Going Geothermal

Going Geothermal

Mark Elzinga held nothing back when he built his four-acre organic greenhouse at Elzinga & Hoeksema in Portage, Mich.

He spent money, took risks and entrusted a lot of people with the future of his operation–people like Stephen Hamstra, executive vice president at GMB, who helped design the solar-geothermal energy system that should provide 80 percent of Elzinga’s heating needs. The GMB-designed system should cut down on Elzinga’s energy costs, as well, and significantly reduce the greenhouse’s carbon footprint.

“The geothermal hybrid is a new thing,” Hamstra says. “I’m not aware of a greenhouse that’s done it like this. We presented the concept in 2006 in a white paper at the International Ground Source Heat Pump Association (IGSHPA) annual meeting in Albany, N.Y., and there was a lot of favorable response.” 

One Of A Kind

Elzinga was among the first to take notice, and he now has an impressive solar-geothermal system that includes 200 solar energy collectors, a 60,000-gallon insulated water tank and a heat exchanger that includes 26 miles of polypropylene tubing sunk in 200 wells that are each 300 feet deep.

The system uses Michigan’s year-round ground temperature to create hot water that’s stored in an above-ground tank and available for most of the greenhouse’s heating needs. In the summer, only a handful of heat is obviously needed in the building, yet available heat from the sun and air is abundant. So that excess heat is pumped into the ground and available to Elzinga the following winter.

Another part of the GMB design involves two air-handling units that sit outside the greenhouse.

“They’re basically fans and big radiator coils,” Hamstra says. “Each one moves 100,000 cubic feet of air per minute. If the air temperature (outside) is warmer than the soil temperature (underground) in the earth heat exchanger, we’ll turn on a pump and circulate cool water through those coils and blow warm air across the coils to also try to capture free solar energy and warm the soil.”

As reliable as Elzinga’s geothermal system is, the greenhouse can’t exclusively depend on heat from it year-round. Once cold temperatures arrive, high-efficiency boilers kick in to make up the difference that the heat pump cannot fill. And, if for some reason the geothermal system needs to be turned off, the boilers are capable of handling the heating load for the entire greenhouse. 

Greenhouse Rookies

Surprisingly, Elzinga is the first greenhouse GMB has ever served. The architectural and engineering company based in Holland, Mich., has mainly worked with the healthcare, corporate and education sectors. And, according to Hamstra, few of his peers have even thought much of having greenhouse growers as clients.

“It’s a huge market with a huge need, and the response is typically that the greenhouse market has been characterized by low-cost heating systems and that growers will put in the minimum to get by,” Hamstra says.

Elzinga’s vertical closed-loop system certainly bucks that trend, but the idea behind it is that the long-term benefits will eventually offset the costs upfront. Still, there’s more to geothermal heat systems in greenhouses than growers simply being open to invest in their futures now. Each greenhouse structure is unique, Hamstra says, and any system GMB installs is custom made.

At Elzinga, GMB was called on midway through the building process. But the earlier it could have been involved, the better, Hamstra says, because geothermal applications are functions of the greenhouse site.

If, for instance, GMB was involved with the Elzinga project at the start, it might have been able to put the bore field underneath the greenhouse itself. And that, among other applications, probably could have reduced the amount of area taken up by various parts of the system, too.

“We need some real estate to do this,” Hamstra says. “Talking to one grower who has a huge aquifer available and a big irrigation system with greenhouses and large open fields, a ground-water heat pump system is certainly a possibility. If you’ve got a good source of ground water, a good place to get rid of it after you’ve just pulled some heat out of it and no bacteria that will cause problems over time, it can work well.” 

Thinking Ahead

A geothermal system can also work well for a greenhouse, Hamstra says, if it collaborates with another building, particularly one that’s refrigerated. In a study conducted last year on a Meijer store in Michigan, GMB found that the store rejects nine times more heat each year than it needs.

Following the study, Hamstra did a computer simulation that gave the Meijer store a geothermal heat pump system, and he put the store side-by-side with Elzinga’s greenhouse. He then found that if Meijer’s waste heat was moved to the greenhouse, the size of Elzinga’s geothermal heat exchanger would drop in half in a virtual building simulation. He also concluded that the greenhouse could use that waste heat to significantly reduce the cost of operation while Meijer had a less-expensive way to lose its heat. “If you’ve got greenhouses that are next to some industrial process–plastic injection molding, even power plants–the waste stream from one industry could become the feedstock for the other industry,” Hamstra says.

As good as that scenario sounds, few growers are positioned right next door to buildings that can accommodate that amount of heat. But if growers are considering geothermal heat pumps for their greenhouses, Hamstra recommends that they consult engineers who’ve gone through the rigors of Certified GeoExchange Designer (CGD) training administered by IGSHPA. The investment is simply too much, he says, to rely on some run-of-the-mill heating company that’s conveniently located.

