Going Geothermal

Going Geothermal

Mark Elzinga held nothing back when he built his four-acre organic greenhouse at Elzinga & Hoeksema in Portage, Mich.

He spent money, took risks and entrusted a lot of people with the future of his operation–people like Stephen Hamstra, executive vice president at GMB, who helped design the solar-geothermal energy system that should provide 80 percent of Elzinga’s heating needs. The GMB-designed system should cut down on Elzinga’s energy costs, as well, and significantly reduce the greenhouse’s carbon footprint.

“The geothermal hybrid is a new thing,” Hamstra says. “I’m not aware of a greenhouse that’s done it like this. We presented the concept in 2006 in a white paper at the International Ground Source Heat Pump Association (IGSHPA) annual meeting in Albany, N.Y., and there was a lot of favorable response.” 

One Of A Kind

Elzinga was among the first to take notice, and he now has an impressive solar-geothermal system that includes 200 solar energy collectors, a 60,000-gallon insulated water tank and a heat exchanger that includes 26 miles of polypropylene tubing sunk in 200 wells that are each 300 feet deep.

The system uses Michigan’s year-round ground temperature to create hot water that’s stored in an above-ground tank and available for most of the greenhouse’s heating needs. In the summer, only a handful of heat is obviously needed in the building, yet available heat from the sun and air is abundant. So that excess heat is pumped into the ground and available to Elzinga the following winter.

Another part of the GMB design involves two air-handling units that sit outside the greenhouse.

“They’re basically fans and big radiator coils,” Hamstra says. “Each one moves 100,000 cubic feet of air per minute. If the air temperature (outside) is warmer than the soil temperature (underground) in the earth heat exchanger, we’ll turn on a pump and circulate cool water through those coils and blow warm air across the coils to also try to capture free solar energy and warm the soil.”

As reliable as Elzinga’s geothermal system is, the greenhouse can’t exclusively depend on heat from it year-round. Once cold temperatures arrive, high-efficiency boilers kick in to make up the difference that the heat pump cannot fill. And, if for some reason the geothermal system needs to be turned off, the boilers are capable of handling the heating load for the entire greenhouse. 

Greenhouse Rookies

Surprisingly, Elzinga is the first greenhouse GMB has ever served. The architectural and engineering company based in Holland, Mich., has mainly worked with the healthcare, corporate and education sectors. And, according to Hamstra, few of his peers have even thought much of having greenhouse growers as clients.

“It’s a huge market with a huge need, and the response is typically that the greenhouse market has been characterized by low-cost heating systems and that growers will put in the minimum to get by,” Hamstra says.

Elzinga’s vertical closed-loop system certainly bucks that trend, but the idea behind it is that the long-term benefits will eventually offset the costs upfront. Still, there’s more to geothermal heat systems in greenhouses than growers simply being open to invest in their futures now. Each greenhouse structure is unique, Hamstra says, and any system GMB installs is custom made.

At Elzinga, GMB was called on midway through the building process. But the earlier it could have been involved, the better, Hamstra says, because geothermal applications are functions of the greenhouse site.

If, for instance, GMB was involved with the Elzinga project at the start, it might have been able to put the bore field underneath the greenhouse itself. And that, among other applications, probably could have reduced the amount of area taken up by various parts of the system, too.

“We need some real estate to do this,” Hamstra says. “Talking to one grower who has a huge aquifer available and a big irrigation system with greenhouses and large open fields, a ground-water heat pump system is certainly a possibility. If you’ve got a good source of ground water, a good place to get rid of it after you’ve just pulled some heat out of it and no bacteria that will cause problems over time, it can work well.” 

Thinking Ahead

A geothermal system can also work well for a greenhouse, Hamstra says, if it collaborates with another building, particularly one that’s refrigerated. In a study conducted last year on a Meijer store in Michigan, GMB found that the store rejects nine times more heat each year than it needs.

Following the study, Hamstra did a computer simulation that gave the Meijer store a geothermal heat pump system, and he put the store side-by-side with Elzinga’s greenhouse. He then found that if Meijer’s waste heat was moved to the greenhouse, the size of Elzinga’s geothermal heat exchanger would drop in half in a virtual building simulation. He also concluded that the greenhouse could use that waste heat to significantly reduce the cost of operation while Meijer had a less-expensive way to lose its heat. “If you’ve got greenhouses that are next to some industrial process–plastic injection molding, even power plants–the waste stream from one industry could become the feedstock for the other industry,” Hamstra says.

As good as that scenario sounds, few growers are positioned right next door to buildings that can accommodate that amount of heat. But if growers are considering geothermal heat pumps for their greenhouses, Hamstra recommends that they consult engineers who’ve gone through the rigors of Certified GeoExchange Designer (CGD) training administered by IGSHPA. The investment is simply too much, he says, to rely on some run-of-the-mill heating company that’s conveniently located.

“I’ve heard reports, even in our area of West Michigan, of people who have applied geothermal pumps in greenhouses and the heat exchanger was way undersized,” Hamstra says. “They pulled the soil temperature down very quickly, and partway through the season it ceased to function.” If applied correctly, growers could see financial benefits for years to come. The benefits of such systems on the environment are big, too.

