Organic Controls Sales Have Caught Up With Traditional Pesticides, Garden Retailers Report

It’s taken many years, but organic control sales are now on par with traditional controls for U.S. garden retailers, an analysis of a few years of surveying garden retailers shows. And retailers consistently report that organic controls have a higher increase in sales each year than its counterpart.

The data was pulled from several years of our retail State of the Industry surveys, and the number of retailers responding each year ranged from 216 (in 2014) to 440 (in 2013) garden retailers.

The national picture shows that a similar number of retailers are stocking traditional and organic pesticides. We find 78.3% of retailers are stocking traditional controls, which is just a whisper higher than the 77.93% that carry organics.

But once you look at how the products are performing, you begin to see some differences.

Take a look at the two charts below. The first, which tracks traditional pest control sales performance since 2013, reveals that flat sales were the most common response. In contrast, the most common trend retailers reported for organic pest control sales was an increase in sales.

The difference between the two category in decreased sales is also worth noting. Organic controls were much less likely to be reported as having a decrease in sale compared to traditional. In some cases, decreased-sales reports were a third of decreases of traditional controls.

 

Retail sales of traditional pest controls

Retail sales of organic controls

Anyone who has followed the growth of organic products for the garden knows that the products popularity were established early in some regions, while others were slow to adopt them.

Take a look at the Midwest sales of organics. You can quickly see that their is a higher percent of retailers not carrying the products, and that Midwest retailers are more likely to report flat sales.

organic control sales in the Midwest

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Northeast, one of the early adopters of organic products, reports a much different experience than the Midwest’s. Those reporting increased sales are almost 10 percentage points above the Midwest. And other than an anomaly in 2014, those reporting decreased sales are minimal.

organic control sales in the Northeast

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

How Each Contributes To Overall Sales For Retailers

While organic products have momentum on their side, traditional pesticides still perform better in contributing to the bottom line, although it’s admittedly by a small amount.

In 2014, traditional pest control sales made up 2.55% of total sales, which was up slightly compared to 2013, when retailers reported the category made up 2.21% of sales.

Compare that to organic controls. In 2014, organic controls sales made up 2.25% of total sales, which was up compared to 2013, when retailers reported the category made up 1.96% of sales.

In 2015, we swapped out the percent of sales question with two write-in questions, one asking retailers to tell us which single category saw the biggest increase in sales, and the second asking which category had the largest decrease. Organics had several write ins, while a single retailer reported that their gnat control pesticide was its biggest seller. Conversely, there were no write ins for organics, while traditional pesticides was one of the highest categories for decreased sales.

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “Organic Controls Sales Have Caught Up With Traditional Pesticides, Garden Retailers Report

More From Retailing...
Garden Centers Of America Best Bathroom Awards

September 19, 2016

Garden Centers Of America Names 2016 Best Bathroom Award Winners

Every year, a panel judges the entries on the bathroom’s creativity and comfort to the customer’s overall shopping experience.

Read More
redbud-the-rising-sun-greenleaf-nursery-feature

September 19, 2016

Garden Center Group Dishes Out Retail Awards At SEGreen 2016

The Garden Center Group presented another round of Retailers’ Choice Awards at the Southern Nursery Association’s new SEGreen 2016 conference. Check out this year’s winners.

Read More
Griffin Logo

September 19, 2016

What You Should Do At The Griffin Expos, Pennsylvania Edition

The second of the fall Griffin Expos takes place this week in Lancaster, PA, on September 21-22. If you're heading to this distributor show, make sure you check out these highlights.

Read More
Latest Stories
Garden Centers Of America Best Bathroom Awards

September 19, 2016

Garden Centers Of America Names 2016 Best Bathroom Awar…

Every year, a panel judges the entries on the bathroom’s creativity and comfort to the customer’s overall shopping experience.

Read More
redbud-the-rising-sun-greenleaf-nursery-feature

September 19, 2016

Garden Center Group Dishes Out Retail Awards At SEGreen…

The Garden Center Group presented another round of Retailers’ Choice Awards at the Southern Nursery Association’s new SEGreen 2016 conference. Check out this year’s winners.

Read More
Griffin Logo

September 19, 2016

What You Should Do At The Griffin Expos, Pennsylvania E…

The second of the fall Griffin Expos takes place this week in Lancaster, PA, on September 21-22. If you're heading to this distributor show, make sure you check out these highlights.

Read More

September 9, 2016

It’s Official. Trees Are A Miracle Drug.

Recent studies show that trees are an outrageously powerful good for humankind. Luckily, tree sales are already on the increase. If your customers are aware of these kind studies, those sales may continue to soar.

Read More
Sunflare Japanese Forest Grass

September 8, 2016

Garden Retailers ID Their Favorite Findings At Farwest

The Retailers’ Choice Awards, once again coordinated by The Garden Center Group, were presented to nine exhibiting companies at the 2016 Farwest Show.

Read More

September 7, 2016

How Chalet Nursery Hits The Perceived-Value Sweet Spot

Steve Bailey says the sweet spot in pricing, that proverbial ideal price for your center, is tricky. Price it too high, and the units sold may drop. Price it too low, and you might not sell any more units than at a higher price.