“I’ve heard reports, even in our area of West Michigan, of people who have applied geothermal pumps in greenhouses and the heat exchanger was way undersized,” Hamstra says. “They pulled the soil temperature down very quickly, and partway through the season it ceased to function.” If applied correctly, growers could see financial benefits for years to come. The benefits of such systems on the environment are big, too.

“Reducing our footprint by only moving energy instead of burning a fossil fuel to create heat is a significant one,” Hamstra says. “I think as an industry, growers have been looking for something to relieve them from these huge fuel bills.”

Leave a Reply

9 comments on “Going Geothermal

  1. i am in the business of building geothermal systems currently i have done one small green house system and works quite well my customer is very happy with it but i have mostly done residential i have the potential for much larger projects i would like to go after. there are many large growers in our area so maybe looking at partnering up with someone who has done larger project and expand our business

  2. I am new to greenhouses but I want a geothermal heating/cooling system for 4 greenhouses. Just wondering how much space is really needed only have about a half acre to spare, is it enough?

  3. I have a good thermal greenhouse question I have been pondering about. When constructing my first portable cold frame I only wanted the cold frame to be as tall as it needed to be for the plant heighth. I thought that the extra room would somehow be all the more space for cold air to hang out. Then I thought maybe it would also be a space where the heat collected during the day to be stored.
    So, my question is that is it advantageous to have extra unused room in a greenhouse to store heat captured during the day? The reason I ask is that I really want to make my next greenhouse a walk-in greenhouse but it doesn’t really “have” to be.

    Thanks,

    Jon

  4. I want to know your experience using underground geothermal water for city building.can you help me? if you help me, i am very thankful. And I wish you happy & health in the new year.

  5. i am in the business of building geothermal systems currently i have done one small green house system and works quite well my customer is very happy with it but i have mostly done residential i have the potential for much larger projects i would like to go after. there are many large growers in our area so maybe looking at partnering up with someone who has done larger project and expand our business

  6. I am new to greenhouses but I want a geothermal heating/cooling system for 4 greenhouses. Just wondering how much space is really needed only have about a half acre to spare, is it enough?

  7. I have a good thermal greenhouse question I have been pondering about. When constructing my first portable cold frame I only wanted the cold frame to be as tall as it needed to be for the plant heighth. I thought that the extra room would somehow be all the more space for cold air to hang out. Then I thought maybe it would also be a space where the heat collected during the day to be stored.
    So, my question is that is it advantageous to have extra unused room in a greenhouse to store heat captured during the day? The reason I ask is that I really want to make my next greenhouse a walk-in greenhouse but it doesn’t really “have” to be.

    Thanks,

    Jon

  8. I want to know your experience using underground geothermal water for city building.can you help me? if you help me, i am very thankful. And I wish you happy & health in the new year.

More From Structures & Equipment...
More and more people are employing a landscape service, but that doesn’t mean they don’t still garden

September 2, 2015

Under Siege? Not Really, Just Go For A Walk

I have no trouble with people buying chocolates or wine instead of flowers to celebrate anniversaries, birthdays or peoples’ lives. We should all have choices. However, the other night I felt like I was entering the Republican caucus. I was minding my own business by the television set and became more than a little upset. A website called insteadofflowers.com came on the screen. It provided serene music and wholesome images of busy women doing busy things. It turns out that such busy women enjoy a small token of appreciation, but apparently their enjoyment, according to the voice-over, does not include flowers. This website delivers meals to the house, anything from beef brisket to beef bourguignon. It is a fine website with a good idea. But why pick on us? Why not use “insteadofbaloneysandwiches.com” or “insteadofgrilledcheeseandsoup.com,” “insteadofburgerdoodle.com,” or a dozen other things. When did flowers get to be the whipping boy? […]

Read More
Triathlon BA container shot

September 2, 2015

OHP Launches Triathlon BA, Offers Marengo SC In Smaller Size

Triathlon BA biofungicide/bactericide is now available to authorized OHP distributors for shipment to states where product registration has been approved. State registration information is available here. A next generation preventive biological fungicide, bactercide Triathlon BA is labeled for use in both organic and conventional production on a wide variety of fungal and bacterial diseases on ornamentals, fruits, vegetables and herbs and spices. With the active ingredient Bacillus amyloliquefaciens, Triathlon BA provides preventive control of many foliar and soil-borne diseases such as botrytis, powdery mildew, downy mildew, rusts, leaf spots, alternaria, pythium, phytophthora, rhizoctonia, fusarium and bacterial spot. Triathlon BA, an aqueous suspension formulation, prevents establishment of disease-causing fungi and bacteria on the plant tissues. Depending on the target disease, users can foliar-apply or soil drench Triathlon BA. Repeat applications may be made at three- to 28-day intervals. Under environmental conditions that are conducive to disease development, users may apply at three- to […]

