Maintaining consistent air flow in the greenhouse is critical to producing healthy plants. However, there are different theories as to how to achieve an optimal air flow system.
“For many years, air speed was the goal,” says Kurt Becker, Executive Vice President – Commercial Products for The Dramm Corporation. “Unfortunately, speed is difficult to keep consistent and hard to maintain.”
The true goal of any air distribution system in the greenhouse, Becker says, should be to homogenize the air, as plants can transpire more evenly and efficiently when the microclimate around the plant is removed.
Here, Becker outlines four strategies for proper air flow. These strategies include the type of fans you’re using, and how they are positioned within the greenhouse.
Series Layout vs. Parallel Layout
European greenhouse growers tend to adopt two types of fan positioning approaches:
• Parallel (all fans are placed at one end of the greenhouse, and as air travels across the greenhouse, it circulates from the upper air to the lower air, creating a loop)
• Series (fans are arranged in a pattern starting from one side of the greenhouse and moving in)
The problem with the parallel layout, Becker notes, is that it is based on the greenhouse structures all being the same size, and on flat land.
“Here in the U.S., we have more hills than they do in Holland, where the parallel system was developed,” he says. “A slope means heat gathers at the highest point, and the lowest point near the greenhouse stays cool.”
Several years ago, Becker and his team met with a supplier in the livestock industry who was promoting the series layout.
“We liked the idea, although there was an issue with the type of fans they were using,” Becker says.
Shrouded Fans vs. Basket Fans
The livestock producer Becker observed was using basket fans, which throw air in a much wider pattern, often impacting the crop below with varying direction and speed, and reducing uniformity. These wider patterns minimize forward momentum, as the air from the first fan in a series often conflicts with the air from the second fan, as the direction is non-linear. This results in uneven air flow and makes the second fan in the series work harder to move air forward.
“It’s a suitable design for livestock, because a pig can just move to where the air is circulating,” Becker says. “That’s not the case with a plant.”
Becker’s team at Dramm combines the series layout with a shrouded fan concept. Shrouded fans give the same amount of force as basket fans, but with a more direct blast of air.
“The air moves linearly in a single direction down the bay, creating a larger width as it travels,” Becker says. “As the air moves forward, it will train the air around it to follow that same pattern.”
Shrouded fans in a series work together to carry the air in a forward direction, reducing the energy required, and creating a more even, stable air flow. Additionally, the use of shrouds creates an intake, as well as an exhaust, something that unshrouded fans don’t have, Becker says. This intake can help keep the forward momentum going by pulling air in the desired direction. As a result of the increased distances and lower speed requirements of momentum-based systems, facilities need fewer fans and use less electricity.
Speed-Based Air Flow vs. Momentum-Based Air Flow
As recently as a few years ago, horizontal air flow (HAF) was thought of solely in terms of velocity. However, when the air in a greenhouse is being moved internally, velocity can be very hard to measure. In fact, bursts of erratic speed can cause instability in temperature and climate that can affect plant growth.
“A common misconception is that plants need to be moving for the air flow system to be doing its job,” Becker says. “While this will certainly help remove the microclimate, high-speed, turbulent air flow is often inconsistent, which means that some crops will get more air movement than others, causing irregular transpiration.”
Because of this, momentum is replacing velocity as the desired result in greenhouse air flow systems. The aim is to generate a stable mass of air that slowly builds momentum as it travels through the greenhouse.
“The momentum of air may take a while to get established, but it doesn’t stop moving for a while,” Becker says. “If you can gently move a whole column of air evenly, the fans will cover all corners of the greenhouse. In doing so, you will encourage even transpiration across the greenhouse, removing localized vapor pressure.”
Horizontal vs. Vertical Air Flow
Interest in vertical fans has increased a great deal in recent years. These fans can homogenize the air vertically, removing temperature stratification from top to bottom. Vertical fans can also create movement at the crop level, helping with transpiration and the elimination of microclimates near the plants.
However, the main problem with vertical fans in plant growth is the same as with speed-based fans, Becker says.
“Often, these systems do not homogenize the climate across the entire growing area as well as they do vertically, near the fan,” Becker says. “Additionally, conflict or buffers between fan patterns can cause inconsistency across the crop.”
Horizontal fans, on the other hand, help humidity move evenly around the greenhouse facility, while also promoting transpiration.
A Chance to Learn More
Dramm has produced a number of whitepapers discussing topics related to its primary businesses, including one on momentum-based air flow for optimal plant growth. The whitepapers are available for free download and offer information to growers to help them make informed decisions. Learn more at Dramm.com/whitepapers.