Fact Sheet: The Value Of Neonicotinoids To Turf And Ornamental Professionals

Summary

An extensive study of the diverse turf and ornamental industry (The Green Industry) reveals that neonicotinoids are the top-rated products used by professionals to control their most important pests in greenhouses, landscapes, lawns, nurseries and trees. Economists surveyed 750 turf and ornamental professionals to assess their pest management practices and found that more than 90 percent listed performance and safety factors as their leading considerations when selecting an insecticide. Professionals fear the loss of neonicotinoids would reduce the quality of their plants and services, increase costs and negatively impact their ability to manage pest resistance.

Background

  • The multi-billion dollar turf and ornamental industry grows, distributes and provides retail and customer services for flowers, ornamental plants, trees and managed landscapes.
    Insect pests cause millions of dollars of damage to homes and structures, damage or destroy urban environments and cause medical problems associated with bites, stings or allergies.
    The environmental benefits of managed landscapes include absorption of pollutants, carbon sequestration, prevention of soil erosion and storm runoff, increased wildlife habitats, temperature moderation and noise pollution.
  • Managing pests across diverse geographies requires careful management and the use of Integrated Pest Management (IPM) practices to prevent pest resistance and maintain beneficial insects.
  • Because of the close proximity of treated plant materials with the consumer, human and pet safety is a primary concern among service providers.

Methodology

  • Turf and ornamental businesses included in this survey were categorized as Greenhouse, Landscape, Lawns, Nursery and Trees.
  • Four national professional associations were surveyed and 750 responses were received:

 

Industry OrganizationRepresented MembersResponses
AmericanHortnurseries and greenhouses, landscape, distributors, retailers351
PLANETlawn care and landscape145
Society of American Floristsfloral growers, retailers, importers, suppliers50
Tree Care Industry Associationcommercial tree care firms and affiliates204

Researchers used an online survey of 12 baseline questions to capture data from industry professionals, followed by sub-questions, to allow for analysis across all industry segments.
Respondents included some who reported they do not use any insecticides in their business.

Results

Across all segments, respondents identified the main focus of their business as trees (25 percent), greenhouse (24 percent), lawn (19 percent), nursery (16 percent) and landscape ornamentals (16 percent).
When asked to rate the importance of different variables in choosing an insecticide, more than 90 percent of all respondents listed performance (protecting plant quality and consistency of pest control) and safety (to applicators and customers) factors as their leading considerations.
59 percent of all respondents included a neonicotinoid as one of their top-three “most used” insecticides. On a square footage, or plants treated basis, they are the primary insecticide used in each professional segment.

 

"Most Used" Insecticides (based on sq. ft. or plants treated)*

Industry SegmentInsecticide ClassPercent of Total Products Used
GreenhouseNeonicotinoid
Avermectin
Pyrethroids
26.4
13.3
6.7
NurseryNeonicotinoid
Avermectin
Pyrethroids
28.6
18.1
11.0
LawnNeonicotinoid
Avermectin
Pyrethroids
43.0
38.6
4.1
Landscape OrnamentalsNeonicotinoid
Avermectin
Pyrethroids
37.4
22.9
7.9
TreesNeonicotinoid
Avermectin
Pyrethroids
33.7
25.4
13.0
*Does not include chemical products identified as "unknown"

If Neonicotinoids Were No Longer Available

  • When asked what they would do if neonicotinoids were no longer available, 73 percent of all respondents said there are either “no acceptable alternatives” or “not enough acceptable alternatives” to neonicotinoids to meet their pest management needs.

 

Acceptability Of Alternative Insecticides If Neonicotinoids Were No Longer Available

Acceptable Alternatives to Neonicotinoid InsecticidesGreenhouseNurseryLawnLandscape OrnamentalsTrees
None or not enough65%79%84%67%76%
Enough or more than enough35%21%16%33%24%

 

  • Across all segments, 55 percent of all professionals noted that the loss of neonicotinoids would reduce income for their business and estimated the loss to be about 15 percent.
  • The greatest financial impact due to a loss of neonicotinoids was in the lawn segment, where 68% anticipated a loss of income, and the lowest impact was in landscape ornamentals, where 43 percent anticipated a loss of income.
  • The major reasons given for a loss in income were related to increased costs associated with using alternative insecticides and the impact on the quality of plant products or services.
  • Without neonicotinoids, 78 percent of the professionals said costs would increase due to more frequent applications or greater amounts of alternative insecticides being applied.
  • Two-thirds of respondents indicated that a loss of neonicotinoids would result in an increase in time associated with additional applications, record keeping or training.
  • In addition to cost increases, 45 percent of professionals cited a decreased ability to control invasive pests and 44 percent identified a decrease in the quality of pest management services supplied.
  • Almost half (47 percent) of the professionals stated that there would be a decrease in customer satisfaction if neonicotinoids were not available.

