Impact Of Fungicides On Natural Enemies

Previously, I have written articles on the compatibility of alternative pesticides, primarily insecticides and miticides, with biological control agents or natural enemies such as parasitoids and predators. In general, natural enemies tend to be more susceptible to insecticides and miticides than insect and mite pests. However, fungicides are applied routinely in greenhouses to control both aboveground and belowground fungal pathogens. So how compatible are fungicides with natural enemies?

Although fungicides may not be directly or immediately harmful to a specific natural enemy, there may be indirect or sublethal effects, such as delayed development of the prey and natural enemy, delayed adult emergence of the natural enemy or decreased natural enemy survival. There is, in general, less information on the direct (immediate) and indirect (sublethal) effects of fungicides on natural enemies.

In fact, both the Koppert and BioBest Side Effects Manual/Guide contain minimal information on the effects of fungicides on many natural enemies compared to insecticides and miticides. In addition, many studies have involved natural enemies that are typically found in field or fruit crop production systems. 

Harmful Combinations

When using biological control agents in greenhouse production systems, it is important that fungicide applications not directly or indirectly harm natural enemies in order to avoid disrupting the success of biological control programs.

In general, older fungicides tend to be harmful to most natural enemies, which may be associated with these fungicides having a broad mode of action. Sublethal concentrations of fungicides may affect the fecundity or fertility of natural enemy females by either directly reducing oviposition or decreasing percent egg hatch. For example, mancozeb (Protect T/O) reduces egg-hatch of Amblyseius andersonii eggs. However, mancozeb displays no indirect effects on females and does not impact offspring or young in regards to growth rate and mortality. Mancozeb has been shown to reduce the parasitism rate of the caterpillar parasitoid, Trichogramma cacoeciae by 100 percent. Both mancozeb and thiophanate-methyl (Cleary’s 3336 or Fungo) are directly harmful to the predatory mite, Typhlodromus pyri. Applications of thiophanate-methyl may also result in sublethal effects such as sterilizing T. pyri females. Additionally, mixtures of mancozeb or thiophanate-methyl with the insecticide chlorpyrifos (Dursban or DuraGuard) are more directly toxic to the predatory mite than when these pesticides are applied separately.

Although no longer commercially available, benomyl (Benlate) is toxic to the immature and adult stages of several predatory mites including Amblyseius fallacis and Metaseiulus occidentalis. Predatory mites exposed to benomyl applications tend to have higher adult mortality and decreased female reproductive capacity or fecundity. Furthermore, predatory mites are negatively affected when consuming prey that contains benomyl residues. The fungicides, vinclozolin (Ornalin) and iprodione (Chipco 26019) have been shown to be directly harmful to the first and second instar larvae of the coccinellid, Adalia bipunctata. Maneb, which is an old fungicide and no longer registered for use in greenhouses, is extremely toxic to the parasitoid Microplitis croceipes; however, maneb is not adversely harmful to the commonly used twospotted spider mite (Tetranychus urticae) predatory mite (Phytoseiulus persimilis).

The newer fungicides are typically less toxic to natural enemies, which may be associated with their site-specific mode of action. For example, the demethylation-inhibiting (DMI) fungicides triflumazole (Terraguard) and myclobutanil (Eagle), and the strobilurin fungicide trifloxystrobin (Compass) are not harmful to the twospotted spider mite predator, Galendromus occidentalis. None of the fungicides exhibited any direct or sublethal effects. For example, the fungicides did not affect egg hatch, female fecundity rate or increase immature or adult mortality compared to the untreated checks. The fungicides triadimefon (Strike) and fenarimol (Rubigan) have been shown to control diseases without harming predatory mites, which avoids disrupting the biological control of twospotted spider mite. 

In The Lab

In our research, we have demonstrated under laboratory conditions that the fungicides fosetyl-Al (Aliette) and mefenoxam (Subdue Maxx), which are typically applied as a drench to control root rot pathogens such as Pythium spp. and Phytophthora spp., are compatible with the soil-predatory mite Stratiolaelaps scimitus (=”Hypoaspis miles”) since neither fungicide negatively affected the development of the protonymph stage and reproduction of adult females.

Although not directly harmful to natural enemies, fungicides may have repellent activity that may deter natural enemies from locating insect or mite hosts or inhibit foraging behavior, which will affect the ability of natural enemies to regulate insect and mite pests.

