Organic Controls Sales Have Caught Up With Traditional Pesticides, Garden Retailers Report

It’s taken many years, but organic control sales are now on par with traditional controls for U.S. garden retailers, an analysis of a few years of surveying garden retailers shows. And retailers consistently report that organic controls have a higher increase in sales each year than its counterpart.

The data was pulled from several years of our retail State of the Industry surveys, and the number of retailers responding each year ranged from 216 (in 2014) to 440 (in 2013) garden retailers.

The national picture shows that a similar number of retailers are stocking traditional and organic pesticides. We find 78.3% of retailers are stocking traditional controls, which is just a whisper higher than the 77.93% that carry organics.

But once you look at how the products are performing, you begin to see some differences.

Take a look at the two charts below. The first, which tracks traditional pest control sales performance since 2013, reveals that flat sales were the most common response. In contrast, the most common trend retailers reported for organic pest control sales was an increase in sales.

The difference between the two category in decreased sales is also worth noting. Organic controls were much less likely to be reported as having a decrease in sale compared to traditional. In some cases, decreased-sales reports were a third of decreases of traditional controls.

 

Retail sales of traditional pest controls

Retail sales of organic controls

Anyone who has followed the growth of organic products for the garden knows that the products popularity were established early in some regions, while others were slow to adopt them.

Take a look at the Midwest sales of organics. You can quickly see that their is a higher percent of retailers not carrying the products, and that Midwest retailers are more likely to report flat sales.

organic control sales in the Midwest

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

The Northeast, one of the early adopters of organic products, reports a much different experience than the Midwest’s. Those reporting increased sales are almost 10 percentage points above the Midwest. And other than an anomaly in 2014, those reporting decreased sales are minimal.

organic control sales in the Northeast

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

How Each Contributes To Overall Sales For Retailers

While organic products have momentum on their side, traditional pesticides still perform better in contributing to the bottom line, although it’s admittedly by a small amount.

In 2014, traditional pest control sales made up 2.55% of total sales, which was up slightly compared to 2013, when retailers reported the category made up 2.21% of sales.

Compare that to organic controls. In 2014, organic controls sales made up 2.25% of total sales, which was up compared to 2013, when retailers reported the category made up 1.96% of sales.

In 2015, we swapped out the percent of sales question with two write-in questions, one asking retailers to tell us which single category saw the biggest increase in sales, and the second asking which category had the largest decrease. Organics had several write ins, while a single retailer reported that their gnat control pesticide was its biggest seller. Conversely, there were no write ins for organics, while traditional pesticides was one of the highest categories for decreased sales.

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “Organic Controls Sales Have Caught Up With Traditional Pesticides, Garden Retailers Report

More From Retailing...

May 23, 2016

Ian Baldwin Sees Several Garden Trends Developing This Spring

The garden industry consultant reads the mid-spring tea leaves and sees several trends emerging.

Read More

May 23, 2016

Manhattan’s Urban Garden Center Suffers Second Disaster In Two Years

Two years after a nearby gas explosion destroyed the store in Manhattan's Spanish Harlem, Urban Garden Center had a four-alarm fire that disrupted a popular train route, and the garden retailer is now dealing with an angry community.

Read More
Aerial_view_of_the_Bayer_cross_high_res

May 23, 2016

Bayer Sells Consumer Garden Products Division To French Company

The sale to SBM Développement comes just as Bayer AG makes a bid for Monsanto.

Read More
Latest Stories

May 23, 2016

Ian Baldwin Sees Several Garden Trends Developing This …

The garden industry consultant reads the mid-spring tea leaves and sees several trends emerging.

Read More

May 23, 2016

Manhattan’s Urban Garden Center Suffers Second Di…

Two years after a nearby gas explosion destroyed the store in Manhattan's Spanish Harlem, Urban Garden Center had a four-alarm fire that disrupted a popular train route, and the garden retailer is now dealing with an angry community.

Read More
Aerial_view_of_the_Bayer_cross_high_res

May 23, 2016

Bayer Sells Consumer Garden Products Division To French…

The sale to SBM Développement comes just as Bayer AG makes a bid for Monsanto.

Read More
rain on flowers weather FEATURE

May 16, 2016

Industry Consultants Say Early Sales Are Bolstering Poo…

It's been a roller coaster of a spring. Three garden retail consultants, who remain in close touch with more than a hundred garden stores collectively, report on what their clients are experiencing.