 

Anticipated Impact Of Losing Neonicotinoids On Business Operations

 NegativeNo ChangePositiveDon't know
Costs (application frequency or amounts applied)78%16%1%5%
Costs (time spent treating, training & record keeping)67%28%1%4%
Ability to control invasive pests45%29%16%11%
Ability to manage pest resistance44%29%14%13%
Quality of plant products or pest management services44%32%14%9%
Customer satisfaction with products or services47%32%10%12%

 

  • From an environmental perspective, losing neonicotinoids would represent a significant setback in managing pest resistance, as these products are important to IPM programs.
  • Respondents were asked to identify the top three insects for which control would be difficult without neonicotinoids:

 

GreenhouseNurseryLawnsLandscape OrnamentalsTrees
Aphids 33%Aphids 35%Grubs 68%Borers 38%Borers 36%
Whitefly 27%Whitefly 26%Chinchbug 14%Hard Scale 19%Hard Scale 23%
Thrips 24%Thrips 13%Billbug 10%Leafminer 16%Aphids 23%

 

  • Other pests that were frequently mentioned include soft-scale insects, psyllids, mealybugs, mole crickets and craneflies.
  • If neonicotinoids were not available, respondents indicated they would shift primarily to pyrethroid and organophosphate insecticides.
  • Overall, professionals value neonicotinoids because of their performance and their environmental and safety profile. They offer systemic properties, exhibit long-term efficacy, and provide lower risks to the applicators, customers and their pets than some alternatives.
  • Neonicotinoids are valued because they address the most important concerns of T&O professionals – plant quality, consistent pest control and safety to applicators and customers.
  • Most turf and ornamental professionals indicated that losing neonicotinoids would increase their operational costs, reduce the quality of their plants and services, reduce customer satisfaction and negatively impact their ability to manage pest resistance.

Report References

The Value of Neonicotinoid Insecticides in Turf and Ornamentals: The Value of Neonicotinoids to Turf and Ornamental Professionals.
This report is one of a series that will be released over the next few months as part of a comprehensive evaluation of the economic and societal benefits of neonicotinoid insecticides in North America. The research was conducted by AgInfomatics, a consulting firm of independent agricultural economists and scientists, and jointly commissioned and sponsored by Bayer CropScience, Syngenta and Valent U.S.A. All reports will be published online.

Growing Matters is a coalition of organizations and individuals committed to scientific discourse on the stewardship, benefits and alternatives of neonicotinoid insecticides in North America. Bayer CropScience, Syngenta and Valent U.S.A. Corporation are leading this coalition with support from Mitsui Chemicals Agro, Inc.

Visit the Growing Matters website for the latest information, reports, videos and infographics on the benefits of neonicotinoid insecticides.

Topics:

Leave a Reply

One comment on “Fact Sheet: The Value Of Neonicotinoids To Turf And Ornamental Professionals

  1. Get the science right. Neonics are better than alternative insecticides. Check how well the European trial without neonics is doing. Huge crop losses. These tools as noted in the article are important and emotion needs to be backed out of the discussion.

More From Crop Inputs...
Adult Thrips feature

February 20, 2018

Thrips Causing Headaches? New Research Shows Bio-based IPM Offers the Best Control

Dr. Rose Buitenhuis will present practical knowledge for growers to implement immediately during Biocontrols West Conference in San Diego, March 7-9.

Read More

February 18, 2018

Why Biochar Might Eventually Replace Peat Moss

In a recent study, researchers from the University of California, Davis investigated biochar as an alternative to peat moss.

Read More

February 15, 2018

Boxwood Blight, Seed Your Future Among Topics Receiving HRI Research Funding in 2018

The Horticultural Research Institute recently announced the 10 research projects that will receive funding in 2018 to investigate challenges and solutions in production, pest management, environmental stewardship, and business and marketing.

Read More
Latest Stories
Jose-Milan-Bayer

February 11, 2018

Bayer Has New Turf and Ornamentals Global Market Manage…

Jose Milan will be focused on helping growers deal with regulatory issues, while promoting the environmental benefits the ornamentals industry offers.

Read More
Belchim Crop Protection

January 24, 2018

Engage Agro Now Doing Business as Belchim Crop Protecti…

For more than 30 years, Belchim has been providing agricultural customers internationally, including greenhouse growers, with more than 100 well-known products.

Read More
cuttings-facility

December 13, 2017

New Webinars Address Effective Propagation Techniques

e-Gro, an online clearing house for alerts about greenhouse disease, insect, environmental, physiological, and nutritional disorders, recently posted two new propagation-related webinars on YouTube.

