It’s Official: Growers Stink At Pricing Plants

purple-plant-display-in-front-of-containers-eagle-and-frogEvery time a grower goes out of business, his or her peers discuss why it happened. Did a contract fall through? Did the economy in their area crater? Did their quality suffer?

After analyzing the pricing survey Greenhouse Grower sent out earlier this year, I think I’m safe in saying that the most likely culprit for growers shutting their doors is that they don’t charge what they need to charge for their plants.

I realize that is a bold statement, and that most of you know of other circumstances that led directly to a friend losing his or her business.

But I’m guessing that the finishing blow to the business would not have ended things if they had been pricing plants correctly in the years leading up to that final calamity. Let me show you what I mean.

No One Agrees On What A Grower’s “Costs” Include

Most growers calculate prices by using a markup formula (57% do so). A markup formula is deceptively simple: cost multiplied by a number (which typically ranges from 1.6 to 3 for the greenhouse growing industry). But the way growers arrive at those two basic elements varies wildly. First, let’s look at costs.

Based on what growers told us, few agree on what counts as a cost. Among those who spelled out the elements involved in their costs, here were the most likely to be included:
1. Labor
2. Plugs/liners/seeds
3. Tied: Growing Media; Pots; Overhead

Here were some costs cited by several, but that were less common:
1. Tags
2. Time on bench
3. Square footage per plant

And here are costs that weren’t mentioned at all, unless growers lump them into overhead costs:
• Marketing materials (other than tags)
• Fertilizer
• Water
• Shrink
• Plant Growth Regulators (PGRs)
• Pest control

Now, water can be considered an overhead cost, since it’s a utility like electricity. But all of the others are direct costs involved in growing and selling the plant.

Then there’s freight. When we analyzed how retailers calculate plant prices, we found that many of them didn’t treat freight as a cost. They would calculate markup without the cost of freight, then add freight and round everything up to a retail price point, such as $4.99.

Growers are a little better. Of those who mentioned freight, the majority included it in their costs before calculating markup. However, many didn’t mention it at all.

As you can see, we do not have an industry standard for what “cost” includes.

Now let’s turn our attention to the second half of the markup formula, the multiplier.

Again, there’s no industry standard. In retail, there’s more agreement on what the markup should be. The number doesn’t range too widely — from 2x to 2.8x, typically.

But for growers, you’ll find someone who thinks adding 30% to costs (or marking it up by 1.3) is workable. One outlier on the other end of the spectrum multiplies costs by 5.

That Means A Lot Of Costs Aren’t Covered

According to what we learned, a typical grower will take the cost of the plug, growing media, the pot, a percentage of labor and overhead, and multiply it by an average of 2.4 times (the average markup for growers).

Let’s say a single 4-inch annual in that formula comes to $2. That gives the grower $1.17 to play with. But since only some of the costs were used in the formula, he or she now needs to deduct shrink (including any charge backs from pay by scans), PGRs, fertilizer, pest controls , marketing materials, and freight.

Profit disappears quickly in that scenario.

Plus, we don’t know if the costs that are included actually involve the full amount. Take labor. Is the labor cost used only those workers assigned to that crop? Or does it include management and the owner’s compensation? Does it include insurance and benefits? Worker’s compensation?

It’s Not Smart To Follow The Competition

According to the pricing survey, almost a fifth of growers (18%) base their prices on how their competitors are pricing plants. Most want to be in the same ball park. Others try to be a little above (to position themselves as a quality grower) or a percentage below their competitors.

But after looking at how little consensus there is in the industry, this kind of pricing is highly risky.

Think about it. Basing your prices on your competitors’ gives them control over your operation’s health. What if they price plants in a way that ultimately loses money? What if the competitor you aim to keep your prices below is the guy who multiplies the cost of his liner — and no other costs like growing media, tags, labor — by 3? (That’s a real-world example, by the way.)

You will be following your competitor off a cliff into bankruptcy.

