Don’t You Just Hate Those Big Boxes?

Don't You Just Hate Those Big Boxes?

It is clear to me that consumers are willing to open their wallets only when they feel we bring them good value and continually introduce new and interesting products that increase their chances of success. Whether consumers are shopping at big box stores or a local nursery with just one location, our goal should be to keep them buying more and make them more successful while bringing a new generation into the world of outdoor living.

Some members of the industry like to degrade the big boxes as less-than-legitimate purveyors of green goods. Some have not been able to see the evolution of the industry as a positive and would be happy if we returned to the days of limited distribution and little to no price competition. The big boxes admittedly have brought major changes to the industry that have changed the way we all do business. Let’s not forget they have also brought tremendous growth that would not have been conceivable or possible without them.

The three significant national retailers–Home Depot, Lowe’s and Walmart–have made unbelievable contributions to the growth of the industry through major store expansion that included new selling space for green goods. On the other hand, there has been little expansion among independent garden centers (IGC)–the bulk of which are single-location retailers.

Clearly, there are many opportunities for the IGC segment, some of whom are the greatest retailers in the country (i.e. Armstrong, Pike, Homestead, Lukas, Bordine’s), but the reality is the big boxes overwhelmingly outnumber and outsell the IGC group.

The Good & The Bad

In 2009, Home Depot, Lowe’s and Walmart had a combined 7,378 stores. Let’s say the average green goods selling space in those 7,378 stores averages 10,000 square feet per unit–a very conservative number that would equate to 73,780,000 square feet (1,696 acres) of selling space for this industry’s products. So why would we not love these guys?

The obvious answer is they brought significant change to the industry and created a much higher level of accountability that frankly did not exist prior to their entry. Now, let’s examine the changes that have occurred driven by the national retailers, divided into two categories: 1) changes the industry likes; and 2) changes the industry doesn’t like.

Among the changes the industry likes are that the big boxes increased the demand to unprecedented volumes along with increasing the vendor’s cash flow because they paid faster. Big boxes also made the industry have a better understanding of retail, created a closer consumer connection and caused a revolution in packaging.

Among the changes the industry doesn’t like: Big boxes demanded better prices, made their vendors accountable, made many decisions the grower used to make, demanded a more diverse product portfolio and insisted on accurate labeling, including UPC. Big boxes also instituted non-performance penalties, along with pay by scan, which changed the way greenhouses are managed.

Because of the changing requirements, cost of production became an industry concern. In the 1970s, Aart Van Wingerden understood the need for low-cost production and started selling greenhouses that could lead to lower costs. Many growers bought into his system and endorsed his philosophy. Van Wingerden is, in my mind, the greatest visionary the industry has ever seen. He understood how to satisfy the appetites of these national retailers while doing it profitably.

A Different Perspective

Today, these large retailers continue to provide us with a growth in retail space by adding new stores every year. We can almost be certain without looking at the numbers that 40 or 50 new garden centers will be built every year. So why should some industry members rant and rave about what they consider a negative impact? This industry would be at least 50 percent smaller without the impact of the national retailers, and the consumer would be paying twice as much for green goods.

We hear comments like “the plants at the big boxes are poor quality” or “the prices are too cheap, the grower can’t make money.” It is impossible to imagine a buyer telling a grower: “I don’t care what the plants look like, you just have to meet my price needs.”

The buyers aren’t judged on the buy; they are judged on the sell–gross margins same store sales and GMROI. If there are inferior plants in a big box garden center, it is the result of the vendor–not the retailer–and if the product quality causes a decrease in sales or an increase in discards, then that vendor will, in the long run, not be serving that retailer.

In the 2,000-plus stores I’ve visited, I have seen varying levels of product quality that is the result of vendor performance in production, distribution and merchandising. All retailers want to deliver value, and they don’t mean low prices coupled with bad merchandise. Understanding the role of the vendor is crucial to the success of any company choosing to do business with the large national retailers.

