Pine Wood Chips As An Alternative To Perlite In Greenhouse Substrates: Fertilization Requirements

In our last article (June 2014 issue), we discussed our research findings evaluating the activity and efficacy of plant growth regulator drench applications to a substrate amended with 20 percent pine wood chip (PWC) aggregates. To continue with our theme in highlighting the use of PWC aggregates (Figure 1) as an alternative to replace perlite in greenhouse substrates (Figure 2), this article will focus on evaluating the fertility requirements.



Proper Fertilization Can Minimize Nutrient Loss

While communicating with growers around the United States, it is all too common to hear them express a level of uncertainty about the use of wood-based substrates or components as an alternative for peat and pine bark. In the past, the perception and reluctance to use wood-based materials in growing mixes has derived from stories concerning the use of sawdust and resulting nitrogen (N)-deficient crops.

Since the initial concept to use saw dust as a substrate or substrate component, numerous universities have developed techniques to process wood, thus yielding wood components that have been intensively studied and reported as successful. However, consistent with previous reports about sawdust and crop health, researchers observed that plant growth in substrates composed of wood, or large portions of wood, had a tendency to become N–deficient as a result of high rates of N immobilization.

Such reports evaluated and compared the plant growth of multiple floriculture and nursery plants grown in 100 percent wood-based substrates to traditional peat or pine-bark-based substrates. Results of these studies indicated similar or minor differences in growth if plants were irrigated and fertilized more often in the 100 percent wood substrates, compared to peat or pine-bark-based substrates.

Generally, reduced plant growth in wood-based substrates is only a concern when fertility levels (primarily N) are below optimal recommended levels for plant growth and development. For example, work by Wright et al., (2008) found that ‘Baton Rouge’ chrysanthemums grown in a 100 percent wood-based substrate required an additional 100 ppm N, compared to plants grown in a peat-lite substrate composed of 45 percent peat, 15 percent perlite, 15 percent vermiculite and 25 percent bark (by volume).

Therefore, to counteract microbial N immobilization from a wood-based substrate or a substrate containing wood, growers must use a fertilization program that will supply additional nutrients needed by plants and minimize nutrient waste and loss from leaching. However, to our knowledge there is no information available regarding fertility recommendations for optimal plant growth in peat-based substrates amended with PWC.

Perlite Versus PWC Aggregates In Peat-Based Substrates

At North Carolina State University, we have developed a wood processing technique that produces bilocular and non-fibrous PWC aggregates as a perlite replacement. We investigated peat-based substrates formulated with 10 percent, 20 percent or 30 percent perlite or PWC aggregates. However, based on conversations with growers to determine the most common substrate formulation, we will present and discuss our findings of the substrates amended with either 20 percent perlite or PWC aggregates (Figure 3).

We prepared our peat-based substrates by amending either 20 percent perlite or PWC aggregates (by volume) and adjusted substrate pH to 5.8. Two plant species were trialed: ‘Profusion Orange’ zinnia and ‘Moonsong Deep Orange’ African marigolds (Figure 4, A and B). For zinnia, seeds were double sown directly into the substrates and after six days, seedlings were thinned to one seedling per pot, whereas the African marigold plugs were transplanted into the prepared substrates.

At each irrigation event, drip rings (Figure 5) were used to fertilize each plant with either a constant liquid feed rate of 100, 200 or 300 ppm N, provided by equal N combinations of Peters Professional 20N-10P-20K Peat-Lite Special containing 8.1 percent ammonium (NH4-N) and 11.9 percent nitrate (NO3-N) and Ultrasol Cal-Mag 13N-0.9P-10.8K Water Soluble Seedling Plus containing 0.3 percent NH4-N and 12.7 percent NO3-N. Using the Pour-Thru method, we extracted and measured substrate solution pH and electrical conductivity (EC) with a handheld Hanna pH meter on a weekly basis for six weeks. For each species at the first sign of anthesis, a final growth index (GI) [(height + widest width + perpendicular width) ÷ 3] and plant dry mass were determined.

Fertility Recommendations For PWC-Amended Substrates

Results of our study indicate substrate solution EC levels and pH values as recommended by Whipker, et al., (2001) can be achieved for optimal plant growth in PWC-amended substrates. At 200 ppm N, zinnia substrate solution EC was similar for both perlite- and PWC-amended substrates. For zinnia plants grown in perlite-amended substrates, recommended EC levels were maintained from 14 to 42 days after planting (DAP), while PWC-amended substrates maintained recommended EC levels from 14 to 49 DAP. A steady decline of EC levels from 14 to 49 DAP was observed when plants were fertilized with the insufficient N rate of 100 ppm N, compared to a steady increase in EC levels when plants received 300 ppm N.