Another problem is there are too many unknowns. The competitors may have gotten a deal from their suppliers, or their cost structures are different from yours. And it doesn’t take quality into account. If a crop has a higher quality — it has better, more costly genetics or the plant itself is larger (even if the pot size is the same) — then why price it the same as others?

We found that certain types of growers were more likely to turn to competitive pricing: for example, those growers who do not have a retail division.

It’s Time For The Industry To Get Pricing Right

Greenhouse Grower would like to find a solution to the pricing issue in the industry. We’re seeking ideas and volunteers, and I hope you will join us.

First, we want to find a way to test best practices for different types of businesses, from brokers to growing operations to grower retailers to pure retailers.

We’re not talking about illegal practices like collusion. We’re looking at methods of pricing, from how to evaluate the market value of plants, to which costs need to be covered adequately.

We will also need volunteer businesses who are willing to participate. All of this will be supervised by vetted experts. We turned to a panel of experts for our survey, and will do likewise for any projects we develop. These experts will be available to our volunteer cohorts.

Smart pricing methods are fundamental to our industry’s future. I hope you’ll join us in finding a way forward that makes sense and keeps us financially solvent.

If you’d like to participate, just let us know at gg.edit@meistermedia.com.

Topics: , , ,

Leave a Reply

One comment on “It’s Official: Growers Stink At Pricing Plants

More From Retailing...
Summerwinds Proven Winners display FEATURE

February 17, 2017

Proven Winners Makes Improvements to Its Retailer Certified Training Program for 2017

Understanding the challenges of training new and seasonal staff at independent garden centers, Proven Winners says it is working to equip managers with tools to prepare their employees to better handle customers’ questions and boost their confidence in selling plants this season.

Read More
TPIE 2017 tradeshow floor

February 14, 2017

Trendsetting Products and Ideas From TPIE 2017

If you're a trend watcher, the 2017 Tropical Plant Exhibition, held in Ft. Lauderdale, FL, on January 18-20, was a can't-miss event. In case you missed it, here are a few highlights of the cool products, trends, and ideas seen at the show.

Read More
Plant in box for Amazon feature image

February 6, 2017

Amazon is Coming to Plant Retail; Here’s What it Means for Growers

Plant e-commerce may finally take off soon. The question is, are you ready?

Read More
Latest Stories
Summerwinds Proven Winners display FEATURE

February 17, 2017

Proven Winners Makes Improvements to Its Retailer Certi…

Understanding the challenges of training new and seasonal staff at independent garden centers, Proven Winners says it is working to equip managers with tools to prepare their employees to better handle customers’ questions and boost their confidence in selling plants this season.

Read More
TPIE 2017 tradeshow floor

February 14, 2017

Trendsetting Products and Ideas From TPIE 2017

If you're a trend watcher, the 2017 Tropical Plant Exhibition, held in Ft. Lauderdale, FL, on January 18-20, was a can't-miss event. In case you missed it, here are a few highlights of the cool products, trends, and ideas seen at the show.

Read More
Plant in box for Amazon feature image

February 6, 2017

Amazon is Coming to Plant Retail; Here’s What it …

Plant e-commerce may finally take off soon. The question is, are you ready?

Read More
GrowIt! App Wins Gold At Design100 2014 US Mobile & App Design Awards

February 6, 2017

GrowIt! App Now Offers a Listing of Independent Garden …

The team behind GrowIt!, the app designed to help connect consumers with plants, has launched a new platform that allows independent garden centers to sign up to be a “Garden Shop,” helping new gardeners and community members find garden centers in their specific areas.

Read More
Monrovia Trends Floratourism

January 26, 2017

9 Trends That Could Influence Gardening in 2017

From color-changing conifers to smaller-sized luxury looks, plant experts at Monrovia predict nine trends that will drive consumers to do more gardening this year.

Read More
Bundle Pricing sign at Farmington Gardens

December 23, 2016

It’s Official: Growers Stink At Pricing Plants

The industry’s first pricing survey exposes serious problems in how plants are priced. It’s past time for us to change that.

