I Don’t Want To Be A Chicken Farmer

It was quite a get-together at the Southeast Color Connection show back in June in Greenville, S.C. Most growers in attendance enjoyed a good spring market and were walking the exhibits, participating in educational programs or just connecting with each other.

On the last day of the show, I participated in a forum titled “Do Brands Work?” The question to be answered was: Are brands like Proven Winners, Burpee, Wave, Simply Beautiful, Plants That Work, Athens Select and others of value to the grower, retailer and consumer?
Most of the big-name branders were in the room, along with a good number of growers, large and small. The folks involved were passionate about their brands and, perhaps at times, a wee bit too passionate.

The session was a little more than halfway over when one of the presenters got caught up in the passion of a particular brand and became a little too zealous about the benefits of said pots, labels and brand. At that point, an independent grower asked why she should use a branded product also carried by the box stores. Then another stated that it is the plant that must work–the pot and brand are well and good–but why must he pay for a plant when it’s available generically. Why must those plants be put in your pot? A number of other questions followed, all civilized. We were in the South, after all.

Growers As Brand Developers

The discussion was perhaps a little too civilized, because Carole Barton of Barton’s Greenhouse and Nursery in Alabama could not contain herself. I have known Carole a long time and I know that when she says something, everyone should listen. I certainly did.

Her first statement was that she was fascinated by the comments. Carole was pretty calm, I thought to myself. But then, in fine Bartonesque prose, she started surgically unraveling the threads.

“If I accept your brand as being important to my business, I must accept that you control what plant I must sell, how to label it, what the pot looks like and how to grow it,” she says. “I am in business because I choose the best plants, not necessarily your plants. I don’t want to be a chicken farmer working for you.”

When the panelist responded by asking why Carole thinks people wear Nike T-shirts, she nodded and said, “My point exactly.”

Carole is by no means anti-brand. In fact, she has toyed with developing her own local brand. Her point is that she was a far better judge of what plants her customers desire than the proponents of any brand, especially one that makes lots of rules on what and how she should sell those plants.

It was not a political rally. When the smoke cleared, there was no polarization or rancor. Some good points had been made on the pros and cons of branding, in a forum that allowed people to listen, to comment and to make some decisions. Brands have always been with us and as sure as day turns to night, they will be even more obvious in the future.

However, as much as this industry wants to be like Thomas Furniture or Mercedes-Benz, the plant is still king and growers like Carole will keep the industry honest.

Leave a Reply

More From Varieties...

August 20, 2017

Proven Winners and Kentucky Nursery and Landscape Association to Partner on Summer Outing

This year, KNLA is combining its summer outing with the Proven Winners Landscape Roadshow for an informative event that will take place on September 21.

Read More
Four Star 2018 Catalog

August 18, 2017

Four Star Greenhouses’ 2018 Catalog Includes New Varieties and Cultural Tips

The new catalog is available in both print and digital formats, and features information on new trays that allow for more plugs per square foot.

Read More
Francis Kwong, PanAmerican Seed

August 15, 2017

Ornamental Seed Scientist Francis Kwong Dies at Age 65

Kwong was most recently the Director of Seed Technology for PanAmerican Seed, and his research was instrumental in the development of calibrachoa, angelonia, and other plants.

Read More
Latest Stories

August 20, 2017

Proven Winners and Kentucky Nursery and Landscape Assoc…

This year, KNLA is combining its summer outing with the Proven Winners Landscape Roadshow for an informative event that will take place on September 21.

Read More
Four Star 2018 Catalog

August 18, 2017

Four Star Greenhouses’ 2018 Catalog Includes New Variet…

The new catalog is available in both print and digital formats, and features information on new trays that allow for more plugs per square foot.

Read More
Francis Kwong, PanAmerican Seed

August 15, 2017

Ornamental Seed Scientist Francis Kwong Dies at Age 65

Kwong was most recently the Director of Seed Technology for PanAmerican Seed, and his research was instrumental in the development of calibrachoa, angelonia, and other plants.

