How To Determine The Economic Viability Of LED Lighting

Return on investment for LED lighting is different for every grower. Payback calculations for LED lighting are only useful when they apply specifically to your situation.

The technology of light-emitting diodes (LEDs) has developed substantially just in the last few years. Their efficacy (electrical efficiency) continues to increase, while their cost continues to decrease, which is making them more economically viable in the commercial production of plants. As is the case with many new technologies, the return on investment of LEDs is highly situational and so analyses should be performed using realistic values specific to your operation.

Some lighting companies have developed spreadsheets with payback calculations, which are useful, but only when the values and comparisons are appropriate for your situation. While there are many factors that one should consider when determining whether to make an investment for LED lighting, the most important ones are listed below.

1. Fixture Costs

LEDs are usually more expensive than conventional lamps, and realistic costs should be obtained to purchase and install lighting options that deliver the same intensity to the crop, in µmol∙m–2s–1.

2. Efficacy

This is a lamp-specific value for how efficient a lamp converts electricity into photosynthetic light. A lighting manufacturer should be able to provide you with this value in the unit of µmol per Joule (µmol/J or µmol∙J–1). For high-pressure sodium lamps, colleagues at Utah State University and Rutgers University reported values between 0.9 and 1.7 µmol/J, while for LEDs, values for products in 2016 are around 1.7 to 2.5 µmol/J. Lamps with higher values are more efficient.

3. Electricity Rate

The cost of electricity (kWh) varies widely, and I’ve seen prices as low as 5 cents to as high as 24 cents in the U.S. The potential energy savings of LEDs are obviously greater for growers with high electricity rates.

4. Hours Of Lamp Operation

This value also varies widely depending on the lighting application, crops grown, location, and time of year. Values for indoor crops could be as much as 6,000 hours per year, while for greenhouse production of ornamentals, typical values are 1,200 to 1,500 hours per year. Ornamental crops are usually not lighted from around April 1 until production begins again in December or January.

5. Utility Rebates

In some situations, there are incentives to operate more energy-efficient fixtures. Rebates partly offset the investment cost and make LEDs more economically viable.

6. Electrical Supply

If your supply of electricity is a limiting factor, this can sway the economics of LED lighting rather dramatically if installation of a conventional lamp type requires greater electrical supply.

7. Fixture Longevity And Maintenance

Well-made LEDs can last 25,000 to 50,000 hours before their light output decreases below some value (often below 80% of their initial output). Conventional bulbs burn out quicker; for example, incandescents can last 1,000 to 1,500 hours and halogens about twice that long, while high-pressure sodium lights can last 12,000 to 15,000 hours. Estimate the costs to maintain conventional lamps (bulb cost and labor) in your analysis.

Topics: , , ,

Leave a Reply

More From Lighting...

January 23, 2018

WaterPulse Introduces New Pallet Watering Mat

Pallet Watering Mats have a rubber edge to keep water in and prevent water runoff.

Read More

January 23, 2018

ISO Group Debuting New Cutting and Transplanting Machine at IPM Essen

Because many growers have a limited season for sticking cuttings, ISO Group wanted to develop a machine that can also transplant liners.

Read More

January 20, 2018

New Tech Could Lead to More Efficient Use of Light in the Greenhouse

Working with a $2.45 million USDA grant, a team of University of Colorado Boulder researchers are developing a scalable, cost-effective new greenhouse material.

Read More
Latest Stories

January 20, 2018

New Tech Could Lead to More Efficient Use of Light in t…

Working with a $2.45 million USDA grant, a team of University of Colorado Boulder researchers are developing a scalable, cost-effective new greenhouse material.

Read More

December 17, 2017

Illumitex Expands Horticulture Science Team

The new team members each bring diverse backgrounds and offer lighting expertise from across different segments of the market.

Read More

November 12, 2017

Michigan State Partners With Philips Lighting to Modern…

Several new Philips LED modules were added to Michigan State’s research greenhouses to keep them updated for the newest wave of horticulture students.

Read More
Fluence Bioengineering red lettuce trials - feature

October 30, 2017

Solving Greenhouse Lighting Issues With New Research an…

Changing out your lighting system isn’t quite as easy as replacing a light bulb, but you’ll find the process a lot smoother with this advice from lighting manufacturers and researchers.