“Reducing our footprint by only moving energy instead of burning a fossil fuel to create heat is a significant one,” Hamstra says. “I think as an industry, growers have been looking for something to relieve them from these huge fuel bills.”

Leave a Reply

9 comments on “Going Geothermal

  1. i am in the business of building geothermal systems currently i have done one small green house system and works quite well my customer is very happy with it but i have mostly done residential i have the potential for much larger projects i would like to go after. there are many large growers in our area so maybe looking at partnering up with someone who has done larger project and expand our business

  2. I am new to greenhouses but I want a geothermal heating/cooling system for 4 greenhouses. Just wondering how much space is really needed only have about a half acre to spare, is it enough?

  3. I have a good thermal greenhouse question I have been pondering about. When constructing my first portable cold frame I only wanted the cold frame to be as tall as it needed to be for the plant heighth. I thought that the extra room would somehow be all the more space for cold air to hang out. Then I thought maybe it would also be a space where the heat collected during the day to be stored.
    So, my question is that is it advantageous to have extra unused room in a greenhouse to store heat captured during the day? The reason I ask is that I really want to make my next greenhouse a walk-in greenhouse but it doesn’t really “have” to be.

    Thanks,

    Jon

  4. I want to know your experience using underground geothermal water for city building.can you help me? if you help me, i am very thankful. And I wish you happy & health in the new year.

  5. i am in the business of building geothermal systems currently i have done one small green house system and works quite well my customer is very happy with it but i have mostly done residential i have the potential for much larger projects i would like to go after. there are many large growers in our area so maybe looking at partnering up with someone who has done larger project and expand our business

  6. I am new to greenhouses but I want a geothermal heating/cooling system for 4 greenhouses. Just wondering how much space is really needed only have about a half acre to spare, is it enough?

  7. I have a good thermal greenhouse question I have been pondering about. When constructing my first portable cold frame I only wanted the cold frame to be as tall as it needed to be for the plant heighth. I thought that the extra room would somehow be all the more space for cold air to hang out. Then I thought maybe it would also be a space where the heat collected during the day to be stored.
    So, my question is that is it advantageous to have extra unused room in a greenhouse to store heat captured during the day? The reason I ask is that I really want to make my next greenhouse a walk-in greenhouse but it doesn’t really “have” to be.

    Thanks,

    Jon

  8. I want to know your experience using underground geothermal water for city building.can you help me? if you help me, i am very thankful. And I wish you happy & health in the new year.

More From Structures & Equipment...

January 19, 2016

Tips For Cherry-Picking The Right LED Lighting Solution For Your Greenhouse

If you want to find the right LED lighting solution for your greenhouse, start with these tips from top lighting manufacturers.

Read More
Philips Lighting, Colorado State

January 14, 2016

Philips Lighting, Colorado State University Partner On New LED Lighting Research And Training Center

The partnership will allow the two entities to perform collaborative research and focused cultivation studies to validate and innovate around the application of advanced LED lighting for horticultural activity.

Read More

December 21, 2015

More Than 40% Of Growers Will Add Or Retrofit Structures In 2016

An early look at 2016 State of the Industry results shows why some growers are looking to add or retrofit structures in the coming year.

Read More
Latest Stories

January 19, 2016

Tips For Cherry-Picking The Right LED Lighting Solution…

If you want to find the right LED lighting solution for your greenhouse, start with these tips from top lighting manufacturers.

Read More
Philips Lighting, Colorado State

January 14, 2016

Philips Lighting, Colorado State University Partner On …

The partnership will allow the two entities to perform collaborative research and focused cultivation studies to validate and innovate around the application of advanced LED lighting for horticultural activity.

Read More

December 21, 2015

More Than 40% Of Growers Will Add Or Retrofit Structure…

An early look at 2016 State of the Industry results shows why some growers are looking to add or retrofit structures in the coming year.

Read More
Stuppy Greenhouse Manufacturing's Rainbow Super Structure

December 21, 2015

Three Strategies For Overcoming Greenhouse Heating Conc…

Lost heat, maintaining an ideal greenhouse temperature, and inefficiency in heating systems are three of the most common problems growers face when it comes to heating. Here’s a look at some ways to overcome these challenges.

Read More
Europes Largest Rooftop Farm

December 7, 2015

Europe’s Largest Rooftop Farm Underway, Scheduled To Op…

The Netherlands-based facility, a collaboration between Urban Farmers and Van der Valk•Kleijn, will comprise 14,000 square feet of vegetable production in an aquaponics system.

Read More
Feature Image Cob 700 (NewLux)

November 28, 2015

15 LED Lighting Solutions For Your Greenhouse

Narrowing in on the right LED lighting product often comes down to considering your specific crop needs and growing requirements to see what works best for your application. Here are 15 LED products to take into account when choosing the right fit for your greenhouse.

