Poinsettia Growers Discuss Their Recent Trials And Triumphs

Dan Schantz Farm and Greenhouses has been running poinsettia trials since the mid-2000s, supervising 200 cultivar varieties.
Dan Schantz Farm and Greenhouses has been running poinsettia trials since the mid-2000s, supervising 200 cultivar varieties.

Ask top poinsettia growers about the plant’s future, and their responses are emphatic: The No. 1 plant of the holiday season is here to stay.

This response comes straight from the source. Each year, Dan Schantz Farm & Greenhouses, Millstadt Young Plants, and Mitchell’s Nursery & Greenhouse trial the industry’s top varieties hoping to learn which will entice their customers every winter. Here’s what each company had to say about its 2015 trials, triumphs, and plans for the future.

Dan Schantz Farm And Greenhouses: Poinsettias Are The Christmas Plant

When it comes to running successful poinsettia trials, it requires teamwork, dedication, and perhaps a grower with superhuman recall. No one knows this better than Dan Schantz Farm and Greenhouses in Zionsville, PA.

The operation has been running trials since the mid-2000s, supervising 200 cultivar varieties — all with different growing characteristics and habits — each year. This means separating each cultivar by breeder, color, variety, and growing requirements.

How does the operation manage to keep everything straight, even when the chaos of spring takes hold? The farm has a secret weapon in grower Ian Phelps. As the poinsettia point person, Phelps can name a variety simply by looking at it. The trials, though, are more than an experiment in how to build successful organization protocols. Poinsettia trials are an endurance test.

“The trials themselves are not an easy thing to add to an already busy spring and summer schedule, so it is something that needs to be seriously considered before embarking on hosting a trial at your own facility,” says Paul Hardiman, Head Grower at Dan Schantz. “Taking on a trial can be an added expense to the bottom line of a greenhouse operation and requires that growers will have to be dedicated to raising the crop and sticking with it all the way through the trial, which usually happens in November of most years.”

At the end of the trial, however, the company gains first-hand knowledge about how to grow varieties that will perform for and impress its customers. In 2015, the trial judges selected the best red, pink, novelty, and white varieties, also awarding “judge’s favorite” and “best of greenhouse” honors. Hardiman says the standout plants included the Christmas Feelings and Christmas Ribbons series from Selecta, ‘Titan Pink’ from Syngenta, ‘Pallas Red’ from Beekenkamp, and a numbered (but not yet named) variety from Dümmen Orange that was given a “best future possibility” honor. Dan Schantz Farm will likely integrate some or all of these varieties into its production.

In addition to a stellar line-up of poinsettias each year, Michael Foster, Production Assistant at Dan Schantz and mastermind behind the website, PoinsettiaTrial.com, says the trials offer other perks, as well.

“Dan Schantz Farm has hosted the trials, not only for the benefits that it offers us in terms of being able to adjust our regular growing varieties with new introductions that we learn about through the trial,” he says. “But it also allows us to bring together other growers who face these same issues and put them with the breeders who might be able to shed some light on the questions the growers might be facing in their own operations.”

In 2016, Dan Schantz Farm has opted not to take on the responsibilities of a trial. Hardiman says this doesn’t spell the end of the operation’s trials. The decision will be made on a year-to-year basis. Even without the trials, Hardiman and Foster say they believe the plant will continue to be a Christmas-time favorite.

“The future of the poinsettia is probably pretty secure, but presentation of the poinsettia might become more gift-like with decorative sleeves, pot covers that really make each plant very special, and special-buy pots to put the poinsettias in, such as the Santa Boot that was rather popular this year,” Foster says, noting that even with its holiday-season popularity, the crop might not be a fit for every operation.

“For many greenhouses, the poinsettia is a finicky plant to grow, and many of the smaller growers may give up on growing them in their own houses. The slack will be taken up by the larger operations because what would Christmas be without the traditional poinsettia decorating our homes during the season?”