Read More
One symptom of Botrytis blight is gray, fuzzy sporulation on foliage and flowers, similar to that shown on the flower of this hibiscus

May 16, 2016

In-Store Plant Care Tips To Teach Your Staff

With the spring season still fresh on our minds, now is the time to reflect on some common disease and pest problems that occur in the garden center, recognize which problems touched your store, and identify solutions to quickly treat and control these problems in the future. Ideal solutions for the retail environment will be fast and effective with a short REI, have labels including edibles and ornamentals, present no or minimal odor and residue, bring no risk of burn or other phyto, and will not present a residual bee hazard. It’s a tall order, but we have solutions that fit the bill for some of the most common diseases and pests. The main foliar disease encountered in garden centers is Botrytis. This ubiquitous disease requires humid/moist conditions and can attack both dying and healthy foliage and floral tissue, producing characteristic gray, fluffy sporulation. Botrytis attacks healthy tissue with as […]

Read More

May 16, 2016

What Garden Retailers Will Want To Check Out At Cultiva…

Planning on attending Cultivate'16 in July? We've tracked down the things you'll want to do, from catching a screening of the documentary "Gangster Gardener" to checking out the new cultivars at The Ohio State University's trial gardens.

Read More

May 10, 2016

Spring 2016 Has Seen Big Sales Increases Despite A Wet …

Cool, wet conditions followed an early spring across much of North America. But customers didn't seem to care as much, and year-over-year sales are enjoying a significant boost, retailers are reporting.

Read More

May 10, 2016

An Internet-Based, Employee-Scheduling Tool Is A Hit At…

Owner John Heaton talks about how the scheduling tool has made life easier for managers and employees.

Read More

May 9, 2016

2015 Garden Sales Jumped 26% Over 2014

The National Gardening Survey is out, and 2015 was a big year in garden sales.

Read More

May 9, 2016

9 Practical Tips To Turn New Gardener Panic To Confiden…

Consultant Ian Baldwin has noticed panicked looks on millennial faces while they shop for plants. They have bought into the concept of outdoor fun with the kids or healthy home-grown food, but matching the dream with reality is another matter.

Read More

May 3, 2016

SNA’s Summer Tradeshow Is Revamped As SEGreen

SNA is hosting a new summer show, SE Green, in Athens, GA. It mixes a conference for Southeast-based landscapers, growers, and retailers, with exhibitors.

Read More

May 2, 2016

A Fire At A New Hampshire Garden Center Challenges Spri…

Petal Pushers Farm in Laconia, NH, suffered a two-alarm fire two weeks prior to Mother's Day Weekend. It is already back up and running, but is scrambling to replace its losses.

Read More

May 2, 2016

Surprise Customers With Over-The-Top Service On Busy We…

Customers coming to your store this weekend expect long lines, crowded aisles, and other annoyances. If you step up and wow them this weekend with great service, you'll have a winning formula: low expectations + high traffic + amazing service = lots of new and repeat customers.

Read More
PMA Floral Anaheim

May 1, 2016

Produce Marketing Association Plans Floral Supply Chain…

The PMA Fresh Connections: Floral events will unveil new market research and trends, while offering insights into the changing landscape of floral retailing.

Read More
Natureworks Monarch life cycle caterpillar FEATURE

April 29, 2016

Do Customers Really Care How Plants Are Grown?

The consumer uprising against neonicotinoids has roiled the industry over the past couple of years. In June 2013, someone applied pesticide to a tree in full bloom, using the product in an off-label manner. That misapplication killed tens of thousands of bees, capturing the attention of activists. A short three years later, that activism has led to policy changes for big chains like The Home Depot and Lowe’s. Several cities and towns across the country have banned the sale of neonicotinoids, as has the state of Maryland. All of this made me curious. How was all the publicity affecting consumer attitudes at local garden stores? Traditionally, customers have shown little interest in how flowering plants are grown, other than they like the idea that they are from a local source. They have been much more particular about food plants than they have ornamentals. So I sent questions out to a […]

Read More

April 26, 2016

How To Host A Spectacular Farm Dinner

Farm-to-table dinners are a great way to connect your customers with a love for nature and growing things. These three green industry companies have had a lot of success with their farm dinners. Find out what it takes to pull one of these dinners off successfully. Advice from Tangletown Garden’s Dean Englemann: You have to be certain you’re matching the ticket price to the experience, make sure you’re exceeding expectations. It can’t just be about the food. You have to deliver the experience. For us, we want to make sure there’s a lasting experience of connecting our food to families and dining. For lack of a better comparison, we want sitting in a field, eating food we grew and created, to be a religious experience. There’s almost a ceremonial aspect to these dinners. We’ve always thought that the shortest distance between the earth and people is the distance between the hand and the […]

Read More

April 26, 2016

Fun Display Ideas From California Spring Trials

In a year that was light on new introductions, plant breeders ramped up their display creativity. Garden retailers can find a lot of inspiration for their own stores here!  

Read More

April 26, 2016

12 Questions To Test If Your Store Is New-Customer Frie…

Consultant Ian Baldwin offers ways to help you look at your store with fresh eyes and how you can make it welcoming for new gardeners.

Read More
[gravityform id="35" title="false" description="false"]