It is important to note that most studies associated with evaluating the effects of fungicides on natural enemies are conducted under laboratory evaluations in which the natural enemies are enclosed in Petri dishes exposed to fungicide treatments (either wet or dry residues). These evaluations tend to over-estimate the effects of fungicides compared to those effects observed in the field since the laboratory tests are designed to represent a worst case situation. If the fungicides are not harmful under laboratory conditions then in all likelihood they will not be harmful when used in greenhouses. In order to avoid any harmful effects to natural enemies, it is best to make releases several days following a fungicide application. However, fungicide applications may still decrease host quality, which may indirectly increase parasitoid or predator mortality. For example, parasitoid females may not deposit eggs in unsuitable hosts and predators may avoid consuming hosts that are not a viable food source.

Any differences in natural enemy susceptibility to fungicides may be due to a number of factors including whether the natural enemy is a parasitoid or predator, species of natural enemy, life stage (e.g. egg, larva, pupa and adult) sensitivity, application rate used, timing of application and mode of action of the fungicide. All these factors are complex primarily due to the different interactions that may occur among the aforementioned factors and the variability in natural enemy sensitivity. Furthermore, any harmful effects from fungicide applications may not be associated with the active ingredient, but may be due to the inert ingredients, such as carriers or surfactants. Fungicides applied as a drench to the growing medium may negate any negative effects to natural enemies residing on aboveground plant parts (e.g. leaves and stems).

The compatibility of natural enemies with fungicides is highly variable. Interactions may be associated with the type of fungicide, whether the natural enemy is a parasitoid or predator, and the stage of development. More research is needed to assess the potential compatibility of commercially available natural enemies with fungicides in order to avoid disrupting successful biological control programs.

Leave a Reply

2 comments on “Impact Of Fungicides On Natural Enemies

More From Disease Control...
Feature image The 2015 Perennial Plant Of The Year, Geranium x cantabrigiense ‘Biokovo.’

August 27, 2015

The Perennial Plant Association’s Regional Symposium Will Be This October In Dallas

The Perennial Plant Association plans to hold its Regional Symposium October 5 in Dallas, Texas, in conjunction with the All-America Selections/Home Garden Seed Association's Summer/Fall Summit held October 5 to 8.

Read More
september_grow_rodale institute

August 25, 2015

Hospitals Are Getting Into The Organic Food Business

Growers investing in the organic food movement could serve a growing new area with vegetable transplants and starts, as well as produce, as hospitals begin to prescribe healthy diets and nutrition, and even go so far as to grow their own food. As part of a new phenomenon among progressive hospitals, health professionals are beginning to realize that without health and nutrition, programs and techniques may be done in vain or worse — obsolete. As more patients seeking a healthy diet turn to nutritionists, who recommend sugar-free, alkaline diets to prevent disease and aid in recovery, hospitals recognizing this trend are taking action. St. Luke’s Hospital in Bethlehem, Pa., recently contracted with the nearby Rodale Institute to manage an organic farm, established in 2014. The hospital, part of a six-campus network, aims to provide excellent healthcare, part of which includes educating patients about the benefits of a plant-based, organic diet. […]

Read More

August 21, 2015

Proven Winners Announces Roadshow Events For 2015

Proven Winner's Roadshow Events, held across North America, provide growers and retailers with the opportunity to learn how to grow Proven Winner's newest varieties and receive information about industry trends.

Read More
Latest Stories
r3bv2 disease

May 20, 2015

SAF And AmericanHort Ask Government To Take Ralstonia O…

The Society of American Florists (SAF) and AmericanHort want Ralstonia solanacearum, Race 3, Biovar 2 (R3Bv2) taken off a list of animal and plant diseases that the federal government has determined could be misused as terrorist weapons. SAF and AmericanHort submitted formal comments together on the horticulture industry’s science-backed position on the matter. According to Lin Schmale, SAF’s senior director of government relations, extensive research has proven R3Bv2 does not belong on the government’s list of animal and plant diseases that can be misused as terrorist weapons. Every two years, USDA’s Animal and Plant Health Inspection Service (APHIS) requests a public review of the Select Agent list, asking for comments on whether plant or animal diseases should be taken off the current list or added to it. In the floral industry, R3Bv2 can have a devastating impact on geranium (pelargonium) crops, Schmale says, and both the potato and tomato industries also could be adversely affected by introduction […]

Read More

May 13, 2015

BASF’s Empress Intrinsic Fungicide Is Approved Fo…

BASF’s Empress Intrinsic brand fungicide received supplemental labeling, providing California growers with an effective drench fungicide for disease control and plant health. The supplemental labeling is for use on herbaceous and woody plants in greenhouse, nursery container and field production in California. Empress Intrinsic fungicide provides protection against the four major root and crown disease pathogens: fusarium, phytophthora, pythium and rhizoctonia. Research shows Intrinsic fungicides control the broadest range of ornamental diseases while improving plant resilience to quality and reducing stresses that commonly occur during commercial production, handling and transportation. “More and more growers across the country are discovering the benefits of Empress Intrinisic brand fungicide treatments at propagation for rooted plugs, cuttings and seedlings, and in drench applications on transplants during the production cycle to protect against the major root diseases,“ says Joe Lara, senior product manager for BASF ornamentals. “A BASF fungicide program utilizing Pageant Intrinsic and Empress Intrinsic […]

