Proven Winners Is The 2012 Medal Of Excellence Industry Achievement Winner

Proven Winners Partners

Proven Winners didn’t invent the idea of a plant brand. There have been many other good ones before and since. But few — if any — have been as influential.

The 2012 winner of Greenhouse Grower’s Medal of Excellence Industry Achievement Award has introduced groundbreaking new varieties and taken consumer marketing to never-before-seen heights. In the process, it has built one of the few truly successful national plant brands in the history of our industry.

Now in its 20th year, this company has succeeded with a laser-like focus on great plants and great marketing, coupled with an absolute conviction that the Proven Winners way is the best way to sell plants.

Take a look at two decades of results. It’s hard to argue that they’re wrong.

From A Single Plant To A Brand

The seeds of Proven Winners were planted in 1991. The Kientzler Company’s Garry Grueber had a unique plant from Australia — Scaevola ‘Blue Wonder’ — and was looking for help distributing it in the U.S. He found willing partners in John Rader and Evelyn Weidner of Weidner’s Gardens in Encinitas, Calif.

After a year of successful sales regionally, Rader, Weidner and Grueber realized there was potential for the variety on a bigger scale, but they would need partners to expand to national distribution.

Tom and Sharon Smith, owners of Four Star Greenhouses in Michigan, and Henry and Jeff Huntington of Pleasant View Gardens in New Hampshire agreed to help. Rader soon partnered with Jerry Church to buy the propagation business from Weidner’s Gardens and formed EuroAmerican Propagators as the third partner. Proven Winners was born.

Plants For The Consumer

From the beginning, the partners agreed the Proven Winners brand would have two cornerstone qualities to differentiate it in the market.
The first was great plants. The Proven Winners brand would sell only the best quality, unique varieties that would have high value for consumers. Annuals were the primary focus for the first ten-plus years. Canadian partners Nordic Nurseries, Ed Sobkowich Greenhouses and Dentooms Greenhouse were brought in later in the 1990s. Proven Winners ColorChoice Flowering Shrubs were added in partnership with Spring Meadow Nursery in 2004. Walters Gardens was brought on board in 2010 to provide a selection of premium perennials under the Proven Winners brand.

The list of unique new introductions under the Proven Winners banner — from Superbells to Supertunia to Diamond Frost to Snow Princess — is long and familiar. But for all of these lines, top garden performance quality was the top priority.

“The partners said, ‘We’re going to take the best plants available from plant breeders. We’re going to trial them for two to three years. And we’re going to introduce the best varieties as Proven Winners.’ That was the model,” says Proven Winners Director of Marketing Marshall Dirks.

Four Star, EuroAmerican, and Pleasant View have been leaders in developing new propagation techniques, implementing university research in areas such as quicker liner production and faster finishing times for growers. Plants are propagated from mother stock derived from aseptic tissue culture to offer the cleanest selections possible.

Even with this focus of providing the best possible starts for growers, plants are selected for the brand based on garden performance that consumers will respond to, instead of the more traditional grower-focused input traits.
According to Dirks, many breeders have been typically focused on grower performance: uniform series, blooming times and growth habits — compact growers that looked good at retail.

“The partners realized, ‘That’s nice, but that’s not our customer. Our customer is the gardener. We need to introduce vigorous plants that will make her feel successful when she grows them.’ That was the key,” he says.

Building A Market

Proven Winners’ second cornerstone quality was great marketing, specifically, great marketing that speaks directly to consumers.
“Our initial marketing was to the industry,” says Mark Broxon, Proven Winners executive director. “In 2001, as our sales reached a critical mass, true consumer marketing began. And once that began, we have kept our foot on the accelerator — which has also been good for the industry as a whole.”

To pay for consumer marketing, plants are sold with a marketing fee. Those dollars provide the resources needed to build awareness and create demand.

“People had collected royalties in the past, but no one had collected a marketing fee. That was unique to Proven Winners,” Dirks says.
The Proven Winners tag was an important innovation as well. The partners determined early on that a large, branded plant tag would accompany every Proven Winners plant.

“From the beginning it was our number-one form of POP,” Dirks says. “The tag was more than 6-inches tall, double the size of the typical tag at the time. It was groundbreaking.”

Those distinctive white containers were a significant development as well, making their first appearance in 2002. Containers were round rather than square to create a premium look and offered an eye-catching pop of white in a garden center full of other colors. Index printing was developed to allow the logo to go in the same place on the container every time, directly under the tag slot. The brand also took a lesson from grocery store shelves and created patented containers that spin in their trays to ensure the logo and the tag always face forward.