Read More
Battlefield Farms in Virginia noticed an improvement in the quality of heuchera propagation plugs after using Philips’ LED production modules

November 23, 2015

LED Lighting May Be The Next Frontier For Plant Nutriti…

Philips Lighting’s senior plant specialist, Dr. Abhay Thosar, shares how the company is working with growers to help create custom plant recipes for streamlined production of better quality crops.

Read More

October 27, 2015

How Dallas Johnson Greenhouses Is Simplifying Shipping

Two years ago, Dallas Johnson Greenhouses, a 61-acre operation in Council Bluffs, Iowa, and No. 21 of Greenhouse Grower’s Top 100 Growers, was struggling to get its orders out. With its range of potted annuals, there were so many skus that it was impossible to get enough carts into the shipping greenhouse, and the crew couldn’t get orders processed fast enough. As a result, the operation was consistently pulling orders until midnight every night during the busy shipping season, says President and CEO Todd Johnson. So Johnson got together with Arie Van Wingerden at Cherry Creek Systems to discuss his problem, and what they came up with has changed everything, Johnson says. Inside one of Dallas Johnson Greenhouses’ existing structures, the team installed a shipping system made with Echo-Veyors, the popular cable conveyor system designed by Cherry Creek Systems. The system was placed right in the front of the greenhouse, […]

Read More
Tidal Creek Growers

October 24, 2015

Five Tips For Successful Use Of Boom Irrigation Lightin…

Michigan State University Extension shares five tips to help growers use boom irrigation lighting more effectively to accelerate flowering of long-day ornamental crops.

Read More

October 22, 2015

Three Solutions For More Efficient Plant Shipping

Many products are available to help growers minimize cost, increase efficiency and maintain the best plant quality possible during shipment. Here are just a few options designed to make the process smoother.

Read More

October 8, 2015

Industry Standards For Greenhouse Lighting On The Horiz…

As the use of LEDs has risen among greenhouse growers, so have concerns about the best way to measure and compare the many LED light products across the market. As a result, the lighting industry is responding to a call for greater transparency and the development of standardized measuring and testing methods.

Read More

September 28, 2015

11 Products For Precision Greenhouse Growing

These new options in equipment, automation, structures, lighting and software are designed to help growers run their operations with efficiency and accuracy and at a lower cost.

Read More
Laura Drotleff

September 25, 2015

Growers Solve Problems With Precision Horticulture

My dad’s hands are covered with sores, nicks, scratches and bruises. It’s the ongoing reward — or drawback — of his ingenuity, as he’s constantly wrenching on equipment or constructing new innovations that will help him get work done more efficiently on the farm. As a kid, I would always marvel at his toughness, and how he would barely notice a new wound, shrugging it off as he kept working, driven to complete his work and bring his idea to fruition. He’s still at it today, and his hands tell the story of the many projects he’s completed over the years. I’m guessing many of you can relate, and your hands look similar to my dad’s. After all, ingenuity is the name of the game in this business, where creative thinking to solve problems often leads to revolutionary solutions that automate production, save labor and cut costs. That’s easy to […]

Read More

September 24, 2015

AgriNomix Helps Keepsake Plants Cut Labor Costs With Au…

Keepsake Plants reduced labor for trimming Hydrangeas from 60 people to 28 by automating the process with AgriNomix Venti Trimmers.

Read More

September 24, 2015

4 Dramm Products That Put The Precision Into Growing

When accuracy counts, the right tool makes all the difference. New products from Dramm put tools in growers hands to get the job done efficiently.

Read More
The single cells move forward, still grouped with their pack, until the pack is positioned in front of an arm that can pick up several individual plants at a time

September 24, 2015

How Spring Meadow Nursery’s Custom Sorting Machine Kee…

The Michigan-based nursery uses automation to cut apart trays of immature plants and regroups them into new trays of similar-sized plants.

Read More
Figure 3. Sole-source lighting in a multi-layer vertical growing system utilizing hydroponics for vegetable production.

September 23, 2015

MSU Offers New Greenhouse Lighting Online Course For Gr…

  Michigan State University Extension is now offering a non-credit, pre-recorded online course on greenhouse and horticultural lighting. The lighting course is intended for greenhouse and ornamental plant growers and others interested learning about the fundamental concepts about how plants respond to light quality, quantity and in duration. It provides introductory to moderately-challenging content primarily based on experiments performed at Michigan State and Purdue Universities. This is the second course in the College of Knowledge Online series offered on the national Extension website. The first course was Floriculture Root Zone Management, also available online. What Growers Will Learn From Taking This Course The 3-hours of pre-recorded lecture and video demonstrations are divided into seven units. The first and second units cover the properties of light and its importance for plant growth and development. The third unit discusses how light quality influences stem extension and flowering. The fourth unit of the course teaches […]

Read More
ArmstrongGrowers Hanging Basket Area

September 22, 2015

Sole-Source Lighting In Horticulture: Bedding Plant Plu…

Researchers determine how sole-source LED lighting can be used effectively for the production of bedding plant seedlings.

Read More
[gravityform id="35" title="false" description="false"]