Read More
Candy Tops Snapdragons Series (Sakata Ornamentals)

August 3, 2017

Five Characteristics Breeders Want in Top-Performing Sp…

New spring annuals have to provide something for everyone — longevity, durability, performance, and more — if they want to meet breeders’ high standards for market-worthy plants.

Read More
Petunia 'Headliner Pink Sky" (Selecta)

August 3, 2017

Why Eccentricity is the New Black in Spring Annuals

Consumers judge plants by appearance, color impact, and ease of maintenance, which is why retailers want new spring annuals that are novel standouts.    

Read More

August 1, 2017

39 New Vegetables and Herbs for 2018

New vegetable and herb introductions for 2017 offer unique shaped fruits, distinctive foliage, intense flavors, improved disease resistance, high yields, and more. Here are 39 new vegetable and herb varieties to consider for your product mix in 2018.

Read More
2018 Griffin Catalog

July 31, 2017

Griffin Releases Print and Digital Versions of Its 2018…

The 250-page print catalog features more than 350 new varieties from leading breeders, while the enhanced digital version has extra features on crop culture, grower tools, and more.

Read More
Emerald-Coast-Growers-Guide-Feature-Image

July 27, 2017

Emerald Coast Growers Offers Updated Guide on its Newes…

This year’s guide features new varieties while maintaining Emerald Coast’s ornamental grass program and expanding its perennial plants line.

Read More
Terra Nova Shipping Box

July 20, 2017

Terra Nova Nurseries, Dümmen Orange to Partner on Unroo…

Terra Nova Nurseries has contracted with Dümmen Orange to produce unrooted cuttings (URCs) from Terra Nova private stock located at Dümmen Orange’s Central America facilities. The URCs will fulfill orders in North America and Europe.

Read More

July 20, 2017

New Perennials, Trial Gardens, and Merchandising Were H…

Darwin Perennials Day has steadily become one of the must-attend perennial events of the summer. This year, even the weather cooperated.

Read More
2018 Ball Seed Catalog

July 17, 2017

Ball Seed’s 2018 New Varieties Catalog Now Available

The expanded guide includes breakthrough breeding from Ball in annuals, perennials, vegetables, potted plants, and more.

Read More
Pleasant View Open House

July 16, 2017

Pleasant View Gardens, D.S. Cole Growers Hosting Open H…

The event gives horticulture industry professionals the chance to check out nearly 80 new introductions from Proven Winners, as well as Pleasant View’s new Savor Edibles & Fragrants line.

Read More
All American Selections

July 12, 2017

All-America Selections Celebrates Milestone Anniversary…

Coinciding with its 85th anniversary celebration, AAS is hosting an open house at its new offices, and has also released its annual report.

Read More

July 8, 2017

Plant Patent Law: Protecting the Variety Pipeline

Breeders call for better cooperation in protecting intellectual property while considering how stricter laws and expensive patents could impact the future of innovation.

Read More
Calibrachoa ‘Superbells Holy Moly!’ (Proven Winners)

July 8, 2017

Are Utility Patents Tying Up Innovation With Litigation…

The opportunities for innovation in plant breeding could be greatly advanced by creating an industry-led patent licensing platform.

Read More

July 8, 2017

Fleuroselect and CIOPORA Offer Organizational Leadershi…

Learn why breeders feel these organizations should be emulated in an industry-led initiative to protect plant breeding efforts.

Read More
Thalictrum Nimbus White (Terra Nova Nurseries)

June 30, 2017

Kelly Norris Dishes on New Plants, Going to Seed, and B…

From woody perennials to genetically modified petunias, Kelly Norris gives his take on what turned out to be a busy spring.

Read More
Jim Devereux, Green Fuse Botanicals

June 24, 2017

Green Fuse Botanicals New Vice President is Focused on …

Jim Devereux, who will oversee production, sales, and marketing for Green Fuse, says he hopes to bring genetics to the market that break from traditional production methods for finished growers.

Read More