Even with a greenhouse full of beautiful blooms and consistent successes, the Millstadt Young Plant poinsettia trials continue to offer new challenges and opportunities each year
Even with a greenhouse full of beautiful blooms and consistent successes, the Millstadt Young Plant poinsettia trials continue to offer new challenges and opportunities each year

Millstadt Young Plants: The Future For Poinsettias Is Now

Millstadt Young Plants in Millstadt, IL, was first approached about hosting poinsettia trials in the Midwest region when Purdue University decided to stop running its trials. Now in its seventh year, Millstadt’s trials have grown into what many describe as the “biggest and best” around. Adam Heimos, the grower in charge of the trials, has a theory about how the operation earned this lofty reputation.

“I think how we got to this point was on trust, starting with the breeders: They have too much riding on these trials. They have to trust that we will present their product in the best way possible,” he says. “Then, the brokers have to trust that we are providing an accurate representation so they can sell these plants to their clients. Lastly, we have to trust our retailers to relay what the everyday customer is looking for in a poinsettia. If this life-cycle of communication can stay open, I have no doubt we will keep this trial going.”

Heimos says this method paid off in 2015, and the trials were a success. Although he declined to name “the best” variety of the trials, Heimos says he has a few favorites.

“I like ‘Pallas Red’ from Beekenkamp. It has a smaller bract, but makes up for that with quantity. Most of the plants had a canopy full of beautifully red bracts. Pallas is a smaller-vigor poinsettia but showed very well,” he says, also praising the Christmas Feelings series from Selecta and Premium series from Dümmen Orange. “Syngenta’s ‘Whitestar’ still stands as the best white on the market, and the Titan series had a good showing with three colors.”

Even with a greenhouse full of beautiful blooms and consistent successes, the trials continue to offer new challenges and opportunities each year. Heimos stresses that having access to cutting-edge cultivars is somewhat of a blessing and a curse.

“First and foremost, the biggest benefit and the biggest challenge has to be that we get to grow the newest poinsettias that haven’t hit the market,” he says, noting that while the new plants bring the greenhouse ample press and publicity, the pressure to organize everything from the cuttings to the final setup without misrepresenting a single variety is immense. “The more we get to learn on how to grow the new varieties, the better the trial will become in the future.”

Having a strong path forward with respect to the trials is important, particularly because Heimos says he thinks poinsettias are having a moment.

“The future is now,” he says. “Dümmen Orange released its ‘Gold Rush’ poinsettia that has definitely shaken things up. Syngenta has the Titan series that continues to perform. Selecta’s traditionalist ways contain some of my favorite varieties.”

Ultimately this level of innovation will only continue. Heimos even has a suggestion for breeders: “I think a bio-luminescent poinsettia would be rather unique.”

Mitchell’s Nursery & Greenhouse first caught the poinsettia bug in 1996, but the operation didn’t begin trialing the plant until 2004
Mitchell’s Nursery and Greenhouse first caught the poinsettia bug in 1996, but the operation didn’t begin trialing the plant until 2004.

Mitchell’s Nursery & Greenhouse: Poinsettias Publicity Is Good For Business

Mitchell’s Nursery & Greenhouse in King, NC, first caught the poinsettia bug in 1996, but the operation didn’t begin trialing the plant until 2004. It all began when Jim and Judy Mitchell attended the trials at their alma mater, North Carolina State University.

Determined to start something closer to home, Judy approached a Syngenta representative about the project. The rep agreed to send a few extra cuttings of different varieties, prompting Judy to order a few extra varieties from other breeders for the next year. Mitchell’s first trial included 30 to 35 varieties. In 2015, the grower trialed 33 red varieties alone, with an additional 20 pink, 15 white, and 29 novelty varieties, resulting in more than 9,000 total poinsettias.

Jim and Judy’s son Jay, who helps run the family business, says this dedication to growing its trials has been crucial in helping Mitchell’s expanding its overall reach.

“The trials have helped build our business,” he says. “They make us a unique destination. It’s fun. It exposes our customers to more than just Red, Pink, White, and Jingle Bells [varieties].”

Jay also mentioned that the trials bring the greenhouse positive publicity, but that the amount of magazine and newspaper articles and visits and live broadcasts from local TV stations is a testament to his mom’s hard work.