As we are clearly in the era of “retailer in charge,” some companies have figured it out and manage their business to satisfy their customers. And they do it very profitably. Although there are those who chide the national retailers, there is a sizable group that loves them because they are making a lot of money serving them.

Leave a Reply

4 comments on “Don’t You Just Hate Those Big Boxes?

  1. Jerry, you nailed it. Along with Don Blume’s interview and Alan Armatage’s insightful analysis on Carol Barton’s comments on brands I think this issue of GG was among the best ever on relating the state of the industry. I think it is a great thing that this industry gets together as often and as openly as they do to share what is going on. I am so pleased to have events like OFA and the Seeley conference and others where we can come together and share. Thank you all.

  2. Thank you for writing this article! As someone who works for a wholesale grower who sells mostly to big box stores, it’s nice to finally have someone talk positive about them instead of looking at them like they are some sort of plague. So much of the product sent into these stores straight from the grower is some of the best quality even compared to some of the independents. The difference is it is then the individual stores responsbility to care for the product. Thats why some stores look great and others trashy. Some management love their garden centers and others could care less they have one. That’s the difficulty for me, to see what I know is a good quality product not be watered in 100 degree water for days because someone just called in sick. It’s embarassing to us a grower as well to see our product look poorly in stores.

  3. Jerry, you nailed it. Along with Don Blume’s interview and Alan Armatage’s insightful analysis on Carol Barton’s comments on brands I think this issue of GG was among the best ever on relating the state of the industry. I think it is a great thing that this industry gets together as often and as openly as they do to share what is going on. I am so pleased to have events like OFA and the Seeley conference and others where we can come together and share. Thank you all.

  4. Thank you for writing this article! As someone who works for a wholesale grower who sells mostly to big box stores, it’s nice to finally have someone talk positive about them instead of looking at them like they are some sort of plague. So much of the product sent into these stores straight from the grower is some of the best quality even compared to some of the independents. The difference is it is then the individual stores responsbility to care for the product. Thats why some stores look great and others trashy. Some management love their garden centers and others could care less they have one. That’s the difficulty for me, to see what I know is a good quality product not be watered in 100 degree water for days because someone just called in sick. It’s embarassing to us a grower as well to see our product look poorly in stores.

More From Finance/Operations...
PP&L CAST 2015 intros

April 22, 2015

6 Breeding Companies Serve Up New Varieties At Pacific Plug & Liner

Pacific Plug & Liner’s theme this year, Labyrinth, a conservatory of the world’s most captivating plants, was perfectly topped off (pun intended) with fascinators for the women and newsboy caps for the men. The PP&L team dressed their part to act out the gothic “conservatory of the world’s most captivating plants.” Truly, the displays looked like they practically popped out of a catalog, and the costumes were a nice touch. Retailers take heed, the fully merchandised displays at Pacific Plug & Liner are worthy of emulating. We’ll let the pictures tell the story of all the fabulous variety introductions presented at  Pacific Plug & Liner’s 2015 California Spring Trials, where Cultivaris, Cohen Nurseries, Histil Nurseries, Jaldety Nurseries, Southern Living/Sunset Collection and Pacific Plug & Liner all highlighted their 2016 introductions.  

Read More
Speedling 2015 CAST intros

April 22, 2015

Speedling Inc. Presents New Varieties From ABZ Seeds, Hem Genetics, Thompson & Morgan, Vista Farms & PSI

You name it, we saw it at Speedling's California Spring Trials location in San Juan Bautista, where five companies showed off their new introductions for 2016.