Read More

December 4, 2017

Raker-Roberta’s Young Plants Debuts as Roberta’s Finali…

On December 1, Eric Wallien of Roberta’s Inc. in Waldron, IN, officially purchased C. Raker & Sons in Litchfield, MI. The new identity of the company is now Raker-Roberta’s Young Plants, according to a Dec. 1 letter to Raker’s customers, suppliers, and business partners from Vice President Susie Raker-Zimmerman. “There have been minimal changes in management and we will be providing the same products and services on which we have built our reputation in the industry,” Raker-Zimmerman said in the letter, which also announced the name change and new logo. The sale of C. Raker & Sons was announced in September . A series of events affecting Raker’s financial situation caused the need for the operation to find an alternate solution. Roberta’s had been a customer of Raker’s since 2011, and the fourth generation, family owned grower-retailer was a fan of Raker’s commitment to quality. The agreement to purchase C. […]

Read More
Biocontrols in a Greenhouse

November 27, 2017

4 Opportunities to Educate Yourself on IPM Practices in…

The Michigan State University Extension floriculture team has developed four greenhouse integrated pest management sessions that will be presented at the 2017 Michigan Greenhouse Growers Expo in Grand Rapids, MI.

Read More
Parasitized aphid mummies, ladybird beetle larvae

November 11, 2017

OHP Announces Two New Ornamental Pest Management Tools

OHP recently added two new crop protection tools to its profile of biosolutions: a biological insecticide, and an ornamental fungicide.

Read More
OHP Biosolutions

September 26, 2017

OHP Acquired by AMVAC, But Will Continue to Operate As …

AMVAC has acquired OHP and its chemical and biological crop protection solutions for the greenhouse and nursery markets. The deal will close in early October, and there will be no changes to staff, products, or operations.

Read More
Hydroponics Michigan State Web

September 14, 2017

Hydroponic and Aquaponics Growers Face Possible Loss of…

The National Organic Standards Board is considering recommending that USDA revoke the ability for hydroponic, aquaponic, aeroponic, and other container-based growing methods to be certified organic, according to an update from growers at Upstart University.

Read More
Aphids

July 7, 2017

New Tools for Your Crop Protection Arsenal in the Green…

Over the past few months, crop protection companies have developed several new products designed to help you manage a wide range of insect and disease pests. Here’s a look at some of them.

Read More
Yellow Stick Card for thrips

July 5, 2017

Tips From a Top 100 Grower for Effective Thrips Control

A combination of conventional materials and biologicals can help provide season-long management of thrips in hanging baskets.

Read More
Primula acaulis, Botrytis, Disease, Griffin Greenhouse Supplies

May 30, 2017

BioWorks Launches New Biofungicide for Botrytis Control

BotryStop was developed for the control of pathogens such as Botrytis, Sclerotinia, and Monilinia in several crops, including ornamentals.

Read More
Adult Aphidoletes in web - Feature

May 27, 2017

How to Overcome Biocontrol Challenges by Thinking Outsi…

With a little creative thinking and adjustments to your strategy, you can overcome your greenhouse biocontrol challenges.

Read More
Cannabis Seedling

May 20, 2017

Biocontrols: A Practical Option for Cannabis

With limited options for chemical pest control, cannabis growers are incorporating biocontrols into their integrated pest management programs. More education will cement this solution as a viable option in this emerging market.

Read More
Christmas Cactus

May 18, 2017

How to Increase Branching and Flower Bud Production of …

Based on research completed at North Carolina State University, here are some methods for increasing branching and flower bud production of Christmas Cactus (Schlumbergera bridgessii).

Read More
Herbicide Drift in the Greenhouse

May 15, 2017

How to Identify and Mitigate Herbicide Contamination in…

Herbicides applied off-site or within the greenhouse can significantly damage ornamental and edible crops. Beth Scheckelhoff, an Extension Educator for Greenhouse Systems at The Ohio State University, provides some examples and basic recommendations for mitigating and preventing herbicide contamination and injury in the future.

Read More

May 4, 2017

Bayer Altus Update: Neonic Insect Control Alternative N…

Altus, a butenolide class insecticide with the active ingredient flupyradifurone, will be available beginning May 1, and is labeled for greenhouse and nursery use on ornamental plants, vegetable transplants, and indoor vegetable production.

Read More
Bumblebees

May 2, 2017

Pollinator Update: The Bumblebee on the Endangered List…

With plenty of attention being placed on pollinator health around the country and the world, here’s what you need to know.

Read More
Florikan Space Technology Hall of Fame

April 25, 2017

Out-Of-This-World Plant Nutrition: Fertilizer Company I…

NASA scientists are growing vegetables on the International Space Station using Florikan’s controlled release fertilizer.

Read More