Misconceptions With Controlled Release Fertilizers

Pilon: How do rates vary between incorporation and topdressing?

Passchier: There are two factors involved when speaking about incorporation and topdressing the fertilizer. The first is the potential differences in nutrient availability for the plant when incorporating versus topdressing. The second is the amount of fertilizer that is used when incorporated compared to the topdressing rate.

Let’s remember that CRF fertilizers are released by temperature and research shows that different technologies are affected by the temperature changes around the CRF prill that can alter their expected release. Just think about the temperature fluctuations and moisture consistency in the media versus the temperature fluctuation and moisture consistency on top of the media. In general, there is likely to be less temperature fluctuation and more moisture consistency in the pot than on the surface of the pot.

The surface of the media is subject to greater temperature changes between night to day and from cloudy to sunny days. Growers can expect the release of incorporated fertilizers to be more consistent than fertilizers that are topdressed.

Research from Virginia Polytechnic Institute shows temperature fluctuations from 20°C up to 40°C and back down to 20°C in a 20-hour period results in significant differences in release between the CRF technologies. In another experiment, the CRFs were held at 40°C for three days in a flask and then were subjected to constant temperatures for two weeks resulting in a much more consistent release between CRF technologies. From these experiments, we can correlate that logically the temperatures on the surface fluctuates more quickly than in the soil. So depending on the technology, some fertilizers will release more as topdressing than when incorporated.

What is the correlation between topdress and incorporation rates? To answer this, I’ll refer to a real life situation. A grower used the same nine-month fertilizer on a crop; some plants were topdressed while others had the CRF incorporated. He followed the recommended rates for each application method on the product’s label. The plants that were topdressed were not performing as well as the plants that had CRFs incorporated. It turns out, the recommended topdress rate amounted to half the quantity of fertilizer per pot as applied with incorporation. Even with technology differences, I have never seen a fertilizer that can produce the same crop with the same soil and irrigation practices with only half the fertilizer.

The question then is why is the topdress rate so different than the incorporation rate? Each grower should consider their unique growing conditions, but the answer may have something to do with the above mentioned research. I encourage each grower to become familiar with the rates used for topdressing compared to the rates used for incorporation at their facility. It is important to follow the recommended rates on CRF labels, but growers should understand the differences between these rates and make any necessary modifications. 

Pilon: Just considering the role temperature plays on the release of CRFs, the formulation I choose seems critical to a successful fertility program.

Passchier: It requires an understanding of your production practices and how these practices combined with temperature and leaching influence the release and availability of nutrients from these products.

Pilon: Do I choose a formulation based on an average year or do I pick one based on addressing the fertility needs during the adverse or extreme conditions that are likely to occur?

Passchier: Have you ever seen a normal year? Like many aspects of growing, think the process through. Does it make sense or are you just wishing it works? Growers should understand that there is always a possibility for adverse or extreme conditions. No CRF product can release effectively under all circumstances. A good fertility program will have strategies in place to address these extreme conditions. For example, if unseasonably cool weather has reduced the rate of release, growers can conduct soil tests to determine if the nutrient levels are too low and then apply nutrients through foliar feeding or using water soluble fertilizers. Conversely, with excessive temperatures, growers can monitor the crops, and if the salt levels are climbing, they can reduce them by leaching the crop. CRFs do not replace the need for growers to monitor the nutritional status of their crops and make the necessary adjustments on a regular basis.

Pilon: If a fertilizer specifies a six-month release at 70 degrees, what could I expect at 55 or 85 degrees? How would extended periods of these temperatures affect the release/performance of the fertilizer?

Passchier: Most CRF products provide a table, such as the one shown in Table 1, depicting its longevity at various temperatures. Growers should note that each product and formulation will have its own longevity, even when the NPK values are similar.average temperature is higher than it actually is.same rate, it stands to reason that there will likely not be a sufficient quantity of nutrients left in either of these formulations in the long run.

To best determine a product’s true longevity, the grower needs to know what the average media temperature is throughout production. As mentioned previously, it is difficult to determine the average media temperature. When measuring the media temperature during the summer months, there are often wide temperature fluctuations that often cause growers to assume their average temperature is higher than it actually is.

The temperature at the prill affects the speed at which the fertilizer goes to a semi-soluble state so it can move through the membrane (coating) or the speed at which the prill cracks and lets the fertilizer out so it becomes available plant food.

The bigger question again is how does the rate of the fertilizer affect the feeding of the plant at the temperature you are growing in? When using 10 pounds of 19-5-8 per cubic yard with media temperatures of 60°F, the CRF may possibly have a nine-month longevity, but the amount of fertilizer available to the plant at this temperature will likely be insufficient for plant growth. Conversely, when using 10 pounds of 19-5-8 at 90°F, the amount of fertilizer being released will likely be excessive.