Read More
PittMoss on Shark Tank

April 22, 2015

PittMoss Wins On Shark Tank

Mont Handley, president and CEO of PittMoss, appeared on ABC’s Shark Tank on April 17 to try to get the “sharks” to invest in his peat moss alternative. Three investors from the TV show contributed $600,000 to PittMoss for a 35 percent stake in the company. Check out this clip from ABC’s website in which Mark Cuban, Kevin O’Leary and Robert Herjavec discuss getting on board with the product. PittMoss is an alternative to sphagnum peat moss, made up of a mix of proprietary additives and recycled paper rescued from landfill space. Handley founded the Pittsburgh-based company in 1994. What started as a small experiment grew into a full-fledged business with the help of funding provided by an EPA SBIR grant and Pittsburgh’s Idea Foundry. Today, PittMoss is available to commercial greenhouses and nurseries from Michigan to Maine to North Carolina, with plans to grow. To learn more, visit PittMoss’ website, or check it […]

Read More
Latest Stories
PittMoss on Shark Tank

April 22, 2015

PittMoss Wins On Shark Tank

Mont Handley, president and CEO of PittMoss, appeared on ABC’s Shark Tank on April 17 to try to get the “sharks” to invest in his peat moss alternative. Three investors from the TV show contributed $600,000 to PittMoss for a 35 percent stake in the company. Check out this clip from ABC’s website in which Mark Cuban, Kevin O’Leary and Robert Herjavec discuss getting on board with the product. PittMoss is an alternative to sphagnum peat moss, made up of a mix of proprietary additives and recycled paper rescued from landfill space. Handley founded the Pittsburgh-based company in 1994. What started as a small experiment grew into a full-fledged business with the help of funding provided by an EPA SBIR grant and Pittsburgh’s Idea Foundry. Today, PittMoss is available to commercial greenhouses and nurseries from Michigan to Maine to North Carolina, with plans to grow. To learn more, visit PittMoss’ website, or check it […]

Read More
Syngenta logo

April 15, 2015

Syngenta Names Chris Freeman Senior Key Account Manager…

Chris Freeman is the new senior key account manager for Syngenta Flowers, Home & Garden's Commercial Sales business in the Americas, effective March 2015. Freeman, who joined Syngenta in 2006, carries more than 25 years of experience in the agriculture and floriculture business.

Read More
Lake Buchanan_LCRA

April 10, 2015

USDA Designates Areas Of West And Southwest As Drought …

The ongoing drought has resulted in disaster area designations in counties across nine Western and Southwestern states, including Texas, where some reservoirs are at or near historically low levels.

Read More

April 9, 2015

Altman Plants’ Online Cactus Shop Shows Strong Sa…

Altman Plants recently opened its new Cactus Shop, an online retail store that sells a variety of cactus and succulents. The store is a take-off of Altman’s original wholesale business, as the company started as a mail order catalog.

Read More
Dummen

April 8, 2015

Dümmen Group Welcomes Jim Devereux And Andrew Konicki T…

Dümmen group recently announced the addition of Jim Devereux and Andrew Konicki to its team. They are the newest members of the Key Account and Broker Support team for Dümmen, and will be responsible for building, developing and maintaining current broker and grower customer relationships.

Read More
Gov._Jerry_Brown_California

April 8, 2015

California Institutes First Ever Statewide Mandatory Wa…

California Gov. Jerry Brown announced April 1 that, for the first time in state history, action will be taken to implement mandatory water restrictions, with the ultimate goal of reducing water usage by 25 percent. As Californians are pushed to conserve more, growers will need to think about how demand for products will be affected.

Read More
DNA-logo

March 31, 2015

DNA Green Group Will Acquire Rijnplant

DNA Green Group and Riknplant have finalized DNA Green Group's acquisition of Rijnplant, meaning that the breeding and propagation activities in pot and cut anthurium, bougainvillea and heliconia will transfer to DNA Green Group.

Read More
AFE scholarship_Ryan Dickson

March 25, 2015

AFE Educational Grant And Scholarship Application Deadl…

Apply now for American Floral Endowment (AFE) scholarships or educational grants. Applications can be found online. For educational grants for 2015-2016, applications must be submitted no later than June 1. Scholarship applications are due May 1. AFE will award $40,000 in scholarships for 2015.