Influencing An Industry

From wonderful new varieties to groundbreaking marketing concepts, Proven Winners has built one of the most recognizable and respected brands in the market. Its annual roadshows educate growers and retailers on the brand’s genetics and how to best grow them. It works closely with retailers, offering certified training programs as well as detailed advice on store layout and merchandising.

But, in many ways, the company has made contributions that have benefitted the entire greenhouse industry.

“I think our biggest impact has been to make gardening a better experience for consumers while creating value for the industry,” Broxon says. “We work closely with growers and retailers, but it is the consumer that ultimately buys our plants from those growers and retailers.”
With today’s consumer more time-starved and overwhelmed with choices than ever before, making it easier for them with a known brand and better plants has been the right way to go, Broxon says.

“No other company trials plant varieties to the extent that we do — after breeders have already made their selections — to ensure that our plants provide the highest level of consumer performance. And our investment in consumer marketing benefits the entire industry by bringing consumers into garden centers not only to find Proven Winners plants, but to experience gardening in general. Gardening is a great lifestyle; we believe in this industry and want people to enjoy gardening — and be successful — which keeps them as customers for us all.”

Leave a Reply

4 comments on “Proven Winners Is The 2012 Medal Of Excellence Industry Achievement Winner

  1. It is true that Proven Winners has changed the face of the Industry. But I for one find it a change for the worse. I have worked in the industry for 17 years and have come to avoid most Proven Winners at all costs. First, let me explain that I consider myself a novice Plantsman. With an Associates Degree in Horticulture from a Community College and a Grower of Tropical Plants I know something about plants. The entire Marketing/Branding of Proven Winners immediately put me off. Overnight, every Nursery and Garden center had the hideous, blatant displays. Advertising as far as the eye could see. Everytime I did encounter a Proven Winners Plant that I found new and interesting, upon asking about it, I received a Sales Pitch for Proven Winners Potting Medium, Proven Winners Fertilizers, but not one person knew what the plant was or how to grow it properly, other than quoting me verbatim what was printed on the tag. Proven Winners said they were going to sell to the Industry only and NOT the Big Box Stores….we all know how long that took. And so they have gone from being a plant supplier to a Capitalist Conglomerate. Looking at the price of the Plants, plus the cost of Tags, plus the cost of the pots…it has come to Nurseries and Garden Centers selling 4 1/2" pots for $6 – $7 dollars at some places. Outrageous. With no disrespect to Proven Winners, I personally wish they would go the way of Etera.

  2. When you are on top you will always have haters no matter what you do to try to make everyone happy. Just look at sports teams. I just would like to thank the thousands of customers we have at wholesale and retail that have supported us. Most importantly the consumers who will soon experience close to 2,000,000,000 plants. If someone looked into a crystal ball 20 years ago and predicted that our industry would be selling fewer flats of petunias at what is as low as $7 a flat in my area but selling a single pot of a Petunia for as much as $7 a pot as Kyle points out we would all be saying "Your crazy" Quoting a good friend of mine Bob Steinlage "I would rather be getting shot at than the one doing the shooting. Thanks again to Greenhouse Grower and all the others who have seen our vision to improve the industry. Tom Smith Partner Proven Winners.

  3. As it is time to order for the spring/summer 2013 season, I am still fuming over a Proven Winners incident last year. I grow annuals and perennials for a municipality with large parks and large public gardens. I was going to order some Seniorita Rosalita plugs last year, which I have grown in years past, and was told I had to buy pots and tags with every plug. No exceptions. Our budget has been slashed huge amounts in the last 5 years and the thought of having to pay for plastic pots and large tags when I am not in a retail business, in this day and age, is ridiculous. I appealed to Proven Winners explaining that we are not in the business of selling plants, we only grow for public viewing. But they turned me down. I like the plants, but in this day and age of recycling, waste not want not, budget cuts, labor cuts, I refuse to be bullied in to growing a plant and paying for plastic pots when I already have plenty of plastic pots. If I have any extra in the budget, I'd rather spend money to have more people working than pay for a whole bunch of plastic pots and tags that I do not need!

  4. I don't know what all the fuss is about Proven Winners. So far out of 5 plants I have purchased, 4 have died within 4 weeks. I contacted the company for help with one of the plants and by the time they got back to me (2 weeks), the plant was long dead. I also signed up for the newsletter and free book and have never heard from them. I was on the web searching to see if anyone else thinks PW is just a bunch of hype, charging extra money for a whole lotta extra nothing!

Latest Stories
Joe Lamp'l

July 1, 2016

Gardening Personality Joe Lamp’l Will Be Keynote Speake…

Lamp’l, who hosts the PBS series “Growing a Greener World,” will discuss effective ways to build your business and keep your customers.