Read More
Greenhouse Retail Center

December 20, 2016

Top 10 Things I’ve Learned From The Garden Retail…

After covering this industry for close to 20 years, I've picked up a few life lessons along the way.

Read More

December 19, 2016

Smart Retail Tech All Garden Retailers Can Use

Your store may be dark for the winter, but it’s never too early to think about the light of spring and opportunities to improve within your store. Take note of how many national retailers are making capital improvements, altering product assortments and brands, employing more part-time staff, trying new promotional tactics, and modifying services including store hours. Are you thinking of making changes to retain your best customers? Are you considering taking control of some operational costs? Is there a dark side to your retail environment? Retail shopping survives today because it has evolved. Retail has morphed into a blend of displays, services, events, category-specific brands, exclusivity, location and, most importantly, customer satisfaction! It’s more than the thrill of the hunt for a great bargain; it’s an experience. Are you striving to offer a “good to great” retail environment that entices today’s consumer to shop your store? Who will spread […]

Read More

December 13, 2016

The Industry’s Take: How We Can Win More Customer…

Check out these customer winning ideas, which range from smaller, European-type garden to boosting the decorative side of plants to just waiting for Millennials to start buying homes.

Read More

December 12, 2016

How To Merchandise Plants With Pantone’s 2017 Col…

It's great that "Greenery" is Color Of The Year, but how can plant retailers take advantage of a color that most of their products already have? Pantone has an answer for that!

Read More

December 5, 2016

Benary’s Jennifer Calhoun: How We Can Make Plants…

I see one main issue facing our industry in getting more people to buy plants — we assume that the way we used to sell plants is the way millennials will want to buy them. Nothing could be further from the truth. We sell plants in small packs that you plant in a hole in your garden, with a generic label that says “blooms all season.” Millennials don’t have gardens, so they want a plant they can put on their fourth floor apartment balcony, or better yet on a shelf in their living room near a window.  We give them too little information to help them be successful under those circumstances. But what we don’t realize is that if the plant dies, they feel personally responsible for killing another living thing which is so painful that they would prefer not to take the chance a second time. If we sold […]

Read More

December 5, 2016

A Visual Guide To Garden Retail Merchandising

Antje Verstl, a German visual merchandiser who has worked with many high level garden retailers in Europe, has a lot of practical, and inspirational advice on how to transform your plant yard into an exciting place to shop. Take a look at this gallery, and enjoy a visual guide from Verstl. Her book, “Eagle & Frog!,” is now available for purchase by an American market through her website.

Read More

November 29, 2016

How The Industry Is Ensuring Consumer Success With Plan…

Greenhouse Grower RETAILING reached out to growers and suppliers for their ideas on how to attract and keep new plant customers. Here's what they had to say about ensuring gardening success.

Read More

November 29, 2016

Heroes To Hives Seeks Veterans For Beekeeping Training

Michigan State University is bringing together two great causes of our times — supporting vets and boosting pollinators — in its new program aimed at teaching professional beekeeping to former soldiers.

Read More

November 28, 2016

Help Nature-Loving, Gardening-Skeptic Consumers Fall In…

Learn sales and merchandising techniques that will help you bring in new customers in part three of our The Missing Gardener series.

Read More

November 21, 2016

How Graf Growers Uses Bridal Fairs And Food Festivals T…

If garden retailers want to attract customers who don't think local garden stores relate to their lives, they must meet these consumers where they congregate and prove their store's relevance to their lives.

Read More

November 19, 2016

Woman Power! Cater To Your Most Important Plant Retail …

With a whopping 84% of lawn and garden sales being made by female shoppers, it's a woman's world when it comes to plant retailing. Here are some pragmatic tips on how your merchandising can cater to this important demographic.

Read More

November 18, 2016

Customers Expect A Lot From Plants — And From You

In this second article in the Missing Gardener: How To Rebuild Our Customer Base series, learn techniques to show new customers how much they can get out of plants.

Read More