“She has learned how and when to call or email and get great coverage,” Jay says. “Everyone wants to do stories on unique Christmas activities. Poinsettias always make great pictures, but you can’t wait for someone to call you. You have to make the call and give them the idea, then also be willing to work with their schedule — even if it is 5:30 in the morning — to set up for the morning news broadcast.”

This year, the stations had plenty of gorgeous eye candy from Mitchell’s to help carry viewer ratings. Some of the highlights included ‘Ice Punch’ (novelty), ‘Carousel Dark Red’ (red), and ‘Winter Rose Red Early’ (novelty), which snagged the top three spots in the “best overall” category of the trials. Jay also mentioned other “best of” varieties, including ‘Euro Glory’ and ‘Christmas Feelings Merlot’ reds, ‘Whitestar’ and ‘Infinity Polar’ whites, ‘Christmas Lights’ and ‘Christmas Seasons’ pinks, and ‘Red Glitter’ and ‘Pink Candy’ novelties.

As the number of successful varieties continues to grow and diversify, Jay sees the operation improving its methods.

“Each poinsettia grows different,” he says. “And every year I learn a little more about growing better, more consistent, and uniform plants.”

Topics: , , , ,

Leave a Reply

More From Varieties...
Benary 2018

April 18, 2018

At CAST 2018, Sakata Captures Consumer Attention Spans, and Benary Celebrates Its History

More than halfway through the California Spring Trials, the Greenhouse Grower team had a busy but fantastic day seeing dozens of our friends at American Takii and Benary, and spending time talking about the industry's past and its bright future.

Read More

April 18, 2018

California Spring Trials 2018: New Varieties to Watch From American Takii, Hilverdakooijj, Hem Genetics, Thompson & Morgan, Sakata Ornamentals, and Ernst Benary of America

Check out the newest 2018 plant introductions from American Takii, Hilverdakooijj, Hem Genetics, Thompson & Morgan, Sakata Ornamentals, and Ernst Benary of America.

Read More

April 18, 2018

How the Horticulture Industry’s Past Shaped Its Present

Andrew Scheldorf, the winner of Dr. Allan Armitage’s California Spring Trials Scholarship, says the stories of plant origins help ground our industry to the people and places that have changed us.

Read More
Latest Stories
Benary 2018

April 18, 2018

At CAST 2018, Sakata Captures Consumer Attention Spans,…

More than halfway through the California Spring Trials, the Greenhouse Grower team had a busy but fantastic day seeing dozens of our friends at American Takii and Benary, and spending time talking about the industry's past and its bright future.

Read More

April 18, 2018

California Spring Trials 2018: New Varieties to Watch F…

Check out the newest 2018 plant introductions from American Takii, Hilverdakooijj, Hem Genetics, Thompson & Morgan, Sakata Ornamentals, and Ernst Benary of America.

Read More

April 18, 2018

How the Horticulture Industry’s Past Shaped Its P…

Andrew Scheldorf, the winner of Dr. Allan Armitage’s California Spring Trials Scholarship, says the stories of plant origins help ground our industry to the people and places that have changed us.

Read More

April 18, 2018

Dr. A Weighs in on His CAST Favorites From American Tak…

Here are some of the top variety introductions for 2019 that have pleased Dr. A during California Spring Trials 2018.

Read More
Dummen-Christmas-Decorating

April 17, 2018

Dümmen Orange’s New Gamechanger, Plants for All S…

Greenhouse Grower's California Spring Trials Team headed north on Day 3, with stops at Dümmen Orange in picturesque San Luis Obispo and Floricultura in fertile Salinas.

Read More
Verwer-Dahlias

April 17, 2018

Syngenta Flowers Acquires Netherlands-Based Dahlia Bree…

Syngenta Flowers has reached an agreement with Verwer Dahlia BV to acquire the company’s dahlia assortment and breeding program. Both companies expect to finalize the acquisition in the coming weeks.