It is not uncommon for competitive CRF products at various longevities to provide similar results at similar rates. For example, I conducted trials using a competitor’s 12- to 14-month product against a five- to six-month formulation with the same amount of product applied per container. In my opinion, both products performed equally well. Achieving equal performance in the short run should cause growers to doubt the longevity of the 12- to 14-month fertilizer and also cause them to question the rate used on the five- to six-month formulation. Logically, if both longevities performed well in the short run at the same rate, it stands to reason that there will likely not be a sufficient quantity of nutrients left in either of these formulations in the long run.

To obtain the best results, growers should utilize formulations that have been developed to fit their geographic area and production temperatures. For example, many growers in the North try to use CRFs developed for production in the South and often do not obtain satisfactory results. CRF formulators can develop blends of fertilizer to match a temperature growing region to help growers optimize the release, longevity and performance for various geographic areas. Unfortunately, when it comes to CRFs, there truly should not be a one-bag-fits-all mentality. 

Pilon: What affect do irrigation practices have on the availability of nutrients?

Passchier: The easy answer is everything! Watering practices greatly affect the availability of nutrients to the plant.

Dr. Ted Bilderback at North Carolina State University has done some great research looking at various aspects of irrigation including application timing, methods of delivery, how much to apply and how the architecture of the plant affects the availability of water to the plant. The factors affecting water availability from irrigation practices also affect the availability of nutrients from CRFs. Most importantly, too much irrigation leaches the fertilizer out of the pot and not enough causes the salt levels to build.

As discussed in this series, there are numerous factors and considerations that affect the release of CRFs. Understanding these principles will allow growers to more successfully implement CRFs into production.

Growers should be careful with which formulations they choose, choose an appropriate longevity, use the rates on the products label, have realistic expectations and conduct trials at their facilities to find a formulation that matches their production requirements.

Leave a Reply

More From Fertilization...
Agro-K

May 19, 2016

Agro-K Expands Distribution In New England Through Partnership With Northeast Agricultural Sales

Agro-K, which manufactures conventional and organic foliar plant nutrients, will distribute its full line of foliar fertilizers and soil biological products through NEAG.

Read More
Fertilizer Rates Feature Image

January 29, 2016

Bioworks Releases New Higher Nitrogen Fertilizer For Ornamental Crops

Verdanta N-Vita 9-4-3 promotes foliar growth and features a slow release process, making nutrients available for a longer period of time.

Read More
Primrose Downward Leaf Roll From Calcium Deficiency

January 11, 2016

How Calcium Plays A Critical Role In Plant Health

Supply vegetables and poinsettias with a healthy amount of calcium to avoid tip and leaf burn.

Read More
Latest Stories
Agro-K

May 19, 2016

Agro-K Expands Distribution In New England Through Part…

Agro-K, which manufactures conventional and organic foliar plant nutrients, will distribute its full line of foliar fertilizers and soil biological products through NEAG.

Read More
Fertilizer Rates Feature Image

January 29, 2016

Bioworks Releases New Higher Nitrogen Fertilizer For Or…

Verdanta N-Vita 9-4-3 promotes foliar growth and features a slow release process, making nutrients available for a longer period of time.

Read More
Primrose Downward Leaf Roll From Calcium Deficiency

January 11, 2016

How Calcium Plays A Critical Role In Plant Health

Supply vegetables and poinsettias with a healthy amount of calcium to avoid tip and leaf burn.

Read More
Sustane Research Greenhouse 2015

January 7, 2016

Fertilizer Manufacturers Aim To Deliver Sustainable Sol…

Industry experts discuss the latest trends to help ensure 2016 is your best year yet.

Read More
Fertilizer Rates Feature Image

August 12, 2015

Selecting Fertilizer Rates For Several Spring Bedding P…

Fertilizing bedding plants can be difficult due to the differing needs of the large variety of plants that we grow. Many operations do not grow enough of any one crop to cater the fertilizer specifically for each crop. Therefore, grouping crops with similar fertilizer requirements and having two to three fertilizer strengths available is a practical way to ensure plants are getting the fertilizer they need. With many new plant varieties on the market, we wanted to conduct a trial at Cornell University to determine best fertilizer rates for several common bedding plant crops. 22 Bedding Plants Studied To Establish Fertilizer Rates Plugs and rooted liners of 22 crops (Table 1) were transplanted into 4-inch (500 mL volume) round pots with a commercial peat/perlite based substrate. The plants were grown in a glass greenhouse at Cornell University during the spring season at a spacing of one plant per square foot. Heating set […]