Read More

April 20, 2015

Three Michigan State University On-Demand Webinars Offe…

The first rule of effective insect and disease control for vegetables is to take action to prevent problems before they occur. But in order to do that, you need to have an effective pest and disease management strategy in place that incorporates best practices to ensure a successful outcome. Michigan State University offers three pest and disease management on-demand webinars that will get you started and keep you on the right track.

Read More

April 15, 2015

BASF’s Pageant Intrinsic Fungicide Registration A…

The state of California has approved the supplemental label registration of Pageant Intrinsic brand fungicide for disease control in the commercial production of greenhouse-grown tomatoes and tomato transplants for the home consumer market.

Read More

March 23, 2015

BioSafe Makes Label Changes To OxiPhos And ZeroTol 2.0

There have been some recent label changes made to the BioSafe Systems product OxiPhos, a systemic bactericide/fungicide that reduces downy mildew spores when tank mixed with ZeroTol 2.0.

Read More

March 23, 2015

Nufarm Fungicides Now Registered For Use On Edible Crop…

Nufarm Americas announced label expansions for two of its fungicides that will provide more pest management options for the ornamental industry. The Cleary 3336 F and EG fungicides are now registered for use across a wider range of edible crops, including select greenhouse vegetables and transplants, herbs and backyard fruit.

Read More

March 11, 2015

Research Gives Clues For Preventing Coleus Downy Mildew

Maintaining awareness of coleus downy mildew is more important than ever to safeguard these attractive plants for reliable garden performance.

Read More
Rose Rosette on Knockout rose, May 2013. Photo credit: Alan Windham, University of Tennessee

March 2, 2015

Rose Rosette Disease Fight Gets A Boost From Government…

In 2014, $4.6 million was awarded through the Farm Bill to tackle rose rosette disease, a devastating pathogen that affects one of the industry’s most important crops.

Read More
Fig 1 Leafy Gall On Leucanthemum Becky

March 2, 2015

How To Prevent Leafy Gall Before You Lose Plants

Leafy gall is a nasty disease that can go undetected until plant damage is done. Take these steps to protect your crops from infection.

Read More

October 6, 2014

EPA Registration Granted To Stockton’s Timorex Go…

Timorex Gold, a broad spectrum fungicide, has received EPA registration in the U.S. for disease control on organic and conventional crops.

Read More

August 5, 2014

Prevention Measures For Impatiens Downy Mildew Start At…

Impatiens downy mildew is a fast-moving disease that can quickly go from bad to worse if conditions are right. In case you missed it, here are some of the highlights from Ann Chase's (Agricultural Consulting) downy mildew update at Cultivate'14.

Read More

July 22, 2014

Spray Coverage Key To Uniform Pest And Disease Control …

Greenhouse growers need to understand proper spray application coverage when applying pesticides and growth regulators to ensure successful treatment results.

Read More
Jeff Rich

July 18, 2014

Removing The Mask Of Phytophthora

Phytophthora is the number one disease of floriculture and nursery crops nationwide. Here are some effective measures growers can take to reduce the occurance of this pathogen, known as "the plant destroyer."

Read More

June 27, 2014

Biocontrols Can Be Highly Effective With Serious Commit…

Biocontrols can be very effective when the greenhouse operator makes a serious commitment to using them for integrated pest control. See how Parkway Gardens has successfully used biocontrols for the last nine years.

Read More

May 1, 2014

Be On The Lookout For Botrytis Blight

Greenhouse growers will be challenged by weather forecasts for cloudy and rainy conditions favoring Botrytis blight. Remembering cultural practices and correct fungicides will help until we get more sunshine.

Read More

April 18, 2014

Growth Products Introduces Improved Packaging For Compa…

Following the suggestion of a user of Companion Biological Fungicide, Growth Products has made improvements to the product's packaging to make it easier to handle and more durable.

Read More

April 8, 2014

Switching To Organic Fertilizer

Growers of short-term vegetable or ornamental crops should have an easier time switching from conventional mineral fertilizers to organic fertilizers.

Read More
Edema om Ivy Geranium. Photo credit: SHS Griffin

March 27, 2014

Geranium Leaf Spots: Is it Rust or Edema?

Damp conditions can lead to both rust and edema in geranium. Here's some advice on scouting and treating each.

Read More