Read More

April 17, 2018

Armitage Scholarship Winner Weighs in on Plant Breeding…

Andrew Scheldorf, the winner of Dr. Allan Armitage’s California Spring Trials Scholarship, says breeders' persistence in making small and large breeding improvements is a testament to their passion and dedication to excellence.

Read More

April 17, 2018

California Spring Trials 2018: Stand-Out New Plants fro…

Check out these new plant introductions from the California Spring Trials 2018 trail featuring breeding from Dümmen Orange , Westhoff, Beekenkamp, and Plug Connection.

Read More

April 17, 2018

Allan Armitage’s Noteworthy 2018 Plant Intros fro…

Here are some of the top variety introductions for 2019 that have pleased Dr. A during California Spring Trials 2018.

Read More
Artemisia-Plant-Display-at-Terra-Nova

April 16, 2018

CAST 2018 Provides Fresh Inspiration for Infusing Marke…

The  second day of California Spring Trials took the Greenhouse Grower Team to GroLink in Oxnard, CA, and then up the coast to Windmill Nursery in Buellton. Here are some of the marketing, display, trend, and people highlights we saw at those locations, as well as some beautiful scenery from our evening in Pismo Beach.

Read More
Lavender-Madrid-Lavish-Green-Fuse-Botanicals

April 16, 2018

Allan Armitage’s Spring Trials Favorites From Green Fus…

Here are some of the top variety introductions for 2019 that have pleased Dr. A during California Spring Trials 2018.

Read More
Echinacea-Kismet-White-Terra-Nova-Nurseries

April 16, 2018

Terra Nova Nurseries Debuting New Heuchera, Echinacea V…

Terra Nova Nurseries has created profile pages for these new varieties on its website to help growers learn about growing habits, plant characteristics, and other insights provided by the breeding team.

Read More
Danny-Takao-Allan-Armitage-Andrew-Scheldorf

April 16, 2018

Armitage Scholarship Recipient Reflects on Conversation…

Andrew Scheldorf, the winner of Dr. Allan Armitage’s California Spring Trials Scholarship, is realizing the power of networking and building relationships in the floriculture industry.

Read More

April 15, 2018

California Spring Trials 2018: New Plants From Green Fu…

Breeders at Green Fuse Botanicals, Floranova, Vegetalis, and Ball Horticulture featured new plant varieties at the 2018 California Spring Trials with vibrant color and unique patterns that are easy for growers to produce and ship, as well as small-space friendly vegetables for patio and container growing.

Read More

April 15, 2018

CAST 2018: Reach Young Consumers With Tattoos, Foliage,…

Here are some new and novel marketing and marketing ideas for reaching consumers and improving sales, from California Spring Trials 2018 at Ball Horticultural Co., Green Fuse Botanicals, and Floranova.

Read More

April 8, 2018

Danziger Innovation Session Tackles Evolving Consumer F…

A group of leading cut flower wholesalers, retailers, and bouquet companies gathered in Miami, FL, in mid-March to discuss the future of the cut flower industry, with a focus on innovation and the end consumer.

Read More
Vegetables-from-PanAmerican-feature

April 8, 2018

How You Can Respond to Complex Consumer Demands for Fre…

If you want to sell greenhouse-grown fresh vegetables for a profit, set yourself apart from the competition.

Read More
Hort-Couture-table-setting3

April 7, 2018

Kelly Norris: Growing an Edible Category That Looks Goo…

My last column seems to have stirred up good conversation, sautéed a few long-simmering sentiments, and served up a hearty spread of opinions on social media and in the comments section. Let me restate for clarity, if not also a rebuttal, that never did I question the facts or the value of innovation, only the value of its results. Innovation happens, sometimes repetitiously  and incrementally, and sometimes by leaps and bounds. Without context, one version is neither bad, good, or preferred. It’s our lifeblood, and we ought to increase our proficiency. In the case of new plant development, modern innovation infrequently addresses the ultimate needs of consumers. It so often focuses on the supply chain, which again, by itself, isn’t insignificant. We have to get plants to people efficiently and cost effectively. But why not invest further in addressing issues consumers actually care about or even want? What if we […]

Read More