Substrate solution EC of marigold plants was not influenced by aggregate type but rather by increasing N rate and followed a similar trend to the zinnias. For both species, substrate solution pH was influenced by increasing N rate and followed the normal response of decreasing pH with increasing N rate.

The recommended substrate solution pH 6.2 to 6.5 for both zinnia and marigold plants, was achieved in both substrates, when fertilized at 100 ppm N. The substrate solution pH of both species did not reach recommended pH values when fertilized with 200 or 300 ppm N. Maximum plant growth for zinnia (Figure 6) and marigold (Figure 7) was obtained when plants received 200 and 300 ppm N, respectively, and overall maximum shoot dry weight of both species, was determined when plants were fertilized with 200 ppm N.

Based on the results of this study and visual quality of plants grown in PWC-amended substrates, it is recommended that plants be fertilized with a water soluble fertilizer between 100 to 200 ppm N, without any additional N needed for optimal plant growth. The absence of significant nitrogen tie-up (immobilization) in substrates containing 30 percent PWC (or less) is most likely the result of the large particle size of the PWC aggregates. The PWC particles are larger and have less surface area than wood substrate components that have been previously developed/processed and evaluated in the past by researchers in the US. The uniqueness of the particle size of PWC is not fibrous like previous pine tree substrate materials, hence the lack of degradation and nitrogen depletion observed during greenhouse production.

When substituting PWC for perlite in greenhouse substrates, no adjustments to cultural practices or production of zinnia and marigold plants are needed. However, frequent monitoring of substrate solution EC and pH is recommended, as well as matching a suitable fertility program to the crop. The fertility recommendation provided here can maintain proper substrate solution EC levels and pH values, provide maximum plant growth and reduce excess N applied to zinnia and marigold plants grown in substrates amended with 20 percent PWC (by volume).


Whipker, B.E., J.M. Dole, I.J. Cavin, J.L. Gibson, W.C. Fonteno, P.V. Nelson, D.S. Pitchey and D.A. Bailey. 2001. Plant root zone management. N.C. Community Flower Grower’s Association, Raleigh, N.C.

Wright, R.D., B.E. Jackson, J.F. Browder, and J.G. Latimer. 2008. Growth of chrysanthemum in a pine tree substance requires additional fertilizer. HortTechnology 18:111-115.


Leave a Reply

More From Uncategorized...

July 1, 2015

Rough Brothers Is Acquired By Gibraltar Industries

RBI Solar Inc., Rough Brothers Manufacturing Inc. and affiliates have been acquired by Gibraltar Industries, a manufacturer and distributor of products for residential and industrial markets, for $130 million. Capitalizing on its 80 years of design-build experience and leadership as the largest greenhouse manufacturer in North America, Ohio-based RBI has established itself during the past five years as North America’s fastest-growing provider of photovoltaic (PV) solar racking solutions. The transaction will enable Gibraltar to leverage its expertise in structural metals manufacturing and materials sourcing to meet global demand for solar racking solutions. The company also announced that it anticipates its second-quarter 2015 financial results will be in line with its previous expectations. “Acquiring RBI is an important step in the transformation of Gibraltar into a company with a higher rate of growth and best-in-class financial metrics,” says Gibraltar CEO Frank Heard. “This acquisition directly aligns with key end markets and product platforms […]

Read More

June 30, 2015

Opportunities Abound For Women In Horticulture, Says Dosatron International’s Lela Kelly

My love for horticulture goes back to my grandparents who were farmers in upstate New York. My family’s involvement in agriculture left a lasting impression that has spanned decades, and still drives my passion for our industry today. I started my career in horticulture when I owned a greenhouse, nursery and garden center in Sayville, Long Island, N.Y. We specialized in ground cover production, later branching out to producing perennials and bedding plants.     I then went onto wholesale hard goods distribution. In the 1980s, I was the first woman salesperson on Long Island. What an eye opener that was! New York is a very special place, different from anywhere else in the country. You cannot imagine how difficult it was walking into greenhouses and nurseries as a woman, in a man’s world. Luckily, I grew up in New York City in an Italian family, who taught me great […]

Read More
Medal of Excellence Award

June 30, 2015

Get To Know The 9 Variety Finalists For Editor’s Choice And Industry’s Choice Awards

