Demystifying Pay-By-Scan

Demystifying Pay-By-Scan

I recently participated in a group discussion at the Super Floral Show in Salt Lake City covering the topic of pay-by-scan or as some call it, VMI, or Vendor Managed Inventory. This is a program that has received a lot of attention in the last two years, ever since The Home Depot launched this program across the bedding plant industry in spring 2005. This article is intended to provoke discussion and should be considered neither pro or con. I simply want to state my opinion of current events through my perspective.

The purpose of this article is to clarify some questions that may be out there in the industry in relation to the program. Is it working? What impact does it have on suppliers? Are suppliers happy with it? Is the retailer happy with it? What are the pros and cons from supply side and sell side? If this is such a great concept, then why isn’t it more widespread?

So here we go. What is pay-by-scan? It is a distribution system that allows suppliers to allocate inventory into retail selling sites, maintain the product and replenish as needed. Ownership of the product does not transfer until the customer actually creates the transaction at the cash register. Once the product is scanned at the register, an invoice is created through the electronic data interchange system and growers are compensated in a time period based on their negotiated payment terms.

The retailer never takes possession of the inventory. This burden is squarely placed on the supplier. Therefore, the supplier has increased input in how much inventory goes into a store. This creates interesting pressures both early and late in selling seasons. In the past, growers were definitely more liberal in allocating product to be shipped to retailers where danger of frost and damaged plants could impact sell through. Now that the supplier is liable for losses, more prudent allocation is the wiser business decision. Operators that are anxious to kick-start the season are often at loggerheads with local bedding suppliers to fill tables and overhead racks with tender products to be first and fullest in the game. That’s an easy perspective when you’re playing with house money.

Pay-by-scan takes all markdowns off the retailer’s ledger. In effect, this takes any retailer that is burdened with retail accounting back to cost accounting. For those that don’t have an accounting degree or those who need a quick primer in retail versus cost accounting, retail accounting values the inventory at the current retail pricing. Cost accounting obviously values the current inventory based on its acquired cost. Retailers that use retail accounting are typically very reluctant to take markdowns on current inventory as it is considered a devaluation of assets. Perishable product categories, such as live goods, will suffer in this environment as most operators would just as soon let current inventory devalue to zero rather than take an intermediate markdown to create greater velocity for consumers with greater values. 

An Accounting Refresher

Cost accounting allows for greater flexibility in manipulating retails up and down. What really matters in this system is the maintained gross margin percentage. For example, if you paid $5 for an item and retailed it for $10, you would capture a 50 percent gross margin. If you decided that you needed to achieve a 30 percent gross margin, then you would discount, or put on sale, the $10 item for $7 and get your $3 in gross margin dollars. This is a no-no in retail accounting. Using this example, you would simply set the retail price of $7 and sell all inventory at this retail. There are no up and down or yo-yo retailing.

Retail accounting is also painful when retailers that use it need to adjust retails down to meet competitors. This basically means that either the retailer guessed wrong when establishing retails for the selling season or competition drove down retails in the selling season, causing a downward pressure on retail pricing. Management is never happy about this phenomenon when retails need to be moved down.

This is somewhat of a long-winded explanation of one of the biggest benefits of pay-by-scan to these retailers. It creates a cost accounting system that is much more fluid to meet market demands considering that the retailer and supplier agree on what needs to transpire to benefit both parties in maximizing profits for both.

Retail sellers now have the greatest quality control system in recent retail history. What grower would knowingly ship substandard product if they are solely graded on sell through of the product? This was one of the biggest concerns I had as a mass merchant buyer — that I was indeed getting top-quality product every day from every supplier. As we all know, that isn’t always what happens for whatever reason. Now that suppliers’ compensation is more closely aligned with product sell through, quality has definitely picked up in these programs. It’s unfortunate that it had to come to this system to make more growers sensitive to “harvest discipline.”

Growers have some added flexibility here if they are long on inventory in an item where they can bring products to market at lower costs and corresponding retails, provided the retailer agrees, and drive higher velocity at greater values to the customer where needed. Retailers are happy if their pile of gross margin dollars are higher at the end of the day and growers are usually happy if they get crops that might have to be dumped otherwise, into the buying public’s hands. 

