
Sedeveria-Lilac-Mist-feature

January 19, 2018

Hot-Selling Succulents Remain Hip, With No End in Sight

Succulents continue to fascinate people of all ages and gardening abilities. Perhaps that’s because they still have the right stuff to attract attention.

Read More
lucas-greenhouses-plant-roots-growing-mix

January 19, 2018

8 Opportunities to Help You Prepare for the Spring Grow…

Three New England universities are collaborating on a weekly webinar program covering topics such as pest management, making the most of growing media, and more.

Read More
Laura Drotleff

January 19, 2018

Greenhouse Industry’s Positive Momentum Looks Like it W…

Results from Greenhouse Grower's 2018 State of the Industry survey show that growers increased profits in 2017 by raising prices and paying more attention to their operational costs.

Read More
Heuchera-Northern-Exposure-Black-Terra-Nova-Nurseries

January 18, 2018

Terra Nova Adds Two New Heuchera to its Northern Exposu…

Terra Nova Nurseries has created plant profile pages specific to these new varieties so growers can learn about their growing habits and plant characteristics.

Read More
Whitefly-Feeding-on-Poinsettias-feature

January 18, 2018

Mitigating Whiteflies in Ornamental Production

Gain better control over common greenhouse and nursery pests with these best practices.

Read More
Max-Luthy-TPIE-keynote

January 18, 2018

TPIE Keynote Maxwell Luthy Turns Trends Into Opportunit…

Maxwell Luthy, Director of Trends & Insights for TrendWatching, showed how to turn trends into business prospects for attendees of the 2018 Tropical Plant International Expo keynote address.

Read More
Hanging-Basket-Trimmer-at-Kube-Pak-feature

January 17, 2018

Self-Designed Hanging Basket Trimmer at Kube-Pak Saves …

Kube-Pak recently designed its own trimmer to improve efficiency in hanging basket production. The early returns have been very promising.

Read More
2017 North Carolina University Field Trials

January 17, 2018

2017 North Carolina State University Field Trial Result…

Check out the 2017 field trial results for North Carolina State University/JC Raulston Arboretum in Raleigh, NC.

Read More

January 16, 2018

Ball Horticultural Company, KeyGene Announce Successful…

The companies’ breakthrough high-quality genome sequence and assembly of I. walleriana should lead to more efficient breeding and identification of disease resistance markers for important industry solutions.

Read More
Golden-State-Bulb-Begonia-Feature

January 16, 2018

PanAmerican Seed Buys Begonia Product Line From Golden …

The acquisition of the popular AmeriHybrid and On Top begonia genetics expands PanAmerican Seed’s assortment in this important class.

Read More