Greenhouse Grower‘s Evening Of Excellence reception is rapidly approaching. Here, you can learn more about the varieties that are finalists for the Medal Of Excellence Editor’s Choice and Industry’s Choice Breeding Awards. Thank you to the 2015 sponsors of Greenhouse Grower‘s Medal Of Excellence Awards, Landmark Plastic, Nufarm and Stockosorb. Editor’s Choice Asclepias ‘Monarch Promise’ (Hort Couture) Basil ‘Balsamic Blooms’ (EuroAmerican Propagators) Celosia ‘Dragon’s Breath’ (Sakata Seed) Dianthus Jolt Series (PanAmerican Seed) Salvia Grandstand Series (Green Fuse Botanicals) Scabiosa ‘Kudos Pink’ (Hishtil Nurseries) Industry’s Choice Basil ‘Balsamic Blooms’ (EuroAmerican Propagators) Bidens BeeDance Series (Suntory Flowers) Celosia ‘Dragon’s Breath’ (Sakata Seed) Dianthus Jolt Series (PanAmerican Seed) Lobelia ‘Starship Deep Rose’ (Kieft Seed) Vinca Valiant Series (PanAmerican Seed)     Join us Monday, July 13 in Ballroom 2 at the Columbus Convention Center to find out which varieties will receive the coveted awards. The reception begins at 5:15 p.m. and the ceremony […]

Read More
Latest Stories
2015 Top 100 Growers 75

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Harts Nursery (No. 75)

Learn more about Harts Nursery, No. 75 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 71

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Van de Wetering Greenhouses (No. …

Learn more about Van de Wetering Greenhouses, No. 71 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 71

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Welby Gardens Co./Hardy Boy Plant…

Learn more about Welby Gardens Co./Hardy Boy Plants-Hardystarts, No. 71 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 65

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Corso’s Perennials (No. 65)

Learn more about Corso's Perennials, No. 65 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 64

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Bob’s Market And Greenhouse…

Learn more about Bob's Market And Greenhouses, No. 64 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 61

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Armstrong Growers (No. 61)

Learn more about Armstrong Growers, No. 61 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 59

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Nash Greenhouses (No. 59)

Learn more about Nash Greenhouses, No. 59 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Willoway Nurseries (No. 53)

Learn more about Willoway Nurseries, No. 53 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 51b

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Henry Mast Greenhouses/Masterpiec…

Learn more about Henry Mast Greenhouses/Masterpiece Flower Co., No. 51 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
2015 Top 100 Growers 51a

May 1, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Rockwell Farms (No. 51)

Learn more about Rockwell Farms, No. 51 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top Growers list.

Read More
Top 100 Growers No. 8

April 13, 2015

2015 Top 100 Growers: Color Point (No. 8)

Learn more about Color Point, No. 8 on Greenhouse Grower's 2015 Top 100 Growers List.

Read More

March 31, 2015

Manufacturers Are Taking Biologicals To The Next Level

Through acquisitions and new products, many crop protection companies are making firm commitments to the future of the biocontrols industry.

Read More
Aquaponics At Brogue Hydroponics

March 30, 2015

Aquaponics Is Making A Splash At Brogue Hydroponics

The owners of Brogue Hydroponics explain why they expanded into aquaponics, and how the shift has helped them uncover a new market opportunity.

Read More

February 11, 2015

Benchmarks: Find Your Game-Changer

Refuse to accept the status quo in your organization. Explore possibilities until you find what works best for your company.

Read More
Lychnis 'Petitie Jenny'

February 2, 2015

Variety Showcase: A Dainty Debutante

Lychnis flos-cuculi ‘Petite Jenny’ is a dwarf form of the popular Blooms of Bressingham® variety Lychnis ‘Jenny.’ This double-flowered little beauty was discovered by Paul Gooderham at Bressingham in a patch of its parent, ‘Jenny.’ ‘Petite Jenny’ produces masses of large, fluffy, double flowers like ‘Jenny,’ but with a more diminutive habit. The species goes by the common name “ragged robin,” but there’s nothing unkempt about ‘Petite Jenny’. An easy-to-grow, tidy little plant, it is suitable for any sunny or lightly shaded border and is also a good container candidate. Garden Performance Mass of bright pink double blooms beginning in mid-May. Sterile blooms provide a longer flowering period Erect, leafy flowering stems Forms compact, bushy clumps just 14” tall with an 18” spread Attracts bees, butterflies, hummingbirds and is deer-resistant Ideal for containers, front of borders, informal cottage gardens and as cut flowers’ Sun or part shade USDA Hardiness Zones 5 to […]

Read More

January 20, 2015

Register Now For Biocontrols 2015 Conference & Trad…

The first-ever conference, sponsored by Meister Media Worldwide and the Biopesticide Industry Alliance, March 3-5, offers hands-on, real-world technical advice on biocontrols to help you craft a “softer” pest management program focused on resistance management, MRLs and results.

Read More

October 6, 2014

Fighting Fall Foliar Disease: The Best Defense Is A Goo…

Managing foliar diseases starts with evaluating the greenhouse environment. Virginia Brubaker, GGS Pro Technical support supervisor for Griffin Greenhouse Supplies, shares some ways you can defend against fall foliar diseases.

Read More

July 11, 2014

Highlights From The 2013 USDA Floriculture Crops Summar…

The U.S. Department of Agriculture released its 2013 Floriculture Crops Summary in June. Here are some of the main findings.

Read More