The Service Question

Pay-by-scan is also a selling system that requires a high-level service program. Suppliers are completely responsible for the condition of the inventory and how the program gets displayed and maintained at store level. Thus service is built into costing to pass on these benefits to the retailer. Growers basically have to go to retail merchandising school and, in effect, become retailers. It’s not unusual under this type of program for suppliers in Northern markets to hire two to five people per store to execute programs starting in February for the main selling season and dropping down to a lower level for summer sales. What once was a more efficient staffing process from the mega-retailer has now been pushed down to the “local” growers, who obviously don’t enjoy the same leverage benefits that these superpowers possess.

Growers gain a lot of traction in product mix and what gets advertised. They also have a lot more to say in terms of retail pricing. These are all categories, in the new process, that are jointly negotiated between retailer and supplier. Progressive suppliers can script their own season by being proactive in participating in or writing their own local market ads and providing this information to their merchants. Hand in hand with advertising schedules go production schedules. This reduces surprises that may have popped up in the past, as this seems to have been a problem from time to time.

A major benefit from this type of program for the supplier is exclusivity. They have the right to be the sole source of supply for their category. This eliminates competitive pressures they may have had from store to store on like items. It enables the supplier to control or manage the inventory. They can put in the products they deem appropriate in the quantities that they feel are adequate to meet consumer demand. They can push products into stores based on “what looks best inventory” and manipulate consumer demand accordingly. They can also put as much or as little as they deem appropriate, providing it meets with their regional merchant’s guidance. It basically gives suppliers a much bigger voice in their own destiny.

So far, I haven’t heard of any supplier going out of business as a result of this process. I also have not heard of any supplier that has basically walked away from a retailer because they didn’t want to participate in the program. This is the second full selling season for the program and I would say the jury is firmly out on who benefits from the process.

As we sit here today, retailers have created a “pay-by-scan portal” that has in turn created, for lack of a better term, many “retail mad scientists” that are in the laboratories (their stores) trying to come up with formulas for other product categories that can be siphoned through the portal. For them it means less markdowns and shrink and for suppliers it means more top-line sales. There are many questions arising. Is it good for the supplier? Is it good for the retailer? Is it good for the consumer? Time will tell. There will be lots more discussion to follow, I’m sure.

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Demystifying Pay-By-Scan

  1. We are entering the world of pay by scan (vmi). Can you help with software info. I understand there is massive amounts of electronic info on a daily basis. Thanks

More From Marketing...
Gaillardia x grandiflora 'Arizona Apricot'

February 25, 2015

National Garden Bureau Designates 2015 As Year Of The Gaillardia

Gaillardia, also known as the blanket flower, is a member of the sunflower family (Asteraceae) and a long-blooming pollinator plant. It is fitting that the National Garden Bureau has specified 2015 as The Year of the Gaillardia.

Read More
IPPS Sharing Plant Production Knowledge Globally Logo

February 25, 2015

International Plant Propagators Western Region Sets Annual Meeting Date

The annual meet for the International Plant Propagators' Society (IPPS) Western Region has been set for this September. It will take place September 23 to 26 in Modesto, Calif., and will include learning sessions, tours to local nurseries, a research poster display and poster presentations, various networking opportunities and an awards banquet to close the event.

Read More
Evolvulus Blue My Mind

February 24, 2015

Blue Ribbon Bloomers For Greenhouse Production

Grow what consumers want! Surveys show that blue is one of the top preferred colors of today’s consumers. Here are twelve top recommended blue-flowering Proven Winners annuals and perennials to suit your spring production cycle.

Read More
Latest Stories

February 18, 2015

Range Of Nursery Inspections To Protect Patented Plants…

Plant patents are under protection, and breeders are fighting for their rights to keep growers from illegally propagating protected varieties. It's something you don't want to take a chance on, because the risk is far higher than the reward. More than 300 inspections were carried out last year from New York to British Columbia and from Ontario to Florida to protect plant patents, Plant Breeders’ Rights (PBR) and branded programs.

Read More

February 4, 2015

TPIE 2015: An Electrified Industry Vibe Boosts Cool New…

The general feeling at the Florida Nursery Growers and Landscape Association's 2015 Tropical Industry Exhibition (TPIE) was upbeat and positive. Attendees were inspired by exciting new products and varieties, as well as creative new displays and innovative ideas and left energized for the season ahead.

Read More
Costa Farms Website

January 21, 2015

Costa Farms’ Launches New Interactive Website

Costa Farms is making efforts to educate consumers while pushing horticultural digital marketing forward with the re-design of its website. The new website features a fresh design and improved navigation, as well as a plant finder that gives gardeners easy access to plant information.