Read More
Cannabis states 2016

July 1, 2016

Adult Use Of Cannabis On The Ballot In 2016

25 states have legalized cannabis and public opinion is increasingly positive. Here’s where things may be headed as we move toward the fall elections.

Read More
University of Georgia Trial Gardens

June 30, 2016

First-Ever Academy Of Crop Production Offers Snapshot O…

Hosted by the Georgia Green Industry Association and the University of Georgia Department of Horticulture, the three-day conference covered everything from unmanned aerial vehicles to remote-sensing greenhouse control systems.

Read More
SunPatiens Sakata Medal of Excellence Feature

June 29, 2016

SunPatiens Earns The 2016 Medal Of Excellence In Market…

With its reputation for excellent garden performance from spring to frost, and as a problem-solver for Impatiens Downy Mildew, SunPatiens has become a “hero plant” that helps gardeners succeed.

Read More
Kelly Norris - feature

June 28, 2016

Kelly Norris: Three Variety Trends That Caught My Eye T…

My reflections on promising new plants, the realities of market penetration, and adding value along the supply chain.

Read More

June 28, 2016

10 Things You Need To Do Before And During Cultivate’16

From pre-planning to on-site networking and education, here are 10 things to consider before you depart for Cultivate’16.

Read More

June 28, 2016

How “Brexit” Will Affect The Horticulture Industry

The news this week of Great Britain’s departure from the European Union has sent shockwaves through many industries, including horticulture. Here’s a look at the potential effects of “Brexit” across the horticulture and floriculture industries.

Read More
iPad In Garden Center

June 27, 2016

Inspiring Summer Customers Without A Word Being Said

Now is the time of year to sell your customers what they like, rather than what they need. According to industry consultant Ian Baldwin, one way to do this is to use silent selling techniques and devices that help validate a purchase.

Read More
Oconomowoc

June 27, 2016

Fire Destroys Greenhouses At Oconomowoc Landscape Suppl…

The fire not only consumed the Wisconsin garden retailer's structures, but also major equipment like dump trucks. In all, the owners estimate $1.2 million in damage occurred.

Read More
Robert Conrad, Ball Seed Technology Research Manager

June 27, 2016

Ball Premier Lab Wins Medal Of Excellence Award For Its…

Over the past 30 years, the Ball Premier Lab has set the standard for high-quality seed in the industry, earning it Greenhouse Grower’s 2016 Medal Of Excellence for Industry Achievement, for its dedication to advancing seed and helping growers improve their margins.

Read More
Greenhouse Whitefly

June 26, 2016

Michigan State University Offers Tips On Whitefly Manag…

Whiteflies are making headlines in Florida, but they are found across the U.S. Michigan State experts say it’s important to know how to manage each type of whitefly.

Read More
Schaefer Exhaust Fan

June 26, 2016

What’s New In Greenhouse Cooling

Cooling and ventilation companies, as well as structures suppliers, are working to help growers manage efficiencies. Here are some of their latest innovations.

Read More
Dr Allan Armitage

June 25, 2016

Three Types Of Plant Consumers To Watch

There are three emerging groups of plant consumers that you should be targeting for plant sales in the future, according to Allan Armitage.

Read More
North Creek Nurseries lower trials

June 24, 2016

North Creek Nurseries Is A Finalist For 2016 Operation …

North Creek Nurseries in Landenberg, PA, is one of three finalists for Greenhouse Grower’s 2016 Operation Of The Year award and winner of the Excellence In Sustainable Production award for 2016.

Read More
Cal Poly Logo

June 24, 2016

Cal Poly Ag College Hosting Alumni Reception At Cultiva…

Alumni and friends of The Cal Poly College of Agriculture, Food and Environmental Sciences are invited to a reception that will be held Sunday, July 10.

Read More
Stocking spring plants at Petitti Garden Center FEATURE

June 23, 2016

How Growers Can Help Retailers Sell More In Spring

Fresh from a busy spring season, retailers share their wish list of things growers can do to make spring generate even more sales.

Read More
Houwelings Tomatoes

June 23, 2016

Houweling’s Tomatoes Has A New Corporate Head Grower

Arie van der Giessen, who has led the horticultural operations for many successful regional and national greenhouse operators in North America, will start his new role in September.

Read More
Vic Frey, Kurt Weiss Greenhouses Feature

June 23, 2016

Vic Frey Named A Finalist For 2016 Head Grower Of The Y…

Vic Frey, a finalist for the 2016 Head Grower of the Year and recipient of the 2016 Excellence In Production award, was always willing to trial and experiment with the latest technology. He loved the constant change in this industry, and turned every opportunity into a teaching moment.

Read More
[gravityform id="35" title="false" description="false"]