Read More

September 6, 2016

What You Can Do At This Week’s Distributor Shows

It’s a busy week, with three distributor shows scheduled. If you’re heading Arett Sales, BFG Supply, or the Prince Fall Booking shows, we’ve got the inside scoop on what you’ll not want to miss. Arett Open House Atlantic City, September 11 to 13 Arett’s annual Open House event includes plenty of food and exhibitors (there’s more than 400 booths). There are three keynotes lined up. Kicking off on Sunday, retail motivational speaker Bob Phibbs will fire everyone up with his talk, “You Can Compete.” during a brunch. On Monday, consultant Ian Baldwin will get down to details in his “The Applied Science Of Winning Market Share.” And AmericanHort’s Jennifer Noble will offer the final keynote, asking retailers, “What If We Knew The Future?” And you’ll want to make sure you attend the evening entertainment: Sunday: Happy hour, dinner and live jazz on the show floor. Monday: Dinner at the Tropicana Hotel. BFG Expo […]

Read More

September 6, 2016

Which Plants Do Retailers Change The Prices On Most?

When our panel of experts (Dr. Charlie Hall, Texas A&M, Dr. Bridget Behe, Michigan State University, Consultants Steve Bailey, Ian Baldwin, and Sid Raisch) and I put together a pricing survey, we were curious about which plants retailers were most likely to change the price on. In other words, what’s most likely to be put on sale? Which categories are most likely to have increased prices due to the perceived value? Value-Added Plants Let’s start with value-added plants. Before the survey, most of us thought trendy plants, combo gardens, and large plants would be near the top of the list. We were partially right. Big plants and container gardens are at the top. But succulents and mini plants weren’t even close to the top. The four plant categories that are most likely to have perceived-value pricing applied are: Container Gardens Shrubs Large Perennials Trees Not surprisingly, container gardens leads the pack. About 72% of retailers say […]

Read More
Greenhouse Grower Retailing Logo

September 5, 2016

How Is Greenhouse Grower RETAILING Doing So Far?

Less than a year ago, Greenhouse Grower RETAILING launched. We’d love to get your feedback on how we can improve, and what we should continue doing.  

Read More

August 29, 2016

Does Point-Of-Sale (POS) Make A Difference for Plant Re…

When Greenhouse Grower RETAILING asked plant retailers about their plant pricing techniques, we also asked if they use POS or not. We decided to take a close look at where these two groups differ:

Read More
Griffin Logo

August 29, 2016

What You Should Do At The Griffin Expos, Massachusetts …

The first of the fall Griffin Expos takes place this week in West Springfield, MA, August 31 and September 1, 2016. A Lancaster, PA, Expo will take place next month. If you’re heading to this distributor show, make sure you check out these highlights: White Elephant Sale Each year, Griffin clears out its branch warehouses by holding a sale of its closeout and overstock items. The discounts are deep, and the competition for the items are fierce. “Once items are gone, they’re gone. So, that first hour or so is kind of like ‘the running of the brides’ at Filene’s,” says Tracey Gorrell, Marketing Communications Lead at Griffin. On-Site Experts Griffin offers opportunities to connect face-to-face with industry experts and get answers, tips, and advice catered to your unique needs and interests: The GGSPro team is available to field your questions; and 150 manufacturers, breeders, and young-plant producers can discuss […]

Read More

August 29, 2016

Fire Damages Swanson Nursery

Fire crews were called to Seattle-based Swanson’s Nursery in the middle of the night on August 22, the Ballard News Tribune reported. The fire, likely started by an “electrical issue,” destroyed bathrooms and a seminar room, Retail Manager Eric Nordstrom told the news outlet. Smoke damage was more extensive, however. Swanson’s President, Brian Damron says the fire also reached a storage area and utility room. A fire department spokesman says the fire broke through the greenhouse walls, and that part of a wooden wall had to be removed so the crew could reach the flames. The store’s café resides next to the damaged area, and is temporarily closed. It’s an important part of Swanson’s off season revenue strategy. The store is working with a timeline of repairs with its insurance company so it can determine when the cafe can reopen, the news outlet reports. The fire was out relatively quickly once […]

Read More

August 22, 2016

How Bad Plant Pricing Can Hurt A Good Retailer

Greenhouse Grower RETAILING's pricing survey finds that the most profitable pricing method is used by only 8% of plant retailers.

Read More

August 22, 2016

IGC Chicago Scores Big With Attendees And Exhibitors

The 10th anniversary of the annual event at Chicago’s Navy Pier drew a record number of first-time attendees, while exhibitors reported higher sales than ever.

Read More

August 16, 2016

Products Making Their Summer Debut At Farwest

Heading to Portland to attending Farwest? Then make sure you check out these new products that will be on display!

Read More
Summerwinds Proven Winners display FEATURE

August 16, 2016

Summerwinds Breaks The Price Barrier

In 2012, Summerwinds participated in our 10% Project and raised its priced on three plant brands. What they learned changed the staff culture on plant prices.

Read More
Woman holding vegetable harvest Stock photo FEATURE

August 16, 2016

Gardening Is Enjoying A Sharp Increase, National Garden…

There were 6 million more gardeners in 2015, and 5 million of them were 18 to 34 years old.

Read More
Farwest Trade Show Floor

August 8, 2016

What Garden Retailers Need To Know About The 2016 Farwe…

Farwest continues to strengthen its retail products focus on the show floor to help hard good buyers discover new suppliers and round out product offerings.

Read More
[gravityform id="35" title="false" description="false"]