Read More

September 2, 2015

Delegation Is Key To A Successful Greenhouse Operation

In a packed room at Cultivate’15, speaker Bernie Erven presented key steps growers need to take to improve their delegation skills, the benefits of delegating and the dangers of not learning how to delegate. This is a skill, he says, that everyone needs to learn. “For all of you who are part of a family business, you are choosing not to do things the easy way,” Erven laughed, as he presented a list of ways to know whether or not you’re an effective delegator. The owner of Erven HR Services, LLC, Erven has been working with and observing family businesses for many years. In his presentation, he said, he didn’t share anything that he hasn’t seen first-hand. You might not be a good delegator if you: Tend to be a perfectionist Work more hours than anyone else Lack time to explain clearly and concisely Are often interrupted Enjoy what you used to […]

Read More
Latest Stories
Figure 1. Mustard microgreens grown under sole-source (SS) lighting using light-emitting diode (LED) arrays.

August 21, 2015

Sole-Source LED Lighting In Horticulture: Microgreens P…

In Part 2 of a four-part lighting series highlighting the multiple uses of light-emitting diodes (LEDs), researchers examine the effects of sole-source LED lighting on microgreen production to achieve the highest quality crop possible in an energy efficient manner.

Read More
Lighting 2015 August Feature Image

August 14, 2015

Customizing Crop Foliage Color With LEDs: Ornamental Cr…

Do you find that your purple fountain grass (Pennisetum setaceum ‘Rubrum’) crop is often green to light purple? What if we told you there is a quick solution to enhance and darken the foliage of purple fountain grass or other floriculture crops? In this second article of a four-part series highlighting the multiple uses of high-intensity light-emitting diodes (LEDs), we will discuss our research methodology and findings for enhancing the foliage color of ornamental crops with end-of-production (EOP) supplemental lighting (SL) in the greenhouse. Many ornamental crops that greenhouse and nursery growers produce vary in size, shape and color. These variables are often influenced by the growing environment. For example, leaf color (intensity, distribution or both) of ornamental crops such as purple fountain grass is a key component that often influences the consumer’s perception and ultimately an impulse purchase. The red or purple pigmentation of purple fountain grass leaves is […]

Read More
WaterPulse retail mats can help cut water use in retail settings

August 10, 2015

Technology Provides Solutions For Growing In Drought

In April, California Gov. Jerry Brown directed the State Water Resources Control Board to institute reductions in cities and towns across the state with the goal of reducing water usage by 25 percent. The announcement comes following the lowest snowpack ever recorded in the High Sierra. It was the first time in state history that action was taken to implement mandatory water restrictions. In May, the farmers in California’s Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta agreed to reduce their water use by 25 percent in exchange for assurance that they will not face further curtailment during the June to September growing season. Their proposal was approved by the State Water Resources Control Board. Growers who participate in the program could opt to either reduce water diversions under their riparian rights by 25 percent, or fallow 25 percent of their land. Given these conditions, growers and retailers are in need of methods and […]

Read More
Heating Roundup Feature Image

August 1, 2015

5 New Heating Options For The Greenhouse

Five heating systems manufacturers share their latest and greatest products. Tubing And Aluminum Heat Pipes (BioTherm) From Megatube and MicroClimate tubing to DuoFin and StarFin aluminum heat pipe, BioTherm is dedicated to providing heat solutions that can withstand the toughest greenhouse environments. The MegaTube and MicroClimate tubing options are easy to install and ideal for bench or floor heating. The tubing has a conductive heating surface that allows for maximum root-zone heating. The DuoFin and StarFin aluminum pipe options are great for perimeter heating and melting snow trapped in the greenhouse gutter. It can also be useful for bench heating. Both pipe options provide gentle, radiant heat for plants and don’t require welding. TrueLeaf.net Infinite Energy 2 Condensing Boiler (Delta T Solutions) With up to 98 percent efficiency, the IE2 condensing boiler boasts a stainless steel heat exchanger with larger waterways to ensure maximum heat transfer. The product’s design ensures flexibility while […]

Read More
Heating Feature image

July 27, 2015

In Hot Pursuit Of Heating Trends For The Greenhouse

From biomass boilers to hydronic-heating systems, growers have a range of options to fit their operation’s unique needs. Here’s what five manufacturers had to say about the latest trends.

Read More
lighting feature

June 29, 2015

Customizing Crop Foliage Color With LEDs: Red Leaf Let…

In the first of a four-part series highlighting the multiple uses of light-emitting diodes (LEDs), researchers share how end-of-production supplemental lighting with LEDs enhances red leaf lettuce color prior to harvesting and shipping.

Read More

June 28, 2015

Keep Your Cool In The Greenhouse

Summer is in full swing, and that means growers need to worry about protecting plants and greenhouse employees from brutal temperatures. No sweat! These product manufacturers have offerings to help beat the heat.