Read More
Phillips, Ball Seed Partnership

October 10, 2017

Philips Lighting, Ball Seed Partner on Distribution

Ball Seed will now offer Philips GreenPower LED lighting as a complement to its liners, plugs, unrooted cuttings, seed, and prefinished products.

Read More
LX60 Series (Heliospectra) feature

October 5, 2017

Greenhouse Lighting Suppliers Focused on Efficiency and…

Deciding the best lighting system for your greenhouse — whether you’re growing ornamentals, vegetables, herbs, or something else — can be challenging. Here’s a close look at some of the latest lighting options on the market, and how you can determine whether they are a good fit for your operation.

Read More
John Burns, Philips

October 2, 2017

Former Grower and Horticulturist Joins Philips Lighting…

John Burns, who has worked for large growers including Tagawa Greenhouses and Van Wingerden Greenhouses, will be a Key Account Manager for the western U.S. at Philips.

Read More
Shenandoah Growers - feature

September 30, 2017

How an LED Vertical Growing System Can Enhance Producti…

Shenandoah Growers, a Virginia-based organic herbs producer, is finding that its investment in LEDs has increased production and improved plant quality.

Read More

September 29, 2017

Vertical Farming Looks to Go Mainstream

The University of the District of Columbia is the nation’s only urban land-grant university, so it was a particularly appropriate setting for the Association of Vertical Farming (AVF) to host the AVF Summit 2017 on September 22. The summit was a mix of education, advocacy, and policy discussion about urban agriculture — vertical farming in particular — targeted at finding ways to broaden its adoption in cities around the country and around the world. You’ve probably heard quite a bit in recent months about vertical farming — systems for growing food in stacked layers in completely controlled environments, applying inputs such as light, water, and fertilizer in precise amounts. While there’s some use of these systems in greenhouse settings, in many cases, urban farmers are repurposing abandoned buildings or even shipping containers. Match the availability of these facilities in most large urban areas with big cities’ limited access to fresh, […]

Read More
Valoya Lights

September 18, 2017

3 Steps to Improving the Efficiency of Your LED Systems

Achieving the largest possible optimal light intensity area with the lowest possible number of lights is essential to making an investment in LEDs pay off.

Read More

September 10, 2017

Supplemental Greenhouse Lighting to Produce Seedlings: …

Researchers at Michigan State University see if the results from producing high-quality seedlings with LEDs justify the high capital outlay for installation.

Read More
LumiGrow Vine Crops Guide

August 19, 2017

New Lighting Guide for Vine Crop Growers Now Available

The new guide from LumiGrow is intended to help greenhouse tomato, cucumber, and pepper growers use LED lighting more effectively to maximize profits, boost yields, and increase crop quality.

Read More
LED toplighting, Runkle - feature

August 9, 2017

Lighting Technology Under the Microscope at Production …

Here’s a sneak preview of three lighting trends that will be discussed by Erik Runkle at the Production Technology Conference.

Read More

August 7, 2017

Philips Lighting Signs Partnership Agreement With BWI G…

BWI Grower Technical Sales can now offer its customers a more extensive package of LED solutions, thanks to a new partnership with Philips LIghting that will help bring Philips Horticulture LEDs to greenhouse growers more efficiently.

Read More
Supplemental Lighting at Colorado State

August 2, 2017

Four Must-See Lighting Sessions for the Production Tech…

Educational lighting sessions at the technology conference and tradeshow offer something for everyone, from the novice grower to the seasoned professional.

Read More
Fluence Bioengineering

July 19, 2017

New Videos Highlight Grower Experiences in Shifting to …

Fluence Bioengineering recently produced two videos in which growers in the U.S. and overseas describe why they switched lighting systems.

Read More
Lighting Book Light Management in Controlled Environments

July 11, 2017

Your Chance to Win a Free Copy of “Light Management in …

Each day during Cultivate’17, the Greenhouse Grower/Meister Media Worldwide booth will be giving away one copy of “Light Management in Controlled Environments,” a resource that brings together the latest findings from scientific studies geared toward advancing the science and application of lighting for specialty crop production.

Read More
LumiGrow Pro Series E -feature

May 29, 2017

New LED Options Designed to Boost Greenhouse Plant Qual…

LumiGrow and Philips recently introduced high-efficiency lighting options that are designed to reduce energy costs and improve crop consistency.

Read More