Read More

January 5, 2015

Growers Are Successfully Marketing The Benefits Of Pla…

Growers who are already marketing plant benefits and gardening as a lifestyle say they think this could be the best angle for the floriculture industry to promote our products.

Read More

January 5, 2015

Plants Love You Campaign Raises Plant Benefits To Foref…

Plants make us feel good. It’s a no-brainer, backed by numerous studies, but there’s more to the story. And it’s one the Canadian Ornamental Horticulture Alliance (COHA) hopes its Plants Love You campaign will tell in such a way that it will inspire people to make plants a part of their life, and on a bigger scale. COHA is an alliance between the Canadian Nursery Landscape Association (CNLA), the Fédération Interdisciplinaire De L’Horticulture Ornementqale Du Québec (FIHOQ) and Flowers Canada Growers (FCG). Inspiration for The Plants Love You campaign came from COHA’s research, which revealed that 96 percent of consumers surveyed have a favorable attitude toward plants. When COHA delved deeper into the numbers, one thing stood out loud and clear. “It quickly became apparent that while consumers like plants because they are pretty and make them feel good, few understood the environmental and health benefits plants offer.” says Frank […]

Read More

December 9, 2014

New Website For PanAmerican Seed

PanAmerican Seed's new website is mobile-friendly and has a fresh look and enhanced navigation.

Read More
What’s a pumpulent? It’s a pumpkin planted with succulents, and it’s also one of the ways Altum’s is catching customers’ attention with new products and modern marketing.

December 1, 2014

9 Digital Marketing Resolutions For 2015

Whatever your experience with digital marketing, here’s some advice for keeping your business progressing into the new year.

Read More

November 25, 2014

Conley’s Launches New Website

Conley’s Manufacturing and Sales recently launched its newly designed website, which was redesigned to create a user-friendly digital environment for customers to explore Conley's products.

Read More

November 17, 2014

Canada’s Plants Love You Campaign Educates Consum…

In a cooperative effort to promote the benefits of plants to consumers, the Canadian Ornamental Horticulture Alliance (COHA) recently launched its Plants Love You campaign to make consumers more aware of the health, environmental and economic benefits of plants.

Read More
Supertunia® Vista Bubblegum™ Petunia from Proven Winners

November 11, 2014

Plantbid Offers New Tool For Growers, Plant Buyers

Plantbid is touted as a revolutionary new tool that allows plant buyers to purchase their whole plant list at one time, from growers who provide their complete availability online. According to the company, this new offering could change the way growers and landscapers do business.

Read More
Dahlia Dahlinova Temptation Lavender from Dummen Fides Oro

November 10, 2014

Bas Pellenaars Takes On New Role As Brand Manager For D…

Dümmen group announces the transition of Bas Pellenaars from area manager to brand manager.

Read More

October 28, 2014

Zombie Adventures Are Back: GGS Releases Premiere Of Ne…

What's good for plants, but bad for zombies? GGS structures. The company released a new promotional video to get growers in the spirit of Halloween. GGS Structures ran a series of zombie movies last year, and this year, something new was released October 24.

Read More
Suzanne McKee

October 27, 2014

Use Your Data To Make Smarter Marketing Decisions

Learn which marketing metrics are important to your business, measure successes and learn where changes are needed.

Read More
Sara Tambascio

October 2, 2014

How To Measure The Success Of Your Digital Marketing

Take a look at these metrics in your digital marketing to see if you’re connecting with your audience or just adding to the clutter.

Read More

September 26, 2014

How To Get The Digital Generation Into The Garden: Gard…

Capture millennials’ gardening interests with these marketing tips.

Read More
The Joseph Shinoda Memorial Scholarship Foundation

September 9, 2014

Shinoda Foundation Contributes Nearly $15,000 In Schola…

Based in California, the Joseph Shinoda Memorial Foundation's mission is to encourage educational opportunities for young people interested in entering the industry. Since 1965, the foundation has awarded $790,000 to more than 660 undergraduate floriculture students.

Read More
Salvia 'Playin the Blues' from Proven Winners

September 9, 2014

Grand Gardening Show On Mackinac Island Draws Huge Audi…

Dates are already set for Proven Winners' 2015 Grand Garden Show after the great response the 2014 show received in late August.

Read More

August 27, 2014

New Gardening App GrowIt Connects Community Of Gardener…

Thanks to Ball Horticultural Co.’s Mason Day and Seth Reed, gardeners can now share photos of their plants, interact with other growers and learn about what grows best in their area with the duos new app, GrowIt!

Read More