Read More

March 23, 2015

UF/IFAS Appoints Joseph Albano As Director Of Mid-Flori…

The University of Florida's Institute of Food and Agricultural Sciences (UF/IFAS) has a new directors for its Mid-Florida Research and Education Center (REC) on Apopka, Fla. The role has been filled by Joseph Albano, a research horticulturist from the U.S. Department of Agriculture with more than 25 years of experience.

Read More

March 17, 2015

Pike Nurseries Implements Employee Stock Ownership Plan

Independent garden retailer Pike Nurseries has announced it will become an employee-owned company. Pike Nurseries management has combined with its sister corporation in California, Armstrong Garden Centers, to operate under an established Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP).

Read More
GrowIt! App Wins Gold At Design100 2014 US Mobile & App Design Awards

March 10, 2015

GrowIt! Mobile App Now Available For Android

The mobile app GrowIt! Garden Socially can now be used by gardeners with Android-based smartphones. Now available on the Google Play Market, GrowIt! helps users find plants to fit their lifestyle and connect them with other local gardeners.

Read More

March 4, 2015

Second Annual GreenhouseConnect Will Bring Growers and …

Following a successful inaugural event in Tampa last fall, Greenhouse Grower has announced the dates of its second annual GreenhouseConnect: October 26-29, 2015. Representatives of an expected two dozen leading greenhouse operations from across the U.S. will join senior-level suppliers at Rancho Bernardo Inn in San Diego for several days of one-on-one strategic meetings, a growers-only roundtable, informational sessions and a variety of networking events.

Read More

March 4, 2015

Maryland Green Industry Associations Unite

The Maryland Nursery and Landscape Association recently announced that it is expanding its reach to include the greenhouse industry, meaning it has become The Maryland Nursery, Landscape and Greenhouse Association (MNLGA). The change comes as a result of the planned dissolution of the former Maryland Greenhouse Growers Association and the invitation for those members to join the existing and renamed association.

Read More
IPPS Sharing Plant Production Knowledge Globally Logo

February 25, 2015

International Plant Propagators Western Region Sets Ann…

The annual meet for the International Plant Propagators' Society (IPPS) Western Region has been set for this September. It will take place September 23 to 26 in Modesto, Calif., and will include learning sessions, tours to local nurseries, a research poster display and poster presentations, various networking opportunities and an awards banquet to close the event.

Read More
myers industries Lawn and Garden Logo

February 24, 2015

Myers Industries, Inc. Lawn And Garden Business Sold, N…

The management of Myers Lawn and Garden Group, along with Wingate Partners V, L.P. have recently acquired the Myers Industries, Inc. Lawn and Garden business. The new company is named The HC Companies, and will continue as a North American leading provider of horticulture containers supplying the greenhouse, nursery and retail markets.

Read More
american-hort-logo

February 17, 2015

AmericanHort Announces New Board Members

AmericanHort recently announced the election of new officers and members to the board of directors. Each will assume their positions on the board during Cultivate’15, July 11 to 14 in Columbus, Ohio.

Read More
All American Selections

February 17, 2015

All-America Selections Elects New Officers, Names New J…

While meeting during the Flower and Vegetable Seed Conference in Tampa, Fla., hosted by the American Seed Trade Association, All-America Selections elected new officers for a two-year term. Read on to learn about the new officers, as well as all of the new judges that were added in 2014.

Read More
Greenhouse Grower.com on your desktop, on your phone, on your tablet

February 11, 2015

GreenhouseGrower.com Relaunches With Responsive Design …

Greenhouse Grower magazine, the nation’s leader in profits, production and education for greenhouse growers, announces the launch of its completely redesigned website, GreenhouseGrower.com. The new design is the product of direct user feedback and GreenhouseGrower.com analytics, and includes responsive design for ease of mobile use.

Read More