Read More
Greenhouse Electrical System

June 23, 2015

Don’t Let Your Greenhouse Electrical System Come …

The size of a greenhouse operation is one of the biggest factors when determining the type of electrical system to install. Part 2 of "Don't Let Your Electrical System Come Up Short" covers locating electrical wires, meeting electrical load demands and environmental considerations.

Read More
Schaefer-fan

June 23, 2015

Schaefer Ventilation Opens Distribution Center In Atlan…

Schaefer Ventilation Equipment, a manufacturer of ventilation and thermal comfort products, has opened a new distribution center in Atlanta, Ga., to increase efficiency and provide faster services to dealers. Additionally, the company has added a new staff member to its agricultural and horticultural division to help expand markets in Latin America.

Read More

June 21, 2015

Greenhouse Project Moves Pavlodar (Kazakhstan) Closer T…

Despite regional challenges, greenhouse specialists Dalsem and automation supplier Hoogendoorn have collaborated on a greenhouse complex with the PTK company to bring Pavlodar (Kazakhstan) closer to self-sufficient, local food production.

Read More
HID Lighting System

June 18, 2015

Talking Shop: Using Lighting To Boost Beneficials

Peace Tree Farm was looking for a way to maintain beneficial insect populations through the winter. It found a potential solution through the use of rotating HID lighting.

Read More

June 17, 2015

Costa Farms Reduces Greenhouse Emissions With Solar Pow…

Costa Farms is seeking to make sustainability a top priority at its headquarters and two other buildings in Miami with the recent construction of new solar panels, which will replace 25 percent of the company's power usage with solar energy.

Read More
aquatrols

June 3, 2015

Aquatrols Renews Cooperative Research And Development A…

Aquatrols Corporation recently announced a new Cooperative Research and Development Agreement (CRADA) with Dr. Matt Madsen and the USDA Agricultural Research Service. The objective of the new CRADA is to further refine and evaluate surfactant seed coating technologies for use in wildfire rehabilitation, turf and pasture grasses, restoration species and other horticultural and agricultural systems. The three-year agreement renews a CRADA that Aquatrols first signed with the ARS in 2012. The original partnership has resulted in promising field and greenhouse trials, pending patents and initial steps toward commercialization of the surfactant seed coating technology. “We are very encouraged by the work that Dr. Madsen and his team have put together over the past three years,” says Aquatrols’ President and CEO Tracy Jarman. “This innovative technology has shown incredible potential with wide-ranging impacts in multiple industries. Aquatrols’ stated mission is to change the way the world grows and this technology has the […]

Read More
Greenhouse Electrical System

May 26, 2015

Don’t Let Your Greenhouse Electrical System Come …

Ensuring your greenhouse has enough electricity to operate all the equipment that is installed takes planning and consideration of an operation's needs. Part one of two articles on greenhouse electrical systems covers choosing an electrician, meeting immediate and future needs and planning for back-up power.

Read More

May 22, 2015

Nexus Greenhouses Is Optimistic For Expansion Into New …

Cheryl Longtin and Mike Porter, who own Nexus Corporation, say they were excited to attend the grand opening of Gotham Greens’ new structure atop the new Whole Foods grocery store in the Gowanus neighborhood in Brooklyn, N.Y., when it opened in December 2013. The project is just one example of some of the new and expanding markets that Nexus Corporation has expanded into over the past few years. Jeff Warschauer, vice president of sales for Nexus, says the company has enjoyed getting to know and working with the founders of Gotham Greens, Viraj Puri and Eric Haley, and Jennifer Nelkin Frymark, the chief agriculture officer, on their innovative approach to business. “They are very excited and work hard internally – just great people,” he says. “From our perspective, it’s great to see that excitement and vision. The employees there are happy and there’s no turnover; they’re only adding new people […]

Read More
Canadian Army Reserve training at GGS Structures.

April 30, 2015

GGS Structures Hosts Canadian Army Reserve Tactical Tra…

GGS Structures showed support for the Canadian military by opening up its fabric-covered Tasco Dome for tactical training to help soldiers prepare to fight in urban settings.

Read More
Growers are looking for low-cost options for temperature control, like circulating fans and exhaust fans.

April 10, 2015

New Ways To Give Growers Control Of The Greenhouse Envi…

From heating systems to circulation fans, manufacturing companies are finding new ways to help growers control the greenhouse environment, save on energy costs and streamline production.

Read More
Hendriks-Half-Open-Roof_GGS

March 26, 2015

10 Greenhouse Products For First-Rate Growing Environme…

From coverings to fork-lifts, greenhouse suppliers offer a variety of products to make growing easier. Check out the slideshow to learn more about these, plus several other products that can offer you value, versatility and durability.

Read More