Read More
NSOrganicPlantFood3-1-1_featured

June 13, 2015

UMASS Fertilizer Trials Recommend Nature’s Source Organ…

In a recent online fact-sheet at its Extension website, the UMass Amherst Center for Agriculture, Food and the Environment lists Nature’s Source Organic Plant Food 3-1-1 as “the best liquid organic fertilizer,” according to Dr. Douglas Cox, Stockbridge School of Agriculture. It is called-out by the Extension after a number of years of studying the use of organic fertilizers for growing commercial greenhouse crops. The trials evaluated traditional water soluble and granular slow-release chemical fertilizers. Dr. Cox recommends Nature’s Source Organic Plant Food 3-1-1 as a liquid fertilizer that is readily available, cost effective, OMRI-listed and with good label directions for greenhouses. He also mentions the ease-of-use in how it mixes well with water and can pass fertilizer injectors. “Nature’s Source is currently the best liquid organic fertilizer,” Cox wrote in his article “Organic Fertilizers – Thoughts on Using Liquid Organic Fertilizers for Greenhouse Plants,” “I have seen no foliar chlorosis yet with this fertilizer. Nature’s source is widely available and a great […]

Read More

January 9, 2015

6 New Fertilizer Products For Healthy Plants

These five products add even more options for delivering nutrients to the root zone.

Read More

January 7, 2015

Fertilizers And The Future

As growers look for new ways to cut costs and conserve resources, fertilizer and equipment companies are offering products that strive to save water, reduce toxic runoff and keep chemicals out of the equation.

Read More

December 31, 2014

Gain Greater Control Of Fertilizer With Automated Ferti…

University researchers look at integrating irrigation and fertilization with the help of water sensors to reduce fertilizer treatments and improve application timing.

Read More

October 30, 2014

Basics & Beyond: Comparing Substrate Fertilizer Ame…

Cornell University researcher determines if substrate-incorporated slow-release fertilizers can be used to replace or reduce the need for liquid fertilizer for four spring crops.

Read More

July 24, 2014

Using Controlled Release Fertilizers To Produce Garden …

Researchers determined whether or not garden mums can be grown with controlled-release fertilizer, and if it reduces fertilizer leaching, as compared with water-soluble fertilizers.

Read More

March 14, 2014

New Foliage Pro Fertilizer Offers Complete Nutrition Pl…

Dyna-Gro Nutrition Solutions has developed a process it says is capable of keeping all 16 essential plant nutrients in solution form.

Read More

January 30, 2014

OASIS Grower Solutions Introduces New One-Bag Hydroponi…

The new 16-4-17 Hydroponic Fertilizer from OASIS Grower Solutions (OGS) is a one-bag solution that replaces two-part systems traditionally used by commercial hydroponic growers. It is specifically formulated for commercial hydroponic production of lettuce, herbs and vegetables.

Read More

December 30, 2013

Fertilizer Changes Growing Mix pH

When considering a fertilizer's influence on media pH, you need to know its acid or basic reaction.

Read More

December 30, 2013

Basics & Beyond: Fundamentals Of Phosphorus Nutriti…

Phosphorus is an essential element, after all.

Read More
Everris Liquid S.T.E.M.

December 30, 2013

New Fertilizers For 2014

New fertilizer products not only deliver optimum nutrition, they also provide for easier application and increased efficiency. Check out these new products to help your operation produce a healthy crop in 2014. Click through on the pages below.

Read More

December 18, 2013

Focus On Fertilizer: Micronutrients And Organics

New fertilizer products are focusing on micronutrients and providing efficient options for organic production.

Read More

August 27, 2013

BioWorks Adds EcoVita To The Verdanta Family Of Biofert…

EcoVita, a homogeneous granular organic fertilizer, has been added to Bioworks Inc.’s Verdanta biofertilizers product family. This fertilizer will be manufactured and supplied to BioWorks by DCM Corporation of Belgium, a producer of natural and organic-based fertilizers in Western Europe. EcoVita is suitable for a wide variety of crops with its gentle release curve including:• Organic fertilization as a base nutrition in potting mixes• Leafy vegetables• Fruiting vegetables (s a top dressing) • Roses and other ornamentals The new fertilizer offers long-lasting and continuous action for 75 to 100 days and contains organic phosphorus (5 percent P2O5) for fast rooting. Nutrients in EcoVita are gradually released by the soil microbes, in addition to producing humus for better rooting and less leaching. EcoVita is OMRI Listed, making it suitable for use in organic production. “We’re pleased to introduce EcoVita 7-5-10 as our organic NPK product to complement our organic products: K-Vita 2-0-20 […]

Read More
[gravityform id="35" title="false" description="false"]